We examine whether people's beliefs about government debt affect their attitudes towards government spending and taxation. We first ask all of our respondents about their estimate of the current debt-to-GDP ratio in the United States. Then, we inform half of the participants about the actual current debt-to-GDP ratio. Thereafter, all of our respondents complete a series of questions measuring their attitudes towards government spending and taxation using self-reports and behavioral measures. In this document, we outline our plan for analysis of the data, including the main specifications of interest, the dimensions of heterogeneity, and corrections for multiple hypothesis testing.
Intervention
Our experiment is structured as follows: First, we inform all participants about the debt-to-GDP ratio in 1970 and ask them to estimate the current debt-to-GDP ratio in the U.S.. Second, only respondents in the treatment group receive information about the actual debt-to-GDP ratio in the U.S. in 2016 (104.81 percent).
Experimental design
Our experiment is structured as follows: First, we inform all participants about the debt-to-GDP ratio in 1970 and ask them to estimate the current debt-to-GDP ratio in the U.S.. Second, only respondents in the treatment group receive information about the actual debt-to-GDP ratio in the U.S. in 2016 (104.81 percent).
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization is done by the computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
800
Observations
800
Arms
400 receive the info treatment
400 receive no info.
Primary outcomes
We ask all of our respondents whether they think that there is too much government debt in the U.S. and whether the government should reduce the amount of debt. Thereafter, we ask them a series of questions on their attitudes towards the amount of government spending in general and on different spending categories. Subsequently, our respondents answer a series of questions on whether income taxes of different income groups should be increased or decreased, whether the government should introduce a wealth tax and whether the Estate tax should be increased or decreased.
We also add a question that allows us to understand our respondents' preferences over debt- vs. tax-financed government spending. Half of our respondents are asked whether they support the introduction of a temporary investment program on infrastructure which is financed by a temporary tax increase, while the remaining respondents are asked whether they are supportive of the same investment program financed by issuing new debt. This novel measure allows us to test whether people's beliefs about the level of government debt affect their preferences over the way new government spending is financed.
Subsequently, we explore mechanisms, such as our respondents' expectations about future taxation and government spending as well as their beliefs about the sustainability of public finances. Moreover, we measure our respondents' trust towards the government and their beliefs about the effectiveness of the government and about the corruption of politicians.\medskip
Then all respondents complete two novel behavioral measures that capture their attitudes towards government spending and the size of the government. First, they are given $5 and can decide how much to keep for themselves or how much to donate to the Cato Institute, which is an NGO advocating for downsizing the government. Second, we give all of our respondents the opportunity to sign a real online petition on the White House webpage in favor of introducing a balanced-budget rule.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.