Correcting Beliefs about Wage Catch-Up after High Inflation: Evidence from a Survey Experiment on Labour-Market and Consumption Outcomes

How to cite

Kouvavas, Omiros; Dossche, Maarten; Schoefer, Benjamin; Kocharkov, Georgi; Botelho, Vasco. 2026. "Correcting Beliefs about Wage Catch-Up after High Inflation: Evidence from a Survey Experiment on Labour-Market and Consumption Outcomes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019499. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19499-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Omiros Kouvavas* , Maarten Dossche , Benjamin Schoefer , Georgi Kocharkov , Vasco Botelho

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019499
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19499-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-27 – 2026-11-03
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D84; E31; J31; E21; D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19499

Abstract

This project elicits the response to an information treatment on past wage catch up to inflation an experiment embedded in the ECB Consumer Expectations Survey (CES), wave 81 ad-hoc module (ref September 2026). Respondents first report when they believe average wages in their country caught up with the 2022--2023 rise in prices. A randomly assigned half is then shown the official, country-specific answer, crossed with an independent framing manipulation (own income vs.\ average wages) of a subsequent hypothetical energy-shock scenario. We pre-specify tests of within-wave updating of personal wage-catch-up beliefs and of beliefs about the persistence of wage responses to future shocks. Follow-up questions in Wave 82 (ref October 2026) re-elicit the personal catch-up belief, measures the standard 12-month wage-growth expectation and a new horizon-conditioned wage path at 1, 3, and 5 years, and collects wage-demand, consumption, and realized labour-market outcomes. The plan fixes the sample, randomization, variable construction, and multiple-testing corrections before any access to Wave 81 or Wave 82 data.

Intervention

This study embeds a randomized information-provision experiment in the ad-hoc module of the September 2026 wave of the ECB Consumer Expectations Survey (CES), a monthly online panel survey of consumers in 11 euro-area countries (approx. 19,000 respondents per round). All respondents first report a belief about when average wages in their country caught up with the 2022-2023 rise in consumer prices. Respondents are then randomly assigned to one of four groups in a 2x2 factorial design that varies (i) whether they are shown additional information relevant to that belief, and (ii) the framing of a subsequent hypothetical scenario about future income growth. All four groups complete an identical questionnaire; only the specific screens shown differ by assignment. Follow-up outcomes are measured within the same September interview and in the following month's (October 2026) wave of the same panel, covering respondents' income and inflation expectations, wage negotiation, household consumption, and labour-market behaviour. The intervention involves no deception beyond withholding information from a subset of respondents, no incentives beyond the survey's standard participation arrangements, and poses no more than minimal risk to respondents.

Experimental design

Randomized controlled trial embedded in an ongoing, nationally representative online panel survey (ECB Consumer Expectations Survey). Individual-level random assignment to one of four groups in a 2x2 factorial design (information provision x framing), stratified by country/language and recruitment method, with equal target allocation across the four cells. All groups complete the same survey instrument; only the specific screens shown differ by assignment. Outcomes are measured within the same interview and in the following month's wave of the same panel.

Design details

Randomization method
Simple random assignment (equal probability, no minimization or covariate-adaptive algorithm), implemented in real time by the fielding contractor's (Ipsos) survey-scripting software at the point each respondent reaches the relevant module.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent. Randomization is stratified by 11 country/language groups (Germany, France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, Belgium [French- and Dutch-speaking strata], Finland, Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Austria) crossed with 2 recruitment methods (CATI, CAWI), giving 22 strata, with equal target allocation across the four treatment cells within each stratum.
Clusters
Not applicable - randomization is at the individual respondent level, not clustered.
Observations
Approximately 19,000 respondents in the September 2026 (Wave 81) CES round across 11 euro-area countries, of whom approximately 14,000-14,500 respondents (about 76% retention, based on realized wave-to-wave CES retention rates) are expected to complete the linked October 2026 (Wave 82) round used for the cross-wave outcomes.
Arms
Approximately 4,750 respondents per cell in September (Group A: no information, own-income framing; Group B: no information, average-wage framing; Group C: information shown, own-income framing; Group D: information shown, average-wage framing), based on equal allocation of the approximately 19,000-respondent Wave 81 sample across the four cells of the 2x2 design. Approximately 3,600 respondents per cell are expected to remain for the October cross-wave outcomes, assuming 76% retention applied uniformly across arms (differential attrition across arms is a pre-specified robustness check).
Primary outcomes
(1) Within-subject change in the personal wage-catch-up belief between its pre-treatment (AX3010) and post-treatment (AX5030) readings, September wave. (2) Expected own-income or average-wage growth 18 months after a hypothetical energy-price shock (AX5040_3 / AX5042_3), September wave. (3) Indicator for any large-ticket household purchase, October wave. (4) Realized on-the-job search and job-search-entry indicators, and the re-elicited wage-demand percentage, October wave. (5) Re-elicited personal wage-catch-up belief (FLQ_82_2100), October wave (persistence of outcome 1). (6) Standard 12-month wage/income-growth expectation, consolidated from Q2510/Q2520/Q2530, October wave. (7) Horizon-conditioned expected real wage gap and implied catch-up horizon at 1, 3, and 5 years, constructed from FLQ_82_2300_1-3, October wave.
Secondary outcomes
(1) Descriptive distribution of prior beliefs (AX5000) relative to the official answer and the resulting informational surprise (no causal test attached). (2) Expected own-income or average-wage growth 6 months after the hypothetical energy-price shock (AX5040_1-2 / AX5042_1-2), and a categorical 18-month price-growth forecast, September wave. (3) Total nominal household consumption and each of 12 individual expenditure categories, October wave. (4) Employer change (proxied by tenure under 3 months with current employer), applications sent, and realized wage-negotiation incidence and outcome, October wave. (5) Expected real wage gap at each individual horizon (1, 3, and 5 years) taken separately, and the treatment effect on the respondent's own displayed inflation expectations (reported as a diagnostic), October wave.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords