Goals and Gaps: Educational Careers of Immigrant Children

How to cite

Ferrara, Eliana La; Carlana, Michela; Pinotti, Paolo. 2017. "Goals and Gaps: Educational Careers of Immigrant Children." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002148. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2148-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Eliana La Ferrara* , Michela Carlana , Paolo Pinotti

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002148
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2148-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2012-09-03 – 2014-07-30
Countries
Italy (Europe)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2148

Abstract

Researchers study the educational choices of immigrant students in Italy. Given increased migrant flows, educational systems have witnessed increased pressure to provide the same level of cognitive training and support for diverse student populations. A literature review indicates that immigrants tend to choose vocational over technical or academic-oriented curricula relative to native students with similar ability. Researchers estimate the impact of a randomized program that provides both career counseling and tutoring as treatment. Ultimately, results indicate that the program successful mitigates educational segregation as male treated students have a lower probability of being retained and a higher likelihood of choosing a more rigorous high school. Although the results are not significant for girls, the overall result has positive spillovers of treated immigrant students.

Intervention

As migrant flows have increased over the past few decades, it is becoming increasingly difficult for education systems to ensure the development of skills in a diverse student population and promote social cohesion. This paper studies the educational choices of children of immigrants in Italy. Immigrants tend to choose vocational over technical and academic-oriented curricula. Researchers then estimate the impact of a randomized program "Equality of Opportunity for immigrant students" (EOP) that provides tutoring and career counseling to a random sample of immigrant children who demonstrate high academic potential. Ultimately, the results indicate that the program successfully reduces segregation as male treated students have a lower probability to be retained and a higher probability of attending an academic or technical high-school. The results for girls are in the same direction but not significant. Results indicate improved cognitive and soft skills as well as positive spillovers.

Experimental design

"Equality of OPportunity for immigrant students" (EOP) targeted immigrant children who displayed high academic potential as measured by sixth-grade standardized test scores. Researchers selected all schools in five cities in northern Italy. Among the 143 schools selected, they randomized 68 schools as treatment and 75 as the control group.

The treatment itself consisted of two main parts: 1) career choice consultancy and 2) tutoring on study method. The career choice consultancy offered 13 meetings with psychological support and information about the Italian schooling system; this consisted of 5 individual meetings between the student and career counselor, 5 group meetings with all treatment students of the same school; 2 meetings with parents and 1 meeting with teachers of treated student. The second part of the treatment was aimed at improving students' Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (CALP) regarding topics such as Italian grammar, algebra, and geometry.

The datasets are from the Ministry of Education, University and Research (MIUR) and the National Institute for the Evaluation of the Italian Schooling System (INVALSI).

Additionally, researchers employ first exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and confirmatory factor analysis to identify soft skills measures.

Regarding the results, immigrant students in treatment groups are 5.1 percentage points more likely to attending a more rigorous high school compared to immigrant students in the control with most of the significance driven by males students. Furthermore, male treated students are 3.7 percentage points less likely to be retained in grade 7 or 8. Male treated students scored 0.188 standard deviations higher in math and 0.139 standard deviations higher in reading than students in the control group. Male students have 0.291 standard deviations higher aspirations and perceive 0.389 standard deviations lower socioeconomic barriers than control students. The impact on both cognitive and soft skills was internalized by teachers who recommended treated students for a more demanding high school. Regarding the impact of tutoring, the results suggest that the 12 additional tutoring sessions improved neither educational career nor cognitive skills of immigrant children. Male treated students have a lower probability of failing a school year. Lastly, the intervention had some positive spillovers, reducing the retention rate for males and raising the enrollment to more demanding track for females.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomized at the school level. Selection of students within school was based on objective criteria. Each school had 10 selected students eligible for the intervention.
Randomization unit
School
Clusters
143 middle schools
Observations
1217 students total (601 male and 616 female)
Arms
68 schools treatment group; 75 schools control group 597 students treatment group; 620 students control group
Primary outcomes
cognitive skills via math and grammar scores, soft skills, dropout rates, teacher recommendation, aspirations, career/school choice (attending a challenging high school), retention rate

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords