Beyond Bail: Using Behavioral Science to Improve Timely Court Appearance
How to cite
Ouss, Aurelie; Fishbane, Alissa; Shah, Anuj. 2017. "Beyond Bail: Using Behavioral Science to Improve Timely Court Appearance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002143. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2143-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In 2014, nearly 40% of individuals issued a ticket for a violation in New York City did not show up to court, and were issued an arrest warrant as a result. Given this stiff penalty, it might seem that people would only miss court if they deliberately chose to do so. But a behavioral approach suggests other reasons why people might miss court: they might have simply forgotten or engaged in “ostrich behavior.” If these behavioral bottlenecks account for some failures to appear (FTA), then it may be possible to reduce FTA without resorting to the usual strict penalties. With our partners in New York City, we are testing whether various text message reminders can reduce FTA. We have designed several reminders, and we have been conducting a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to determine whether these messages can help, and which are most helpful. Over the course of approximately 12 months, summons recipients will be randomized into one of eight treatment arms. We will use administrative court data and (pending approval) police data to assess the efficacy of the messaging program in general and which message content in particular is most effective in reducing FTA.
Intervention
New York City summons recipients who provided phone numbers on their summons forms and whose case passed the standard pre-hearing court reviews on technical and legal grounds will be eligible to receive text messages, to help them show up in court and avoid failing to appear in court (FTA). They will be randomized into one of eight groups:
C Control group [No messages at any time]
T1.1 Consequences messages [three messages before the scheduled court date]
T1.2 T1 + one consequences post-FTA message, conditional on an FTA for the scheduled court date
T2.1 Plan-making messages [three messages before the scheduled court date]
T2.2 T2 + one consequences post-FTA message, conditional on an FTA for the scheduled court date
T3 A combination of consequences and plan-making messages [three messages before the scheduled court date]
T4 One social norms post-FTA message, conditional on an FTA on the scheduled court date
T5 One consequences post-FTA message, conditional on an FTA for the scheduled court date
Experimental design
Randomized Controlled Trial:
Anyone in New York City who has been issued a revised summons form by the New York Police Department (NYPD) and provided a cell phone number will be included in the study. People who did not provide a cell phone number will not be part of the study. We will compare the treatment group FTA outcomes to the control group FTA outcomes as well as outcomes across treatment groups.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.