Management and energy efficiency in a Chinese manufacturing cluster

How to cite

Karplus, Valerie Jean; Zhang, Da. 2019. "Management and energy efficiency in a Chinese manufacturing cluster." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002221. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2221-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Valerie Jean Karplus* , Da Zhang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002221
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2221-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-03-01 – 2019-06-29
Countries
China (Jinan City, Shandong Province)
JEL codes
D23, M53, Q41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2221

Abstract

We investigate the effects of an energy management training designed to identify both technology and process-oriented energy-saving opportunities for firms in a machine components manufacturing cluster in Shandong Province, China. We aim to understand to what extent, and through what mechanisms, the intervention affects firms' energy management practices and ultimately improves their efficiency of energy use. We are interested in studying the relationship between measures of good management practices and the adoption of experts' recommendations. Our study will also allow us to qualitatively probe the role of management and other firm characteristics, such as firm size, degree of centralization, and appointment of a dedicated energy manager, on achievement of energy savings through a set of pre- and post-intervention survey questions. The training is conducted by a team of local and international energy saving experts with expertise in the metalworking equipment and production processes employed by the firms in our sample. For each firm, experts generate a customized list of improvements and deliver their findings to the firms in the form of a report. A representative of the team follows up every three months to assess progress and elaborate or adjust recommendations.

Intervention

From June to September 2017, one MIT representative, 1-2 McKinsey representative, and 1-2 representatives from the Shandong Zhengxiang International Low-Carbon Technology Company will administer a training aiming at improving firms' energy efficiency to a sample of 20-24 firms randomly selected from the total population of 48 surveyed firms. The training will last one to two days with regular follow-up every three months, with troubleshooting as needed. During the training, firms' current energy management and energy use situation will be assessed, and recommendations tailored to the firms will be provided. Each recommendation will be accompanied with a detailed assessment of energy and cost savings potential. There are in general three types of recommendations: energy management, technology upgrading, and policy information. Energy management-related recommendations will provide several key energy management best practices that firms have not yet adopted, e.g. establishing energy baselines, setting energy targets, appointing an energy management team, and providing them with effective incentives; Technology upgrading-related recommendations will provide information that can help firms to replace or upgrade energy equipment, e.g. identifying outdated air compressor or motor and providing upgrade suggestions, proposing a more efficient lighting design, and adjusting production activities to reduce idle time; Policy information-related recommendations will inform firms of relevant energy saving (either in terms of quantity or cost) policies that the central and local governments have already provided, e.g. direct power purchase that provides lower electricity tariff available for some firms, heating fee that is based on actual energy use not heating area, and energy-saving subsidies that firms may be qualified to apply when upgrading technology.

Firms will be made aware that researchers are piloting this new approach designed to identify these energy efficiency recommendations based on international experience and tailored to their individual circumstances. The recommendations will be provided in a written notice and an online software application, known as the RedE tool, developed by McKinsey.

Experimental design

In the baseline survey, we collected energy use (monthly electricity use) and output (in quantity and value term) of 100 firms in the last three years (2014-2016) as well as firm characteristics such as ownership, industry code, export status and etc. We also implemented a survey to measure the management and energy management levels before the intervention.

We choose 48 firms that satisfy the requirements of our study and randomly choose 24 firms to receive the intervention from June to September 2017. After the training is completed, we will provide follow-up support and track the adoption status of the recommendations of treatment firms for one and half years. For all the participating firms, we will collect post-treatment energy use and output information. By the end of 2018, we should be able to compare the energy efficiency and energy use as well as management and energy management levels between the treatment and control firms.

Design details

Randomization method
Using the pair-wise matching method described in Bruhn and McKenzie (AEJAE, 2009), we created 24 pairs of firms out of the 48 firms that participate in the experiment. We use firms' electricity consumption, electricity intensity, sales and sales growth in 2015 as well as management and energy management levels in the matching process. In each pair of the firms, we randomly choose one as the treatment firm and the other as the control firm.
Randomization unit
Firm
Clusters
48 firms
Observations
48 firms
Arms
24 firms control and 24 firms treatment (12 in one treatment arm and 12 in the other)
Primary outcomes
Recommendation adoption status, and firm energy use and efficiency (monthly electricity use and electricity use per unit of output)

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Karplus, V.J. and Zhang, D. (2022). When “Low-Hanging Fruit” Are Beyond Reach: Management Practices and Firm Energy Efficiency. MIT CEEPR Working Paper 2022-009. https://ceepr.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/2022-009.pdf

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords