Distributional preferences over health and income
How to cite
Hardardottir, Hjördis; Gerdtham, Ulf; Wengström, Erik. 2017. "Distributional preferences over health and income." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002108. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2108-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Gini coefficient and the concentration index for socio-economic health inequality are two widely used measures of inequality in their respective fields. Both indices implicitly make the value judgment that individuals that are equally far away from the median are weighted equally when the index is calculated. The generalized Gini coefficient (Donaldson and Weymark, 1980) and the extended concentration index (Wagstaff, 2002) both generalize the standard indices so that the value judgment enters as a separable variable that can be adjusted e.g. giving relatively higher weight to the disadvantaged part of the distribution. The aim of our study is to use surveys to elicit this inequality aversion parameter with respect to income inequality and socio-economic inequality in health. Assuming that health is increasing in income, we first elicit the ν parameter of the concentration index of socio-economic health inequality. Since the value of the ν parameter is dependent on the societies used to elicit it, we estimate ν based on two types of societies, one with high average health and relatively little variance and one with lower average health and relatively large variance. We then elicit the δ parameter of the generalized Gini coefficient (S-Gini) of income inequality. Both the ν and the δ parameters capture the relative weight respondents put on different income groups (socio-economic groups) when assessing the level of inequality in a society. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to empirically assess the δ and ν inequality aversion parameters using individual data. We also estimate the inequality aversion parameter ε of the Atkinson inequality index for inequalities in income and health, again assuming that health is increasing in income. While δ and ν measures preferences for how to weight income groups when the average health/income is constant, ε measures preferences for how to weight income groups by eliciting willingness to exchange efficiency in health/income for equity in health/income.
Experimental design
Respondents answer to an online survey about their preferences over societies presented to them. All respondents respond to four surveys that each elicit a given inequality aversion parameter. The parameters are: (i) ν of the concentration index for socio-economic health inequality (ii) δ of the generalized Gini coefficient (S-Gini). (iii) ε of the Atkinson inequality index for health inequality and (iv) ε of the Atkinson inequality index for income inequality.
In each survey, the respondent faces a series of tasks where he or she is presented with two (the surveys eliciting ε) or three (the surveys eliciting δ and ν) societies. The different societies represent the effects of a policy change in taxes (δ survey) or the health care sector (ν survey). The respondent has to pick the society he or she prefers. The societies are presented as a distribution of income or health over the group of poor, middle income and rich citizens of the society.
All four surveys come in two different versions that differ when it comes to marginal gain in health or income when the income rank increases. Each participant receives one of the versions randomly.
In all four questionnaires, respondents face a series of five questions, each comparing two societies, a society A that is the same in all questions and a society B that varies between questions. Each question locates the respondent on a certain interval which is narrowed down by repeating the task. For example, in version 1 of the δ questionnaire, the first question places subjects as having δ higher or lower than 0.7. The second question places the subject as having δ higher or lower than 1.5 etc. We only consider subjects that answer consistently while ignoring subjects that e.g. report having δ<0.7 in the first question and δ>1.5 in the second question.
In the δ (ν) survey the average health (income) is constant in all five questions while the relative standing of the three income groups in health (income) is altered. In the ε survey relative health (income) is fix between groups while the average health (income) of the B society varies across questions.
The order in which respondents answer the four surveys is random. Finally, the respondents will respond to a number of control- and background questions on family situation, income, political orientation, time- and risk preferences and health.
A first step is to conduct a pilot experiment with a reduced number of respondents (around 100) and a reduced version of the background questions, excluding questions on health. The main survey including a complete list of background questions will be sent to 1000 respondents. The respondents receive a moderate compensation for answering the survey.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.