Encouraging Protest Participation: A Field Experiment to Study the Consequences of Political Experience and Peer Effects in Protest Participation
How to cite
Yang, David Y.; Zhang, Y. Jane; Yuchtman, Noam; Cantoni, Davide; Bursztyn, Leonardo. 2017. "Encouraging Protest Participation: A Field Experiment to Study the Consequences of Political Experience and Peer Effects in Protest Participation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002301. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2301-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Participation in political movements has the potential to shape political institutions, public policy, and economic outcomes. In this project, we study the causal effects of a “nudge” that induces individuals to turnout to a high-stakes, anti-authoritarian protest. Studying the effects of this sort of nudge, we have two broad areas of inquiry: first, if an individual is randomly nudged to experience a political protest, how does that affect her political attitudes and subsequent political behavior? Are there short-run effects? Persistent effects? Second, does nudging individuals to participate in a protest have spillover effects on their peers’ decisions to protest? Determining whether there are peer effects in the decision to turnout to protest is important for understanding the dynamics of protest participation and protest size.
Intervention
In a second part to our survey (where recruitment occurs through emails to participants who have completed the first part), we randomly assign student participants in the survey into three groups (the details of treatment assignment are described in the following subsection): (i) the protest encouragement treatment group; (ii) a “subway” control group; and, (iii) a “pure” control group.
The treatment condition is intended to “nudge” individuals on the margin of protest attendance into choosing to attend the July 1 protest March by paying them a meaningful amount of money for a small commitment of time while at the March.
The “subway” control condition provides a very similar nudge, and similar payment, for a similar time commitment; however, rather than nudging toward attending the protest March on July 1, the nudge is toward going to central Hong Kong (near the location of the March) on the following weekend. This comparison group will help address concerns about experimenter demand effects and income effects when interpreting differences between a pure control group and the treatment group.
The pure control condition provides another benchmark against which to compare the treatment group.
Experimental design
The sample from which we draw is recruited from the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. Students are recruited via a mass email sent to the undergraduate student population. The email will invite students to participate in an online survey in return for payment for their participation.
All subjects were asked to complete a baseline survey in mid-June of 2017, which included a range of questions used in our experimental analysis. These questions included: cohort, major, gender, housing (on campus or off), whether they were born in Hong Kong, and whether they attended high school in Hong Kong. We also ask about subjects’ political attitudes, and plans to attend the pro-democracy March on July 1, 2017.
In a second part to our survey (where recruitment occurs through emails to participants who have completed the first part), we randomly assign student participants in the survey into three groups (the details of treatment assignment are described in the following subsection): (i) the protest encouragement treatment group; (ii) a “subway” control group; and, (iii) a “pure” control group.
Outcome data will be collected via another online survey conducted between mid-July and mid-August 2017, and the detailed outcome questionnaire will be described in the attached pre-analysis plan.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.