Cluster Randomized Trial of Social Accountability Interventions in Cambodia

How to cite

Beath, Andrew; Trang, Pham; Yen, Wei-Ting. 2017. "Cluster Randomized Trial of Social Accountability Interventions in Cambodia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001995. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1995-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andrew Beath* , Pham Trang , Wei-Ting Yen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001995
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1995-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2017-02-27 – 2019-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1995

Abstract

Despite a decade of rapid economic growth, the access of Cambodian villagers to public services and facilities is still among the lowest in the region. Such failures in service delivery are considered by development agencies and researchers to be at least partially due to limited citizen engagement with local public institutions, which in turn reduces the responsiveness of service providers to the needs of the population. In order to enhance the accountability of service providers and local officials and, as a result, improve the quality of service delivery, the Cambodian government, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and bilateral donors have – with assistance from the World Bank through the Voice and Action Program (VAP) – developed the Social Accountability Framework (SAF). Whereas evaluations of social accountability interventions in other contexts indicate that such interventions have been unsuccessful due to a failure to provide service providers and local officials with incentives to change their behavior, the design of the SAF builds on lessons from the body existing research by providing for coordinated interventions by both state and non-state actors. The Voice and Action Program (VAP) Impact Evaluation (VAP-IE) will use a randomized controlled trial conducted across 42 districts in 15 provinces of Cambodia to determine whether the coordinated interventions mandated by SAF improve the quality of educational, health, and commune services provided to villagers in rural Cambodia and increase villagers’ engagement with local government. Evidence from the VAP-IE will be used by national authorities, NGOs, bilateral donors, and the World Bank to inform future funding and design decisions related to the National Decentralization Reform. The VAP-IE is also expected to contribute to general knowledge on the efficacy of social accountability interventions by providing a rigorous assessment of whether an innovative program that coordinates interventions by state and non-state actors can be successful in enforcing accountability and improving the quality of service delivery.

Intervention

The project has three main interventions. The first is "Facilitation and Capacity Building", which will be achieved through training community accountability facilitators (CAFs). CAFs will facilitate an inclusive environment between service providers and service users. The government will also provide capacity development to local authorities and service providers to promote social accountability and effective engagement with citizens.

The second intervention is "Accessing to Information and Budget". The intervention is done through Information for Citizens (I4C) Package. The I4C Package include simple, user-friendly posters with recent (and frequently-updated) information on the commune budget, work hours, service fees and other related rights and responsibilities of service providers and service users.

The third intervention is "Citizen Monitoring". CAFs will facilitate meetings with community representatives, who collectively assess the performance of the respective commune council, health center and primary school, prioritize their concerns, and identify solutions to citizens’ prioritized concerns, and produce Joint Accountability Action Plans (JAAPs) based on those solutions. JAAPs will be publicly disseminated at district-level media events, presented at the District Integration Workshop (DIW), and will (hopefully) be incorporated in the Community Investment Plan developed during the DIW.

Experimental design

21 of 42 districts will be randomly selected to receive I-SAF activities implemented by NGOs. Implementation of I-SAF activities in these 21 districts will commence in 2017 and conclude in 2018. Activities in the 21 districts assigned to the control group will occur following the completion of the endline survey in 2018. The 42 districts contributed by respective NGOs will satisfy the following eligibility criteria: districts that have not received any SAF interventions in 2015 and 2016; districts that NGOs and the government have capacity to deliver SAF interventions to if they have to; districts that NGOs and the government are willing to postpone SAF interventions for a period of two years if assigned to the control group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in office by a computer. To increase the possibility of achieving statistical balance between the treatment and the control group and to enable inference over conditioning effects, a matched-pair randomization is employed to assign treatment. Per the procedure, districts were matched with other districts in the sample of 42 districts based on the Mahalanobis distance between aggregates of the following variables extracted from the 2010 census: district population; proportion of communes with electricity; share of population in agriculture; number of communes in district; and a dummy variable for each province.
Randomization unit
Districts
Clusters
42 Districts
Observations
3660 households; 840 local leaders (including 168 commune chiefs, 168 school directors, 168 health center staff, and 336 village chiefs)
Arms
Treatment Districts: 21 Control Districts: 21
Primary outcomes
Key outcomes include: School Enrolment, Attendance and Repetition; Test Scores; School Services and Facilities; Satisfaction with Education Quality; Unofficial Cost of Education; School Performance; School Engagement; School Awareness; Infant Mortality; Utilization of Health services; Health Services and Facilities; Access of Poor Villagers to Health Services; Cost of Healthcare; Use of Non-Professional Health Providers; Health Service Performance; Satisfaction with Health Services; Health Service Engagement; Ownership of Birth Certificates; Quality of Service Provision; Unofficial Cost of Service Provision; Access to Information; Satisfaction with Service Provision; Commune Council Performance; Attendance in VIllage or Commune Meetings; Engagement with Leaders; Social Capital; Awareness; Use of Information

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords