The role of informational and credit constraints in sanitation uptake
How to cite
Malde, Bansi; Augsburg, Britta; Caeyers, Bet; Attanasio, Orazio. 2017. "The role of informational and credit constraints in sanitation uptake." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001955. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1955-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Achieving the United Nation’s ambitious target of eliminating open defecation by 2025 demands a thorough understanding of binding constraints to toilet uptake by households. In particular, adoption of safe toilets by poor households is thought to be restricted by credit and informational constraints. Safe toilets entail large investments, accounting for several months of household income for even basic low-cost options. Moreover, households may be unaware of the costs and benefits of safe sanitation. In this study, we consider the impacts of alleviating these constraints on the uptake of safe sanitation in rural India. We do so using a cluster randomised control trial in rural Maharashtra, where we randomly allocate 120 Gram Panchayats (GPs) to one of three arms: (i) access to micro-credit loans for sanitation; (ii) access to micro-credit loans for sanitation, and awareness creation activities; and (iii) a control arm where neither of these interventions was offered. Micro-credit loans could be accessed by the clients of our partner microfinance institution only. In addition to the uptake of safe sanitation, we will also consider whether the interventions improve usage of safe sanitation, and toilet quality, whether they change perceptions of costs and benefits of safe sanitation, and whether microcredit for sanitation crowds out investments on other dimensions, e.g. business. Finally, the design will also allow us to shed light on whether poor households are credit constrained, and not simply credit rationed, for sanitation investments.
Intervention
We evaluate the effectiveness of two interventions: (i) access to micro-credit for sanitation; and (ii) sanitation credit combined with awareness creation activities.
The credit intervention provides access to collateral-free, joint liability micro-credit loans for sanitation to clients of a partner microfinance institution. Only individuals who have been clients of the microfinance institution for at least 1 year are eligible to apply for a sanitation loan. The loan covers a maximum amount of Rs. 15000, charging a 22% interest rate annually at a declining balance over a 2-year repayment period. The loans are intended to be used to construct a new toilet or to repair an existing toilet.
The awareness creation activities are delivered through an NGO and disseminate information on sanitation issues to staff and clients of the microfinance institution, and to the broader community through community-wide activities. Clients of the microfinance institution receive information sessions during their weekly meetings with the loan officer, and were also invited to attend half-day branch-level workshops (Note that each branch covers a radius of around 25 km from the branch office). The community-wide activities included street plays and wall paintings, as well as engagement with community leaders to gain support for their activities and to strengthen awareness of sanitation and hygiene issues, and training of masons on how to construct different low-cost models of safe toilets. The information sessions, wall paintings and street plays disseminated the benefits of safe sanitation on health and non-health dimensions (e.g. safety of females); as well as on the availability and costs of different types of low-cost safe toilets.
Experimental design
The study covers two districts in the Indian state of Maharashtra.Within these districts, we cover 120 gram panchayats (GPs), the smallest administrative unit by the Government of India.They have been selected according to two main criteria: (i) they should fall
within currently active operational areas and (ii) neither sanitation loans nor health insurance products should have been offered at any point in time to community members by our implementing partner.
120 GPs were selected from 133 eligible GPs to be part of the study. The 120 GPs were then assigned to one of the 3 study arms (2 treatment, 1 control) through stratified random sampling, with strata defined according to the district and whether the village was large (> 480 households).
For the baseline survey, we randomly sampled around 30 households per GP stratified by (i) whether a client of our implementing partner ( Grameen Koota) lives in the household and (ii) whether a child under the age of two years lives in the household. The intervention design establishes treatment being clustered at GP level, randomly assigning GPs to different treatment groups, i.e. control, GK (provision of sanitation loans by Grameen Koota) and 'GK + ND' (provision of sanitation loans by Grameen Koota + awareness creation activities by an NGO - Navya Disha). For the endline survey, we re-survey the 3600 households sampled at the baseline (1800 clients of GK, and 1800 non-clients), and supplement this sample with a further 2400 clients sampled from women who were clients at baseline in the 120 study communities.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Britta Augsburg, Bet Caeyers, Sara Giunti, Bansi Malde, Susanna Smets, Labeled loans and human capital investments, Journal of Development Economics, Volume 162, 2023, 103053, ISSN 0304-3878. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2023.103053
- Britta Augsburg, Bansi Malde, Harriet Olorenshaw, Zaki Wahhaj, To invest or not to invest in sanitation: The role of intra-household gender differences in perceptions and bargaining power, Journal of Development Economics, Volume 162, 2023, 103074, ISSN 0304-3878 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2023.103074
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.