Charitable giving trials linked to ESSExLab recruiting and omnibus: i. Crowding out (does one contribution/appeal come at the expense of another?) ii. Do people commit more before a win (conditionally on winning) or after a win? iii. Does the opportunity to donate boost reported happiness (and vice/versa). Associated instrument: Beliefs and attitudes towards starting salaries. [Registered later (but before 30 July implementation): Further trials via the Prolific platform (30 July, 1 August 2017)]

How to cite

Reinstein, David; Vance-McMullen, Danielle; Kellner, Christian; Riener, Gerhard. 2017. "Charitable giving trials linked to ESSExLab recruiting and omnibus: i. Crowding out (does one contribution/appeal come at the expense of another?) ii. Do people commit more before a win (conditionally on winning) or after a win? iii. Does the opportunity to donate boost reported happiness (and vice/versa). Associated instrument: Beliefs and attitudes towards starting salaries. [Registered later (but before 30 July implementation): Further trials via the Prolific platform (30 July, 1 August 2017)]." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002180. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2180-7.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Reinstein* , Danielle Vance-McMullen , Christian Kellner , Gerhard Riener

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002180
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2180-7.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-05-04 – 2017-08-17
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (Colchester, Essex (i. Local residents and ii. students attending University of Essex))
JEL codes
D64, C91, C93, L30, D01, D03, D84.
Secondary IDs
SC-07480 (British Academy:
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2180

Abstract

This is a field experiment in the context of a recruitment drive for the ESSExLab (University of Essex, Colchester). A sample of local participants, drawn from a marketing database, are being paid to join the ESSExLab database as participants, and again to take the Omnibus survey. A sample of already-registered ESSExLab participants (henceforth "Student subjects", although a small share of these are university staff and local residents) are also being paid to take the Omnibus, and again to take an Employability survey. Within these contexts we are running experiments into charitable giving following our previous research, and related research by other authors.

See in particular https://davidreinstein.wordpress.com/research-and-publications/

- "Giving and Probability" (Kellner, Reinstein, Riener); Giveifyouwin.org (popular summary)
- "Substitution Among Charitable Contributions: An Experimental Study.” (Reinstein)

The employability study contains another embedded experiment about gender-differences in perceptions of starting salaries.

Further details are given within the hidden section.

The motivation for the substitution experiment and the broad design are also presented in

"Full_proposal_adapting_LOI_SPI_Reinstein_et_al with timeline.pdf", our 2013 grant application, and again in our BA grant application

"Experiments on Political Ideology for BA grant - word version.pdf".

---

[Registered later (but before these were implemented on 30 July - 1 August 2017): Further trials of "Giving and Probability" via the Prolific platform on UK nonstudents; compensating for low turnout of Essex nonstudents]

Intervention

This is a field experiment in the context of a recruitment drive for the ESSExLab (University of Essex, Colchester). A sample of local participants, drawn from a marketing database, are being paid to join the ESSExLab database as participants, and again to take the Omnibus survey. A sample of students (current participants) are also being paid to take the Omnibus, and again to take an employability survey. Within these contexts we are running experiments into charitable giving following our previous research, and related research by other authors.

See in particular https://davidreinstein.wordpress.com/research-and-publications/

- "Giving and Probability" (Kellner, Reinstein, Riener); Giveifyouwin.org (popular summary)
- "Substitution Among Charitable Contributions: An Experimental Study.” (Reinstein)

The employability study contains another embedded experiment about gender-differences in perceptions of starting salaries.

Further details given in "hidden" section below.

30 Jul 2017: Because of a low response rate to the 'nonstudent' part of the initially planned trial, we added an additional set of trials for the Giving and Probability and happiness components, involving 320 additional participants recruited on Prolific Academic. This trial will be run on 30 Jul 2017 (except for 20 pilot observations). I am registering this component immediately in advance of running it (160 participants on 30 Jul 2017 and 160 more on 31 July or 1 August). The timing and all details of the trial (and my trial account) on the Prolific site and the Qualtrics site (which includes the time and geocode of each response) can be made available in case of a serious need to verify the integrity of this study and its data.
____

Followup 18 Aug 2017: Prolific run on 30 July (140 participants) and 1 August as planned (160 obs) as planned; plus 20 obs in "Pilot runs" on 29 July.

