Cash & Stash Evaluation

How to cite

Zinman, Jonathan; Karlan, Dean. 2017. "Cash & Stash Evaluation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002207. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2207-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jonathan Zinman* , Dean Karlan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002207
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2207-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2014-12-01 – 2017-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2207

Abstract

Consumers face countless opportunities to borrow and spend on impulse. We work with a leading check casher in New York City to develop and test a new product that facilitates impulse saving. The product links check cashing transactions to a basic savings account by prompting customers to make a deposit every time they cash a check. Using a field experiment, we estimate the effects of receiving prompts relative to the account without the prompts on savings behavior.

Intervention

We work with a leading check casher in New York City to develop and test a new product that facilitates impulse saving: "Cash & Stash," a savings account that enables customers to make savings deposits and withdrawals from the check cashing window. The core feature of the product is a prompt to save at the moment the customer realizes a substantial inflow of liquidity. RiteCheck partners with a credit union, first BethEx and now USAlliance Financial, to offer the savings account.This evaluation assesses whether behaviorally-informed product features—well-timed reminders and incentives to save–can encourage check cashing customers to build savings balances.

Experimental design

RiteCheck worked with the research team to randomize 872 Cash & Stash accountholders into one of four arms (see Figure 1 and next sub-section for details on sample creation and characteristics). Account functionality is identical across the four arms, which vary only in prompts and incentives to save. The four arms are:
T0) Account only. No additional incentives to save; no prompts to save after account-opening. This arm is akin to a basic saving account where the account-issuer does not actively promote usage among existing accountholders.
T1) Prompt only. Each transaction performed by these accountholders triggered a teller pop-up window that reminded tellers to prompt the customer to save: “Would you like to make a deposit into your Cash & Stash account?”
T2) Prompt + Sweepstakes. Each transaction performed by these accountholders triggered a teller pop-up window that reminded tellers to prompt the customer to save and to promote a sweepstakes incentive: “Would you like to make a deposit into your Cash & Stash account? Each dollar in your weekly balance is a sweepstakes entry. The bigger your balance the more chances you have to win!” At the end of each week, clients earned 1 sweepstake entry per dollar in their Cash & Stash account. RiteCheck conducted drawings for small prizes ($50 cash prize), and grand prize drawings ($500 cash prize) in July 2015, January 2016, and July 2016.
T3) Prompt + Rewards points. Each transaction performed by these accountholders triggered a teller pop-up window that reminded tellers to prompt the customer to save and to promote a rewards program incentive: “Would you like to make a deposit into your Cash & Stash account? Each week you get triple points for every dollar of your balance. The more you have in your account the more points you earn!” At the end of each week, clients earned 3 points per dollar in their Cash & Stash account, up to a limit of 15,000 points per week. 7,000 points is worth roughly $1.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization occurred at the individual account level, in one of two ways: Batch randomization: Customers who opened Cash & Stash accounts during the initial pilot period (April 2013 through December 2014) and post-promotion period (May 2015 through May 2016) were randomized by IPA staff. In-branch, on-the-spot randomization: During the promotional period (February 2015 through April 2015), clients that visited RiteCheck branches during peak hours (10:00am to 5:00pm) were approached by hired marketers with the offer to open a Cash & Stash savings account. Clients who agreed to open the account and submit their contact information to the marketer were randomized into one of the four treatment groups. Randomization took place using tablets equipped with a mobile data collection toolkit (SurveyCTO Collect), which used a built-in random number generator.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
872 check cashing clients
Arms
Nothing 245, Verbal 228, Sweepstakes 185, Points 214
Primary outcomes
savings accounts balances, deposits, and withdrawals, both while treatments going and after treatments stop. trying to get data on borrowing from an alternative credit bureau

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords