New Hope Project
How to cite
Miller, Cynthia. 2017. "New Hope Project." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002041. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2041-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Conceived of in the late 1980s and implemented in 1994 in two inner-city areas in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, New Hope was an innovative program designed to address problems in the low-wage labor market. Based on the simple premise that people who work full time should not be poor, New Hope provided full-time workers with several benefits: an earnings supplement to raise their income above poverty, low-cost health insurance, and subsidized child care. For those unable to find full-time work, the program offered help in finding a job and referral to a wage-paying community service job when necessary. During the demonstration project, each of these benefits was available for up to three years.
New Hope’s designers expected that its combination of benefits and services would have the direct effects of increasing parents’ employment and income and their use of health insurance and licensed child care. These effects, in turn, might influence the well-being of these adults and their families. MDRC, along with researchers from the University of Texas at Austin, UCLA, Northwestern University, and the University of North Carolina, examined New Hope’s effects in a large-scale random assignment study. The eight-year findings show that work supports can have a range of positive effects on low-income families and their children. Although the economic effects on employment and income lasted for most families only during the three years in which New Hope operated, some effects on children lasted into the longer term:
-- Employment, income, and parents’ well-being. Adults in the New Hope program were more likely to work than their control group counterparts, and the combination of earnings supplements and the Earned Income Tax Credit also resulted in higher incomes. Less consistently, New Hope also had some effects on parents’ well-being. Most of these effects did not last beyond the three years that the program operated — except for a subgroup of individuals facing moderate barriers to work, for whom New Hope increased employment, earnings, and income through Year 8.
-- Children’s environments. New Hope affected children’s environments by increasing parents’ use of center-based child care — an effect that persisted through Year 5, or two years after New Hope child care subsidies had ended. By Year 5 and lasting into Year 8, New Hope led children and youth to spend more time in structured, supervised out-of-school activities.
-- Children’s development. Positive effects on children’s academic performance and test scores were evident at the two- and five-year marks. By Year 8, effects on performance had faded, and new effects had emerged. New Hope children reported being more engaged in school than control group children, and their parents were less likely than control group parents to report that their children had repeated a grade, received poor grades, or been placed in special education. New Hope also improved children’s positive social behavior, effects that lasted through Year 8. At the eight-year point, New Hope adolescents were less likely than their control group counterparts to have cynical attitudes about work and were more likely to have taken part in employment and career preparation activities.
Intervention
The final New Hope model consisted of four key components:
• Earnings supplements. New Hope offered monthly cash payments to participants when they worked at least 30 hours per week and their earnings left the household below 200 percent of the poverty line. Combined with the EITC, New Hope’s earnings supplements raised most participants’ annual household income above the federal poverty threshold.
• Health insurance. New Hope offered a health insurance plan to participants who worked at least 30 hours per week but were not covered by employers’ health insurance or Medicaid. Participants were required to contribute toward the health insurance premium on a sliding scale that took into account their income and household size; New Hope subsidized the remainder. This benefit could also be used to pay part of the participant’s cost for employer-provided insurance if that amount was greater than the required co-pay.
• Child care assistance. New Hope offered financial assistance to cover child care expenses for parents working at least 30 hours per week. Participants were asked to pay a portion of the cost, based on their income and household size, and New Hope covered the remainder. New Hope provided assistance only for child care provided in state-licensed or county-certified homes or child care centers.
• Job access. Participants who were unemployed or who wanted to change jobs received individualized job search assistance. If they could not find work in the regular job market after an eight-week job search, they could apply for a community service job (CSJ) in a nonprofit organization. These opportunities were also offered to participants who were between jobs or who were employed but not working the 30-hour minimum. The CSJs paid minimum wage and might be either full time or part time.
Participants in New Hope who met the 30-hour work requirement could use any number or combination of program benefits and services, depending on their needs. Benefits were administered by project representatives who could provide advice and information about employment (for example, help in finding a job), child care, or other topics.
Eligibility for earnings supplements, health insurance, and child care assistance lasted for three years. The time limits reflected funding constraints and were not considered integral to the program’s design. Rather, New Hope’s designers assumed that benefits would need to be available as long as individuals met the eligibility criteria, if New Hope were to become ongoing policy.
Experimental design
Individuals were eligible for New Hope if they lived in one of the targeted neighborhoods, were age 18 or older, had earnings of less than 150 percent of the federal poverty level, and were willing and able to work full time. Unlike many programs at the time and still today, New Hope eligibility did not depend on the presence of children or family structure. It was open to men and women who were working or not, on welfare or not, married or unmarried, and living with or without children. The two targeted neighborhoods were selected to provide racial and ethnic diversity and to concentrate the program on inner-city, high-poverty areas.
Program applicants who met New Hope’s eligibility criteria were randomly assigned to one of two groups: a program group that could participate in New Hope or a control group that could not.
Most of the information on New Hope’s operations comes from field research interviews with participants and staff working for the program, a review of program documents, and focus groups held with staff and participants. Material describing the members of the research sample at enrollment, and used to group them for various analyses, came from an enrollment form and a survey of opinions about employment. Each was completed prior to random assignment. A database maintained by the program as its management information system provided data on the use of benefits by all program participants.
A variety of administrative records were used to assess New Hope’s effects. Unemployment insurance earnings records measured quarterly earnings and employment. Public assistance benefit records documented welfare payments, Food Stamps, and Medicaid benefits. Tax records provided information on the receipt of Earned Income Credits.
Follow-up surveys measured receipt of non-New Hope services; many economic outcomes such as hours of work, hourly wages, and the type of jobs held; and all the noneconomic outcomes regarding family functioning, parent well-being, and child development. In addition, the research team conducted an ethnographic study of 46 families for 3 years.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Huston, Aletha, Jessica Thornton Walker, Chantelle Dowsett, Amy E. Imes, and Angelica Ware. 2008. Long-Term Effects of New Hope on Children’s Academic Achievement and Achievement Motivation. Working paper. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/long-term-effects-new-hope-children-s-academic-achievement-and-achievement-motivation
- McLoyd, Vonnie, Rachel Kaplan, and Kelly M. Purtell. 2008. New Hope’s Effects on Children’s Future Orientation and Employment Experiences. Working paper. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/new-hope-s-effects-children-s-future-orientation-and-employment-experiences
- Huston, Aletha, Anjali E. Gupta, Alison C. Bentley, Chantelle Dowsett, Angelica Ware, and Sylvia R. Epps. 2008. New Hope’s Effects on Social Behavior, Parenting, and Activities at Eight Years. Working paper. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/new-hope-s-effects-social-behavior-parenting-and-activities-eight-years
- Duncan, Greg, Cynthia Miller, Amy Classens, Mimi Engel, Heather Hill, and Constance Lindsay. 2008. New Hope’s Eight-Year Impacts on Employment and Family Income. Working paper. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/new-hope-s-eight-year-impacts-employment-and-family-income
- Miller, Cynthia, Aletha Huston, Greg Duncan, Vonnie McLoyd, and Thomas S. Weisner 2008. New Hope for the Working Poor: Effects After Eight Years for Families and Children. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/new-hope-working-poor
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.