2018 note: Ordering of student treatments was changed because of low nonstudent response and a revised research priority, see details below.

Experimental design

The parts of our design which we would like to reveal at this point have been described above under 'Intervention (Public)'.

Design details

Randomization method
The 2600 (of 5000) nonstudents were allocated via simple randomization by Pat Lown (assigning random numbers to each address via an Excel spreadsheet). Of these, 2571 had unique emails; duplicates were dropped. Simple tests indicated approximate balance. Next, David Reinstein randomized, within the 4 blocks 'child present x sex', into five groups for the 'batches of 514' mentioned below, using Stata-generated random numbers. - See 'testrandomisedatahq.do' Further randomization is done through Qualtrics survey flow randomizer, selecting 'evenly present elements' in each case. We are blocking this further randomization to a limited extent. For the first 400 Nonstudent participants we are separately randomizing (into the 3x2 treatments in the Substitution experiment first phase) within 2 predetermined groups: those recorded as having children present, and those recorded as not having children present (from the marketing data). We chose this variable to block on as a brief analysis of our Prolific data on a similar population suggested households with children were more likely to contribute (a significant extensive-margin difference). For the next 200 Nonstudents (in the Giving and Probability treatments) we block the randomization by gender. [2018 Note: we didn't get this many respondents] We will block the randomisation for the Student respondents by gender, subject to some feasibility issues. For the timing dimension (time between first and second ask), we are releasing invitations in batches of (approximately) 514 with 48 hour intervals in between. As we have only 400 rewards to give away, and we cannot know the response rate in advance, the distribution of these timings is not fully controlled. For example, we may get few responses each time, leading to a fairly even distribution of responses over the 15 days, or we may get many responses early on. However, the assigned order we are *sending* the emails has been randomized, thus those receiving the invitation in each of the five batches (if we get to five) should have the same characteristics on average. The requested salary and gender component does not involve randomization. ___ Note 18 Aug 2017: The Prolific trial used pure randomisation (no blocking/clustering/stratification) for convenience on this platform. 2018: Stylistic edits to this form
Randomization unit
We randomize essentially at the individual level, blocking the randomization as explained above.
Clusters
NA
Observations
1. Substitution experiment: A targeted and maximum sample of 400 Non-students, plus 200 Students, each observed at two separate points in time (with possible additional follow-ups) 2. Giving-in-probability: a. 1/2 chance of winning - 400 Students (targeted) for 1/2 chance of £10 [2018: Note revision to 600 students, because of low nonstudent turnout] - Up to 200 non-students (targeted) for 1/2 chance of £10 [2018: None administered because of low turnout] - plus possible reallocation from substitution experiment; this change will be made if there is 'extremely low giving' among the 400 Non-students the first time they are asked. b. Ambiguous chance of winning [2018: None administered because of low-ish turnout] - Plus any remaining regular-sample (participants in the ESSExLab pool who do the Omnibus, up to roughly 2000, considering the size of the pool): 30/N chance of one of 30 £10 Amazon vouchers, 6/N chance of winning one of six £50 Amazon vouchers, or both (treatment variation discussed above); equal division between these treatments. 3. Happiness and giving: 750 participants (400 Non-students and 200 students earning certain £10); of which (up to) 600 observed at two separate points in time (with possible additional follow-ups) 4. Requested salary and gender: 200 participants (the 200 regular-sample participants listed in item 1) *** 30 Jul 2017 addition: 320 Prolific participants 2018: Noting changed student randomisation ordering, low turnout + stylistic edits to this form
Arms
NA
Primary outcomes
(These variables pertain to each of the parts of the study) - Charitable donations and commitments to donate; incidence, amounts, and expected values of donation amounts (where individuals make commitments in uncertain situations) - Choice of charity (a very secondary concern) - Reported happiness - Hypothetical responses to scenarios involving starting salaries. These measures and our proposed analysis are further described below in several sections. 2018: stylistic edits to this form

Papers from this trial

  1. Kellner, Christian, David Reinstein, and Gerhard Riener. (2017) "Stochastic income and conditional generosity." Working Paper. https://www.dropbox.com/s/xw306qpqj5ixbc1/GivingProbabilityMaster1.pdf?dl=0

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords