The Effect of Improving Child Care Centers on Early Childhood Development in Bolivia

How to cite

Martinez, Sebastian; Vidal, Cecilia; Johannsen, Julia. 2017. "The Effect of Improving Child Care Centers on Early Childhood Development in Bolivia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002261. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2261-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sebastian Martinez* , Cecilia Vidal , Julia Johannsen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002261
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2261-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2013-05-01 – 2019-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, I15, I25, O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2261

Abstract

It has been widely acknowledged that the grounds for a healthy and productive future are shaped early on for every child. Inadequate health and nutrition, child rearing practices with limited interaction between parents and children, and home environments with few books, toys, and other learning opportunities may all contribute towards poor cognitive growth and overall child development. Early deficits can have life-long consequences, including lower levels of school participation and performance, lower future earnings and income, increased reliance on the health care system and higher rates of criminality (Walker et al., 2001; Naudeau et al., 2010).

The evidence from recent research suggests that well targeted and defined early interventions can accrue positive and sustainable development outcomes (Engle et. al, 2011; Hoddinott et. al, 2008; Gertler et. al, 2014). Among different policy alternatives, center-based child care interventions have proven to be effective in different country settings (Martinez et. al., 2012; Noboa-Hidalgo and Urzúa, 2012), and the provision of public and high quality child care services has become a desired intervention for expanding coverage within early childhood development (ECD) programs.

The Early Childhood Development Unit (UDIT) within the Bolivia’s Ministry of Health (MS) is launching a pilot program in the departments of Chuquisaca and Potosi, which aims to improve the cognitive, socio-emotional and physical development of vulnerable children under four years of age through increased access to early intervention services. The Program encompasses a series of components financed by a loan from the Inter-American Development Bank, including a facility improvement intervention for eligible existing child care centers, as well as an upgrade in quality standards and guidelines in these centers.

The program includes an experimental impact evaluation design where eligible child care centers are randomly assigned to treatment and control groups. The evaluation will measure the causal effect of the intervention on different measures of the quality of services offered, including structural factors and processes indicators, and child development outcomes in the long run.

Intervention

Intervention:

Public child care centers in Bolivia provide daycare services for children under 4 years of age, whereas preschool-age children (4-5 years) are required to attend formal education facilities. The program provides major physical upgrading and improvements of content and staffing capabilities for existing facilities. It will also strengthen the existing national norms and protocols providing standardized guidelines for the work in child care centers in all intervention centers. Specifically, the intervention will finance and support:

• Facility infrastructure improvements through the upgrading of existing selected centers in line with improved guidelines (refurbishments of buildings, redesigning of space use, improvement of safety conditions, etc.).
• Provision or replacement of equipment at the child care center, including appliances, cookware, furniture, and materials.
• Hiring of new human resources (1 senior caregiver/tutor per center and 1 nutrition and hygiene specialist for every two centers)
• Training of new and existing personnel in line with improved guidelines.
• Elaboration, complementation and reproduction of guidelines, norms and quality standards.

The intervention will be implemented in a total of 79 eligible child care centers. All centers will receive the soft component of the intervention (additional personnel and training), 2 centers will receive, in addition, the equipment component, and 48 centers will receive the complete package of the intervention (infrastructure improvements, equipment, additional personnel and training).

Experimental design

Random assignment to treatment and control groups:

The impact evaluation will be based on the design of a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT). Within each program municipality, eligible child care centers were randomly assigned an order of entrance to the program and listed accordingly. Initially, based on program resources available, 83 child care centers on top of the list were identified for the treatment group and an equivalent number of centers from the bottom of the list were assigned to the control group. In municipalities where there was only one child center, it was directly assigned to treatment; those municipalities, however, will not be part of the experimental sample. Randomization was carried out through public lotteries witnessed by local and UDIT authorities to ensure transparency and legitimacy.

Treatment was assigned at the center level and stratified by municipality.

Planned number of observations: 158 child care centers
- Treatment: 79 centers
- Control: 79 centers

The long run follow-up will include a population based sample of children in the area of influence (community or neighborhood) of treatment and control centers. The sample will include 12 children per area for a total sample of 1900 children.

Design details

Randomization method
Public Lottery
Randomization unit
Child Care Center
Clusters
158 child care centers
Observations
158 child care centers and 1900 households with children 3 to 5 years old
Arms
Treatment group: 79 centers and 950 children Control group: 79 centers and 950 children
Primary outcomes
The purpose of this research is to assess the impact of the child care center intervention on a variety of service quality outcomes. Our measurement of quality will consider structural factors, such as infrastructure, equipment, availability of trained personnel, protocols, etc, as well as processes indicators that focus on the child-caregiver interactions. Key Short-term Outcomes • Availability and adequate physical infrastructure, use of space, furniture, and equipment (Infant Toddler Environment Rating Scale – Revised) • Quantity and quality of child stimulation and availability of child support in the center’s environment (caregiving routines, activities and interactions) (Caregiver Interaction Scale). • Caregiver’s knowledge about child development processes and child care practices (Knowledge of Infant Development Inventory). The study will not measure final child development outcomes in the short run, and will rather focus on quality measures of service provision. The application of ECD standardized tests is considered for subsequent follow up surveys (conditional on the availability of funding) including ECD indicators on cognitive, language, gross and fine motor development, and socio-emotional skills with the ASQ-3 or other similar instruments.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords