Bringing property owners into the tax net: Avenues of fiscal capacity and local accountability

How to cite

Knebelmann, Justine; Sarr, Bassirou; Cogneau, Denis; Gurgand, Marc; Pouliquen, Victor. 2017. "Bringing property owners into the tax net: Avenues of fiscal capacity and local accountability." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002277. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2277-5.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Justine Knebelmann* , Bassirou Sarr , Denis Cogneau , Marc Gurgand , Victor Pouliquen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002277
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2277-5.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-11-01 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2277

Abstract

Property taxes are levied for local governments and often represent an important component in their budget funding. As such they play a crucial role in the face of increasing needs for public services in rapidly growing cities. In the context of developing countries, with cadaster shortcomings, weak administrative information and IT systems and poor enforcement tools, most local administrations experience substantial shortfall in property tax revenues. We partnered with the Senegalese tax administration (Direction Générale des Impôts et des Domaines) to develop a new property tax management system in Dakar, including an intensive fiscal census, a new data collection and management application, and the incorporation of modernized cadastral information. It's implementation through a randomized controlled trial will shed light on four questions: i) the extent and mechanisms by which this administrative investment increases fiscal capacity; ii) the respective advantages of a rule compared to discretion in the assessment of tax liability by tax officials; iii) the effects of increased local taxation on local governance dynamics and on the activities of neighborhood delegates; iv) the incidence of the property tax and its effects on the real estate market.

Intervention

We partnered with the tax administration (DGID) and with a private local software company to define a modernized property taxation protocol, and to develop an application with both Android and Web components which encompass all stages of the fiscal chain. The application can be utilized in all areas of Senegal in the future, but the RCT focuses on the region of Dakar (cities of Dakar, Pikine, Guediawaye, Rufisque).

The intervention corresponds to a comprehensive property tax census carried out in treated areas by the tax administration, using the new application. The intervention seeks both to detect unregistered properties and to update the valuation roll. The census is accompanied by sensitization activities carried out in coordination with municipalities.

Within treated areas where the property tax census will occur, there are two possibilities for the way the tax base -- the value of the property -- is assessed, leading to two treatment branches. In the first treatment branch, tax agents in the field assess the value of the property using their discretionary judgement. This involves their knowledge of the area and potential interactions with residents. In the second treatment branch, the application allows for the semi automatized estimation of the property value based on observable characteristics that the agent fills in (rule based, or formula based valuation method). This valuation method is inspired from CAMA methods and Points Based Valuation methods, adapted to the Senegalese context.

Experimental design

The region of Dakar is divided into around 700 cadastral sections. Among these, 194 sections have been identified as eligible for the program -- eligibility being defined as: having up to date cadastral information (plot identifiers); having a tax potential; not being a traditional village, an informal settlement nor an industrial area. These 194 sections have been randomly divided into treatment and control group. The property tax census using the new application is the treatment that will be implemented in the 97 treatment sections. Within these treated sections, another randomization was done to assign 49 sections for the discretionary (or current) valuation method, and 48 sections for the rule based valuation method. The software is configured accordingly for each section.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Our unit of randomization is the cadastral section. The region of Dakar is divided into around 700 sections. The average number of plots in a section is 397.
Clusters
The planned number of clusters (cadastral sections) is 194.
Observations
Administrative data: 194 clusters, 77,000 plots. Survey data: We plan to survey 20 property owners in each section. Total number of observations: 3,880.
Arms
Administrative data: Control -- 97 clusters, 38,000 plots. Treatment 1 Discretion -- 49 clusters, 20,500 plots Treatment 2 Rule -- 48 clusters, 18,500 plots Survey data: Control -- 97 clusters, 1,940 respondents. Treatment 1 Discretion -- 49 clusters, 980 respondents. Treatment 2 Rule -- 48 clusters, 960 respondents.
Primary outcomes
For the comparison T and C: tax payment; tax revenues. For the comparison T1 and T2: tax assessment, tax payment; tax revenues.
Secondary outcomes
Tax notification distribution Compliance Rate Accuracy of property valuation Adjustment of tax assessment to taxpayer's capacity to pay Corruption/Collusion Taxpayer satisfaction Taxpayer attitudes toward taxation and public institutions Resident knowledge of local taxation Resident demand for local government accountability Implication of neighborhood delegate in local governance dynamics Pass-through of the tax to rents Demand for, and Regularization of property ownership

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords