Cash, Income Generating Activities, and Parental Training for Vulnerable Families in Malawi

How to cite

Derksen, Laura; Michaud-Leclerc, Catherine. 2026. "Cash, Income Generating Activities, and Parental Training for Vulnerable Families in Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019472. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19472-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Laura Derksen* , Catherine Michaud-Leclerc

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019472
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19472-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-01 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Malawi ()
JEL codes
I38, O12, J13, I15, I25, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19472

Abstract

Extreme poverty and harsh parenting practices can both undermine the care children receive. The family-strengthening program of SOS Children's Villages addresses these constraints on two fronts: an individually tailored package of productive assets and training intended to stimulate income-generating activities (IGA), and a positive parenting program delivered through community-based group sessions. This trial asks how the tailored IGA package compares to an unconditional cash transfer of similar value, whether parental training improves caregiving and child wellbeing, and whether the two forms of support are complementary.

In August 2025, 1,200 households enrolled in the program across four districts in Malawi were randomly assigned, with equal probability and stratified by district and baseline school enrollment, to one of four arms in a 2×2 design: the IGA package or cash, each with or without parental training. Cash and IGA support were delivered between September 2025 and April 2026. The parental training, an eleven-session curriculum covering parenting styles, fathers' involvement, child nutrition, caregiver mental health, domestic violence, alternatives to corporal punishment, parents' role in education, teen parenting, harmful cultural practices, child protection, and health-seeking, began in May 2026. The sample comprises the 1,200 randomized households and their children aged 17 or younger at endline (approximately 3,285 children).

Implementation data are measured in April 2026, shortly after the economic support was delivered and before parental training began, while main outcome measurement is in April 2027. Study A (IGA versus cash) has seven primary outcomes: school attendance, child development and learning, child nutrition, nutritional status, household cash income, consumption, and net household wealth. Secondary outcomes cover the SOS results-framework indicators of adequate care (school attendance, healthcare access, nutritional status, exposure to violence at home, and mental health) and their composite, health inputs for young children, menstrual product access, child labor, and household poverty status. We test whether effects differ by child age and gender. Study B (parental training) outcomes will be specified before endline data collection.

Intervention

Households were randomly assigned to one of four arms in a 2×2 design, crossing two forms of economic support with a parental training program.

**Income-generating activity (IGA) package.** SOS's standard livelihood intervention. Caregivers first received general financial and business management training and chose a trade. Between January and April 2026 they received trade-specific skills training and start-up assets tailored to their choice — for example, goats or pigs with livestock-management training; tailoring, welding, or salon training with equipment; irrigation training and inputs; or start-up stock for small trading businesses. The package is valued at roughly MWK 1,500,000 (approximately USD 900) per household.

**Unconditional cash transfer.** Households received MWK 1,500,000 (approximately USD 900), matching the value of the IGA package, in two equal payments of MWK 750,000: the first in October–November 2025 and the second in March–April 2026. No conditions were attached to the use of the funds.

**Parental training.** Half of the households in each economic-support arm were additionally invited to SOS's positive parenting program, delivered from May 2026 in community-based group sessions using an eleven-module curriculum: parenting styles, fathers' involvement in childcare, feeding children for healthy growth, caregiver mental health, domestic violence, alternatives to corporal punishment, parents' role in education, teen parenting and school dropout, harmful cultural practices, the child protection referral system, and health-seeking behaviours.

Experimental design

The trial is a household-level randomized controlled trial with a 2×2 factorial design. In August 2025, 1,200 households enrolled in the SOS Children's Villages family-strengthening program across four districts in Malawi were assigned with equal probability to one of four arms: (1) the income-generating activity (IGA) package, (2) IGA plus parental training, (3) an unconditional cash transfer of equivalent value, and (4) cash plus parental training, giving 300 households per arm. Randomization was stratified by district and by whether the household had any primary-school-aged child out of school at baseline (eight strata), using a pre-specified seed and a stratified randomization routine.

The design supports two comparisons. Study A compares the IGA package to cash (600 versus 600 households), pooling across the parental training arms. Study B evaluates parental training (600 versus 600 households), pooling across the economic-support arms, and examines whether its effects depend on the form of economic support.

Baseline data were collected in 2024 by SOS before randomization and cover all children under 18 in each household. The household sample is all 1,200 randomized households. The child sample is children in these households aged 17 or younger at endline (16 or younger at the implementation survey), with eligibility determined by the age recorded at each survey. The baseline masterlist identifies approximately 3,285 such children; this is approximate because masterlist ages are noisy. Implementation-survey child records whose recorded code is missing, ambiguous, or inconsistent with the masterlist (sex or age) will be matched to the masterlist before analysis, using other survey information (e.g. sex, age, enumerator, and survey timing). The endline survey will record the current age and status (interviewed, absent, moved, aged 18 or older, deceased, refused) of every child in the sample, to measure attrition. Follow-up data are collected in two rounds: an implementation survey in April 2026, after delivery of the cash and IGA support and before parental training began, and an endline survey planned for spring 2027. Each round includes a caregiver survey and an individual survey or assessment for each child, with children aged six and older interviewed directly where present and assenting. Longer-run surveys will be planned conditional on funding.

We will estimate OLS regressions of each outcome on an IGA indicator (the cash arm is the reference category), separately by survey round.

Household-level controls: stratification bin, parental-training assignment, baseline annual income (with a missing indicator), baseline number of earners, and the number of boys and of girls in the child sample according to the baseline masterlist. Child controls: age, age band (as in the heterogeneity analysis), gender, and baseline (2024) measures of the outcome, where available, and of primary outcomes 1 and 4, each with a missing indicator. Heterogeneity by child gender and age bands (0–5, 6–12, 13–17). Child age and gender, for covariates and heterogeneity, are as recorded at the implementation survey, or at endline for children without an implementation-survey record.

Standard errors clustered by household, and randomization inference p-values (10,000 replications, re-randomizing with the original assignment mechanism).

We will conduct further exploratory analyses, including to examine implementation fidelity and mechanisms, to test for robustness, and to provide greater descriptive detail.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer, using Stata's randtreat command with seed 20250812, stratified on 8 district × baseline-enrollment strata, with misfits assigned using randtreat's misfits(wglobal) option.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
1,200 households (randomization unit).
Observations
1,200 households (household-level outcomes) and approximately 3,285 children aged 17 or younger at endline (child-level outcomes). The child count is based on baseline masterlist ages, which are noisy; eligibility is determined by the age recorded at each survey. At endline, children born into sample households since baseline will be added for some outcomes and analyses.
Arms
IGA: 300 households, approx. 823 children IGA + parental training: 300 households, approx. 814 children Cash: 300 households, approx. 825 children Cash + parental training: 300 households, approx. 823 children Study A (IGA vs. cash, pooled over parental training): 600 vs. 600 households; approx. 1,637 vs. 1,648 children. Study B (parental training vs. none, pooled over economic support): 600 vs. 600 households; approx. 1,637 vs. 1,648 children.
Primary outcomes
Study A: 1. Attends school or vocational training regularly and not repeating a grade, ages 6–17, binary. Endline survey. 2. Child development and learning index: early development direct assessment adapted from IDELA and similar tools for ages 3–5 and early-grade reading and mathematics assessment subtasks (EGRA/EGMA, Chichewa and English) for ages 6 and older, standardized within age band. Endline survey. 3. Child nutrition index: meals per day and dietary diversity in the past 7 days and in the most recent hungry season, ages 3 and older, standardized index. Implementation survey and endline survey. 4. Not malnourished: BMI-for-age at or above −2 SD, enumerator-measured, ages 3–17, binary. Endline survey. 5. Household cash income, past year: enumerator-assisted reconstruction by source over the past 12 months, excluding remittances, transfers, and own-produced food, household level, continuous. Endline survey. 6. Net household wealth: savings + durable assets + productive assets + livestock + net land transactions − debt, household level, continuous. Endline survey. 7. Household consumption per capita: food consumed in the past 7 days (purchased, own-produced, or received) and non-food expenditure, valued, per household member per day, household level, continuous. Endline survey. Study B: TBC before endline data collection. Endline only.
Secondary outcomes
Study A: 1. Adequate care composite: composite of five indicators (school, healthcare access, nutritional status, violence at home, mental health), ages 3–17, binary. Endline survey. 2. Access to healthcare: no difficulty accessing healthcare for the child in the past 12 months, ages 3–17, binary. Implementation survey and endline survey. 3. Not exposed to violence at home: no physical punishment or withholding of meals, and no physical fights between adults seen at home in the past year, child-reported, ages 6–17, binary. Implementation survey and endline survey. 4. Mental health in normal range: Pediatric Symptom Checklist (PSC-10) score at or below 8, ages 6–17, binary. Implementation survey and endline survey. 5. Health inputs index: health passport, vaccination, vitamin A, deworming, and bed net use, ages 0–5, standardized index. Implementation survey and endline survey. 6. Access to menstrual products: always has access to sanitary pads or other adequate materials when needed, girls 11–17, binary. Endline survey. 7. Child labor: days worked in the past month on the family farm (ages 6+) or for pay (ages 14+), counts, implementation survey; months worked in the past year on the family farm, looking after livestock, in a household business, or for pay, ages 6+, count (0–12), endline survey. 8. No school days missed because of work in the past year, ages 6+ enrolled at some point in the past year, binary. Endline survey. 9. Consumption over the poverty line: household consumption per capita at or above the World Bank extreme poverty line, household level, binary. Endline survey. Study B: TBC before endline data collection.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords