Parents' Fair Share

How to cite

Miller, Cynthia. 2017. "Parents' Fair Share." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0002039. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2039-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cynthia Miller*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0002039
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.2039-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
1994-03-01 – 2001-11-01
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/2039

Abstract

Fathers provide important financial and emotional support to their children. Yet low-income noncustodial fathers, with low wages and high rates of joblessness, often do not fulfill their parenting roles. The child support system has not traditionally helped these men to do so, since its focus has been on securing financial support from fathers who can afford to pay. Meanwhile, fathers who cannot pay child support accumulate debts that can lead them to evade the system and its penalties altogether--and further limit their contact with their children.

Parents' Fair Share (PFS) was designed as an alternative to standard enforcement. Launched in 1994 in seven sites, PFS was a national demonstration program that aimed to help low-income noncustodial fathers find more stable and better-paying jobs, pay child support on a consistent basis, and become more involved parents. Funded by the organizations listed at the front of this monograph, PFS provided employment and training services, peer support groups, voluntary mediation between parents, and modified child support enforcement.

Besides designing the PFS demonstration, MDRC evaluated it. Between 1994 and 1996, each of more than 5,500 fathers was randomly assigned to PFS or a control group, and the program's effects were estimated by comparing how the two groups fared over a two-year period.

Key Findings

-- As a group, the fathers were very disadvantaged, although some were able to find low-wage work fairly easily. PFS increased employment and earnings for the least-employable men but not for the men who were more able to find work on their own. Most participated in job club services, but fewer than expected took part in skill-building activities.

-- PFS encouraged some fathers, particularly those who were least involved initially, to take a more active parenting role. Many of the fathers visited their children regularly, although few had legal visitation agreements. There were modest increases in parental conflict over child-rearing decisions, and some mothers restricted the fathers' access to their children.

-- Men referred to the PFS program paid more child support than men in the control group. The process of assessing eligibility uncovered a fair amount of employment, which disqualified some fathers from participation but which led, nonetheless, to increased child support payments.

Intervention

To be eligible for Parents' Fair Share (PFS), fathers had to be under- or unemployed and have child support orders in place but not be making regular payments. In addition, the children for whom they owed support had to be current or past recipients of welfare. In most cases, the men were referred to the program during court hearings or appointments scheduled by child support agencies. Some hearings were part of normal child support practice, and some were held specifically to determine whether nonpaying fathers were eligible for PFS. For the men who were referred to the program, participation in the PFS core activities was mandatory, and fathers were expected to participate until they found a job and started paying child support. Those who failed to participate were referred back to the child support agency for follow-up, which sometimes led to an additional court hearing. The PFS program comprised four key components:

-- Peer support. Structured around a “Responsible Fatherhood Curriculum” and run by trained facilitators, peer support sessions covered a range of topics, including parental roles and responsibilities, relationships, managing anger, and coping with problems on the job. The purpose of peer support was to inform participants about their rights and obligations as noncustodial fathers, to teach positive parenting skills, and to teach skills designed to help them stay employed.

-- Employment and training. This component was designed to help the fathers secure long-term, stable jobs at wage rates that would allow them to support themselves and their children. Program sites were encouraged to offer a variety of services, including job search assistance, job club sessions, skills training, basic education, and on-the-job training.

-- Enhanced child support enforcement. Although the child support system already had the means to enforce payments, local child support agencies in each site were asked to go beyond their traditional way of doing business. The biggest change was to focus more attention on cases that had typically received low priority — low-income, unemployed men. Sites were also expected to institute several new procedures, such as lowering the fathers’ child support orders while they participated in PFS, coordinating with PFS service providers, and quickly modifying support orders when the fathers found employment or failed to comply with PFS requirements.

-- Mediation. A father’s payment of child support and involvement with his children are influenced by his relationship with the custodial mother, which often includes disagreements about visits, household spending, child rearing, and the roles of other adults in the household. Sites were required to provide services, modeled on those used in divorce cases, to help parents mediate such differences. Participation in this component was voluntary.

Experimental design

The evaluation of Parent's Fair Share (PFS) included more than 5,000 fathers in the program’s target population. Starting in 1994, each one was randomly assigned to the PFS group, which was required to participate in the program, or to a control group.

PFS operated in seven sites:
-- Dayton, Ohio
-- Grand Rapids, Michigan
-- Jacksonville, Florida
-- Los Angeles, California
-- Memphis, Tennessee
-- Springfield, Massachusetts
-- Trenton, New Jersey

The program’s effects were assessed using unemployment insurance records, child support agency records, and surveys of a subset of fathers in the study and the custodial mothers of their children.

Design details

Randomization method
MDRC algorithm
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
n/a
Observations
5,020 men
Arms
2,495 men control, 2,525 men Parents' Fair Share
Primary outcomes
Employment, earnings, child support payments, fathers' involvement with their children

Papers from this trial

  1. Doolittle, Fred, Virginia Knox, Cynthia Miller, and Sharon Rowser. 1998. Building Opportunities, Enforcing Obligations: Implementation and Interim Impacts of Parents' Fair Share. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/building-opportunities-enforcing-obligations
  2. Miller, Cynthia, and Virginia Knox. 2001. The Challenge of Helping Low-Income Fathers Support Their Children: Final Lessons from Parents’ Fair Share. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/challenge-helping-low-income-fathers-support-their-children
  3. Knox, Virginia, and Cindy Redcross. 2000. Parenting and Providing: The Impact of Parents' Fair Share on Paternal Involvement. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/parenting-and-providing
  4. Martinez, John M., and Cynthia Miller. 2000. Working and Earning: The Impact of Parents' Fair Share on Low-Income Fathers' Employment. New York: MDRC. http://www.mdrc.org/publication/working-and-earning

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords