The (Im)Moral Man - An Experimental Study on Empathy, Hypocrisy and Cooperation

How to cite

Buchholz, Margarita. 2017. "The (Im)Moral Man - An Experimental Study on Empathy, Hypocrisy and Cooperation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002317. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2317-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Margarita Buchholz*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002317
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2317-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-06-01 – 2017-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2317

Abstract

We study internal vs. external motivation with regard to helping behavior. Batson (1987, 1991) has formulated the “empathy-altruism hypothesis” (EAH). It claims that empathic concern felt for a person in need produces an altruistic motivation to relieve that need. However, research has neglected the motivational mechanisms whereby empathetic concern elicits help giving. For example, feeling empathetic concern for another person could potentially trigger external pressure to help others (e.g., adherence to social or cultural norms could be motivated by tangible rewards, punishments, guilt, or pressure from others), which in turn could cause helping behavior driven by external motives, rather than being due to an increased motivation to act in accordance with internal moral values. Using a comprehensive laboratory experiment, we test EAH. We experimentally prime empathy. Moreover, in contrast to previous studies, we provide subjects with an opportunity to only appear moral in the eyes of someone in need, without actually being so (hypocrisy case). If empathy causes an internal motivation to help, we should observe more helping behavior and no hypocrisy. However, if empathy merely triggers external motives to help, we would expect to see an increase in hypocrisy. The various benefits of helping behavior for the self will also be investigated; e.g., is acting hypocritically enough to reduce aversive arousal? Practical implications for organizations (e.g., team work) and markets (e.g., for health care) will be discussed.

Experimental design

Empathy will be experimentally primed and subjects will play the Dictator Game (DG), where they can either choose the outcome 8€/2€ or 5€/5€. In order to keep conditions comparable, a control group will receive a neutral prime instead. It is assumed that in the Empathy condition significantly more dictators will choose the equal outcome, which corresponds to helping the other as mentioned before. Moreover, in contrast to previous studies, in two further treatments, subjects will be provided with an opportunity to only appear moral in the eyes of someone in need, without actually being so (hypocrisy case). Therefore the DG will be extended such that dictators get the option to toss a coin in addition to decide about the outcome (coin marked with 5/5 and 8/2). Here again there will be a treatment with a neutral prime and one where subjects will be primed with empathy. Subjects have to tell if they used the coin and which outcome was implemented by the coin (or themselves in case of no coin use). Hypocrisy occurs if subjects indicated coin use but (significantly) more than 50% of the outcomes will be 8/2. If empathy causes an internal motivation to help, we should observe more helping behavior (no coin, 5/5 outcome) and no hypocrisy. But if empathy merely triggers external motives to help, one would expect to see an increase in hypocrisy (coin, 8/2 outcome). In total there are 4 treatments: DGNeutral, DGEmpathy, DGCoinNeutral, DGCoinEmpathy. In order to also investigate if empathy has a lasting spill over effect on trust, dictators will play a trust game after the main task in each treatment. Transfers in the Empathy conditions are assumed to be significantly higher relative to the control group if empathy induces an internal motivation to help.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization by a software and algorithm
Randomization unit
experimental session
Clusters
240 individuals
Observations
240 individuals
Arms
60 control, 60 empathy, 60 control coin flip, 60 empathy coin flip
Primary outcomes
splitting decision (fair or unfair), transfer (measure cooperation)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords