Framing, Social Norms, and Household Investment: A Randomized Vignette Experiment in a Japanese Panel

How to cite

Wagner, Alexander; Okubo, Toshihiro. 2026. "Framing, Social Norms, and Household Investment: A Randomized Vignette Experiment in a Japanese Panel." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019469. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19469-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexander Wagner* , Toshihiro Okubo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019469
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19469-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-29 – 2027-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19469

Abstract

Shifting household savings toward investment is a stated policy goal of the Japanese government. We study whether truthful, one-sentence information and framing statements change households' willingness to invest a (hypothetical) windfall. The experiment is embedded in wave 15 (fielded in the second half of 2026) of a long-running Japanese national online panel (the NIRA-Okubo survey, where NIRA is the Nippon Institute for Research Advancement; about 10,000 respondents per wave since April 2020). Every respondent reads a short hypothetical scenario: unexpected extra income of 300,000 yen, not needed for current living costs, which can be kept in a bank account or partly or fully invested in a globally diversified investment fund. Respondents are randomly assigned, with probability one quarter each, to read one additional sentence - one of three truthful statements about such funds or about household saving in Japan - or no additional sentence. The outcome is the amount (0 to 300,000 yen) the respondent would put into the fund. The survey's household-portfolio questions, asked before the scenario, provide pre-treatment measures of actual investment behavior. The exact statements are documented in the analysis plan and hidden fields, embargoed until trial completion.

Intervention

All respondents read a short hypothetical scenario about receiving unexpected extra income of 300,000 yen and deciding between keeping it in a bank account and investing part or all of it in a globally diversified investment fund. A randomly selected quarter of respondents reads, in addition, one truthful sentence about the long-run performance of such funds; a second quarter reads one truthful sentence about the possibility of large gains and losses of such funds; a third quarter reads one truthful sentence about how Japanese households allocate their financial assets; the remaining quarter reads no additional sentence. All statements are factually accurate and sourced. The exact wording is documented in the hidden fields and the attached analysis plan, embargoed until trial completion.

Experimental design

The experiment is embedded in wave 15 of the NIRA-Okubo Japanese national online panel (NIRA is the Nippon Institute for Research Advancement; fielded in the second half of 2026 by a commercial survey company; roughly 9,000 expected completes). Continuing panelists are invited first and are not screened on employment status, and newly recruited respondents, who fill the remaining cells of the survey company's stratified design, are in employment at recruitment. The analysis sample is restricted to respondents aged 18 and over. All respondents answer the panel's standard household-portfolio questions (types of financial assets held; total financial assets), then read the hypothetical windfall scenario described in the intervention field. Respondents are randomly assigned (individual level, one quarter each) to one of three additional one-sentence statements or to no additional statement, and then state the amount of the windfall they would put into the investment fund. The windfall and the allocation are hypothetical and no money changes hands. Randomization is independent of a separate information experiment fielded elsewhere in the same questionnaire and registered separately. The assignment indicator (which of the four versions was shown) is stored permanently as a respondent-level variable, including for the group shown no additional sentence.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is carried out by the survey company's platform at the individual respondent level, at the moment a respondent begins the questionnaire. Each respondent receives an independent random draw over the eight combinations of the two experiments fielded in this wave (four conditions of this experiment, crossed with two information conditions of a separate experiment registered separately), each combination with probability one eighth. Assignment is therefore one quarter per arm for this experiment and independent of the other experiment by construction. The draw is made when the respondent enters the main survey, and a number is drawn for every respondent who enters, including those who later break off; the pattern does not change if a respondent pauses and resumes. The assignment indicator is stored permanently as a respondent-level variable. The assignment involves no blocking, no stratification and no quota balancing.
Randomization unit
Individual (respondent)
Clusters
Approximately 9,000 (clusters are individuals; individual-level randomization).
Observations
Approximately 9,000 wave-15 completes (about 2,250 per arm). Respondents under 18, whom the panel admits and who make up about 0.2 percent of a wave, are excluded from the analysis sample.
Arms
4 arms: approximately 2,250 each (long-run returns / price risk / deposit norm / no statement). The wave also carries a separate two-arm information experiment, registered separately, and the survey platform assigns respondents over the eight combinations of the two (4 x 2). Assignment to the four arms of this trial is therefore approximately one quarter each, and approximately one eighth of respondents falls in each of the eight combinations.
Primary outcomes
Amount allocated to the investment fund (numeric, 0-300,000 yen; elicited in units of 10,000 yen).
Secondary outcomes
(1) Indicator for allocating any positive amount (extensive margin). (2) Item nonresponse on the allocation question.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords