Service Design Training vouchers for manufacturing SMEs
How to cite
Janssen, Matthijs; Hertog, dr. Pim den; Janssen, dr. Matthijs. 2017. "Service Design Training vouchers for manufacturing SMEs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002064. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2064-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite evidence that switching to service-based business models might increase their competitiveness, many manufacturing SMEs experience difficulties when trying to do so. Due to lacking awareness of its potential, the SMEs often are unable to identify tools and parties relevant for successful ‘servitisation’. In order to investigate whether policy support can make a difference, a Dutch pragmatic trial issues vouchers for manufacturing SMEs to receive service design training from public or private knowledge suppliers.
Aiming at >240 applications, the RCT is designed to grant 80 submissions and reject >160 of them. An initial benchmark survey is followed up (both amongst the intervention group and the control groups) 1 month and 13 months after the treatment period terminates. This, in combination with several case studies, generates a basis for examining the extent policy-backed service design trainings truly help manufacturing SMEs to strengthen their competitiveness.
Intervention
The core of the experiment is a voucher scheme for manufacturing SMEs to receive service design training from creative industries’ firms or knowledge institutes with relevant expertise. SMEs that are granted a randomly assigned voucher can approach a qualifying knowledge supplier with a ‘knowledge question’ related to service design. This question can range from “what is service design” in general, to more specific questions related to management, tools, or actual project development. The voucher is worth max. €4000, out of which the SME has to contribute 25%. In practice, this implies that a voucher project rewards a participating SME with a few days of interaction with one or multiple experts from the knowledge supplier. There is considerable freedom when it comes to the form and content of the pragmatic trial, as long as it meets the characteristics of service design training.
The primary research question is:
Do manufacturing SMEs that receive vouchers for obtaining service design training become more competitive than those who do not receive such support?
Experimental design
To assess the effect of the service design training vouchers, the performance of manufacturing SMEs (the unit of analysis) receiving the vouchers is compared against firms not getting any treatment. The trial type thus concerns a RCT with parallel group design.
The general set-up of the RCT involves a baseline survey, followed by two outcome surveys in later stages. The focal unit of analysis is the firm level. The items in the questionnaire are based on extensive review of literature on servitisation. All items, typically using yes/no-questions or 5-point Likert scales, are adopted from existing studies like the European Manufacturing Survey (EMS). This does not just guarantee the validity of the scales, but also opens up possibilities to benchmark the applicants against the response of those other studies. In line with the approach followed in the EMS, the benchmark and outcome survey items are based on a preference for surveying the implementation of actual practices rather than only asking for perceptions. A first outcome survey is conducted 1 month after the 4-month treatment period is over, and a second one follows 13 months later. The survey will be distributed amongst all applicants. In case there were only few of them, also control groups 2 and 3 will be addressed. Control group 2 is made up of early bird survey respondents who did not submit an actual application for a voucher. Control group 3 is the collection of firms who were not involved at all, but belong to the communities that were targeted in the recruitment strategy. Involving them would no longer fit with the principles of a RCT.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.