Private vs. Public Mental Accounts: Experimental Evidence from Savings Groups in Colombia
How to cite
Salas, Luz Magdalena. 2014. "Private vs. Public Mental Accounts: Experimental Evidence from Savings Groups in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000210. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.210-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I designed and implemented a Randomized Controlled Trial to study whether simple modifications to the framing and labeling of a commitment savings product affected savings accumulations and other outcomes of low-income individuals in newly-formed Village Savings and Loan Associations in Colombia. Motivated by insights from behavioral economics, the study tests if behavioral responses vary depending on whether subjects are led to label and create ‘mental savings accounts’ in private or public ways. Individuals in the private-labeling treatment groups were led to label their savings as earmarked for a particular purpose and to state savings accumulation targets, information which was shared only privately with a member of the research team. Individuals in the public-labeling treatment groups received the same intervention but were then asked to reveal publicly and announce their chosen goals to other members of their savings group. The average treatment effects of the public-labeling intervention are very strong and significant. Savings accumulations increased by an average of 35% and savings goals were 8.5% more likely to be reached in comparison to the untreated group. Further results strongly suggest evidence of differentiated behavioral responses of individuals in the private-labeling treatment group: private commitment to a savings goal is more effective for individuals who, after random assignment but prior to the intervention, had been measured to be less constrained by economic circumstances and institutional barriers.
Intervention
The RCT randomly assigned 137 newly formed Village Savings and Loan Associations (VSLA), mainly in rural areas from nine municipalities of Colombia into two treatments and a control group. Individuals in the control group were exposed to the standard VSLA model. In the private-labeling treatment members received an additional module with a short organized guided conversation aimed at discussing and highlighting the difficulties of committing to a savings path and the potential role and use of mental accounts in strengthening those commitments. I asked participants to voluntarily state in writing a savings purpose and weekly savings goals. This was intended to help guide individuals to form and label their mental ‘savings’ account to privately commit to achieving that savings purpose. Goals were not stated publicly. The public-labeling treatment was similar except that the group discussion encouraged members to make commitments to themselves as well as to others in their group in order to explore the possibility that this might lead to different outcomes. As in the private-labeling treatment members were asked to voluntarily state a savings purpose and weekly savings goals in writing, but in this intervention, those commitments were shared with all members of the group. By doing this, individuals explicitly label their ‘mental savings account’ and publicly commit to their own decision. Individuals were not informed about the (public) nature of the treatment prior to the public announcement. This module included a trust building game and a guided conversation aimed at highlighting the achievements of group commitments.
Experimental design
I randomly assigned newly formed VSLA to two treatments and one control group in 9 municipalities of Colombia. The assignment of the VSLA was carried out using a simple lottery and the method is called spot-randomization in which the assignment to treatment was random at the time when the VSLA was formed. For example, if 5 new VSLA were formed in a week in Cartagena, I draw the type of intervention that the VSLA would be assigned to (private, public or control). This status is maintained throughout all the experimental period. The unit of randomization is the savings group (or VSLA) and the unit of analysis is at the individual level.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.