Education in Emergencies, Evidence for Action (3EA): Testing remedial tutoring support and targeted interventions in Lebanon (2016-18)

How to cite

Aber, J. Lawrence. 2017. "Education in Emergencies, Evidence for Action (3EA): Testing remedial tutoring support and targeted interventions in Lebanon (2016-18)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002123. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2123-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

J. Lawrence Aber*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002123
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2123-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-11-01 – 2019-07-31
Countries
Lebanon (Akkar, Bekaa)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2123

Abstract

Lebanon, a nation of approximately 4 million citizens, is now sheltering more than 1 million registered Syrian refugees, approximately half of whom are Syrian children between the ages of 3 and 18. This study investigates the impact of Healing Classrooms Tutoring and low-cost targeted social-emotional interventions for the school-aged Syrian refugee population in the Bekaa and Akkar regions of Lebanon.

In Fall 2016, we will randomize sites, defined as informal tent settlements and/or buildings serving 1-3 informal tent settlements, stratified by region: (1) no tutoring support/wait-list (K = 21); (2) Healing Classrooms Tutoring Basic (K = 33); and (3) Healing Classrooms Tutoring Mindfulness (K=33). In Spring 2017, half of sites will continue providing Healing Classrooms Tutoring Basic while half of sites will provide Healing Classrooms Tutoring Brain Games.

In 2017-18, IRC will deliver programming to 57 program sites, stratified by region and prior year's treatment status. They will be randomized to two treatment arms: Healing Classrooms Tutoring basic (K =28) or Healing Classrooms Tutoring 5-component SEL curriculum (K =29)

Intervention

Healing Classrooms Tutoring: Lebanese teachers will be trained in the IRC’s Learning in a Healing Classrooms approach to providing high-quality safe, supportive, predictable and cooperative learning environments. Facilitators complete pre-service face-to-face training, participate in monthly Teacher Learning Circles (TLCs), and receive regular mentoring visits from trained IRC field staff. Children attend 8 hours of remedial class per week with foci on Arabic, Math, and a second language

Healing Classrooms Tutoring Mindfulness/Brain Games: In fall of 2016, half of all teachers (see below, Research Design) will receive additional training to incorporate targeted mindfulness strategies into their HCT daily classroom routines. In the Spring, the same teachers will receive additional training to incorporate a set of executive-functioning "Brain Games" into classroom routines. Both trainings include: (1) 1-2 days additional pre-service face-to-face training; (2) dedicated monthly Teacher Learning Circles; and (3) mentoring visits including mindfulness/brain games support on a monthly basis. Teachers will be encouraged to use targeted practices to facilitate classroom transitions (e.g., switching from Arabic to math instruction), with an expectation of spending 20-30 minutes per day on these activities.

In fall of 2017, teachers in 30 of 60 sites will receive training in 5-component SEL, focusing on the competencies of brain building, mindfulness, emotion regulation, conflict resolution, pro-social skills, and perseverance. Teachers continued to receive the same implementation support as tin the prior year, including 5 day HCT training, 3 day SEL training, TLC, monthly mentoring visits. Children received same 8 hours of HCT, and the HCT+SEL group implemented additional 30 minutes of 5-component SEL programming per day

Experimental design

Year One, Cycle one includes a 3-arm site (informal tent settlement or building) randomization. Randomization is stratified by region,
Treatment conditions are:
(1) no Healing Classrooms Tutoring /waitlist (K = 20);
(2) Healing Classrooms Tutoring Basic (K = 33);
(3) Healing Classrooms Tutoring plus Low-Cost Targeted Intervention (K=33).

Year Two: a two-armed site-randomized trial to determine the effect of comprehensive SEL programming on children’s academic and social emotional outcomes over and above LIHC retention support alone. Sites (K= 60) will be stratified based on their condition in year one to ensure balance of prior intervention(s) between treatment and control conditions. Minimally-detectable effect sizes average 0.2, with a range of .12-.37 .

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was completed in office via computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization for all cycles/years was conducted at the site level. Randomization was stratified by the region. Each region had two or three groups: waitlist (no remedial support; year 1, cycle 1 only), treatment (Healing Classrooms Tutoring + SEL intervention), and control (Healing Classrooms Tutoring only) group sites are assigned in each region.
Clusters
Year 1: 87 Community sites, defined as an informal tent settlement or a rented building space pulling from nearby residential area Year 2: 60 Community sites, defined as an informal tent settlement or a rented building space pulling from nearby residential area
Observations
5220 students in Year 1 3000 students in Year 2
Arms
Year 1, Cycle 1: (1) no remedial tutoring support/waitlist (K = 21); (2) Healing Classrooms Tutoring Basic (K = 33); (3) Healing Classrooms Tutoring plus Low-Cost Targeted Intervention (K=33). Year 2: (1) Healing Classrooms Tutoring Basic (K = 30); (2) Healing Classrooms Tutoring plus 5-component SEL Intervention (K=30)
Primary outcomes
For access to programming versus no access to programming (Year 1, Cycle 1), the Primary Impacts are: Literacy skills, Math skills, and Perceptions of supportive classroom environment For contrast of Healing Classrooms Tutoring vs. Healing Classrooms Tutoring Plus, Primary outcomes are Executive Function skills, Emotional Regulation, Prosocial Skills, and Stress Reactivity

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords