Can access to formal saving devices reduce poverty and vulnerability? Experimental evidence from Benin.
How to cite
LeMay-Boucher, Philippe; Daye, Modeste; Tomavo, Charlemagne; Grogan, Louise. 2017. "Can access to formal saving devices reduce poverty and vulnerability? Experimental evidence from Benin.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002285. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2285-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Amongst many development actors and public aid donors it is commonly perceived that the poor cannot escape poverty because they are credit constrained and as such cannot invest. The main reason why they are credit constrained being the lack of collaterals. Microcredit, the practice of lending small amounts of money to the poor, is heralded as a key tool in the fight against poverty in least developed countries (LDCs). It is easy to overlook the fact that what the poor may actually desire is not a loan, but simply the ability to put their savings in a secure and reliable account. In which case the poor’s interest could be best served by providing access to an affordable formal saving account (microsavings). Addressing this empirically weak spot, this project will analyse the financial needs of the poor by measuring the impact of having access and using two formal saving devices: a saving account in an MFI and mobile banking (through the use of a mobile phone). Through a randomized controlled trial in Benin, West Africa, we will test which of these financial instruments is more effective in helping individuals to reduce poverty and vulnerability.
Microsaving is of great interest given that the vast majority of populations in LDCs have little if no access to formal finance. Most individuals in Benin use informal saving or lending mechanisms; informal due to the lack of any binding legal arrangement. In the absence of formal finance many Beninese resort to rotating savings and credit associations (ROSCAs). Participation in ROSCAs is costly and no interest is earned. Their members also bear the risk of default by other members, which frequently leads to financial loss and the breakdown of groups. ROSCA members have less flexibility in saving than they would on their own, since the group-determined contribution level is likely to differ from their individual optimal saving rate. Despite these constraints, ROSCAs enjoy popularity and are pervasive in LDCs. One can speculate that access to more secure and reliable formal financial products could lead to significant improvement in people’s ability to save and invest and would reduce the impact associated with shocks the poor face on a near daily basis.
To carry out our comparative analysis, we will offer access to microsaving devices to different samples of individuals. This will allow to:
1) Analyse what drives the demand for these financial devices and enhance our understanding of the poor’s motivations for saving and investing.
2) Examine whether formal financial services are more effective in helping individuals to escape poverty than ROSCAs.
3) Investigate subsidiary effects of formal finance on consumption patterns and the use of informal finance. Does formal finance help in reducing expenditures on luxury/frivolous items? Do the poor manage better to avoid falling into a debt trap with or without formal finance? Is formal finance driving people out of ROSCAs?
4) Analyse the resulting investments and their sustainability in two crucial dimensions: education and health. These are known to crucially impact long-term poverty.
Intervention
We will run an RCT that will allow us to test directly for the impacts of microsavings.
Treatment 1 will offer individuals a bank savings account with the FECECAM. FECECAM already has a large client basis and offers flexible and accommodating membership conditions. It would again represent the ideal partner for this treatment. Our treatment will cover the administrative costs of opening an account and the passport size pictures required.
Treatment 2 will provide individuals the use of mobile banking by opening a mobile phone saving accounts. Comparative to other regions in Africa and notably East Africa, mobile banking is a recent phenomenon in Benin. Our treatment would offer a transfer (gift) upon the opening of an account with MTN Benin or MOOV Benin, our two partners in this project.
Our control group would not be exposed to any of these offers.
Experimental design
We will collect and analyse data using a large and representative survey of around 3,500 households. We will sample from Cotonou, the largest city in the country with around 1 million inhabitants, and from two towns in Benin: Parakou in the north and Abomey in the centre. This sample frame will offer a mix between households who live in urban and semi-urban conditions. The first six months will focus on improving our questionnaire by piloting it. The next 24 months of the project will see us visiting each randomly selected household across our three sites every 6 to 9 months, for a total of 2 (or 3) observation points for each household. During the remaining 6 months of the project we will start the analysis phase.
Our survey will target parts of the three sites where informal finance is present and thriving. This would give us enough variations in ROSCAs and insurance group membership. We know from our previous surveys in Benin (in 2004, 2006 and 2014) that these areas are likely to include poor households with the appropriate income brackets and financial degree of activities for this study. On the one hand, targeting poorer regions is likely to lead to negligible (if not undetectable) impact from our treatments. Poorer households who cannot even use informal finance are less likely to demand any saving vehicles because of their inability to save. On the other hand, targeting richer neighbourhoods would see us surveying a large proportion of households already using formal finance products, which would render our treatment superfluous.
Our questionnaire will include a baseline survey aimed at obtaining housing information and information on each member: religion, activity, education, work, risk aversion, discounting, etc.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.