Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Randomized Experiment
How to cite
Coita, Ioana - Florina. 2026. "Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Randomized Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019449. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19449-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates how individuals perceive and respond to financial risk under uncertainty, using an incentivized 24-month simulated personal loan repayment task. Participants recruited via Prolific are randomly assigned to one of four conditions in a 2×2 between-subjects factorial design, crossing (a) outcome framing (the same financial information presented as gains vs. as losses) and (b) visibility of a running performance score (displayed vs. hidden) throughout the task. Each simulated month, participants decide how much to repay toward a fixed loan installment while managing income, expenses, and a sequence of life events common to all conditions. Behavioral outcomes — repayment amount, overdraft usage, and a composite monthly performance score — are recorded automatically each month. Participants complete a psychometric questionnaire before and after the task. The study examines whether framing and feedback visibility causally affect repayment behavior and risk-taking (overdraft use) over time, and exploratorily examines whether individual differences in psychological traits moderate these effects. An earlier version of this study was pre-registered on OSF under the name of
Neurocognitive Pathways to Risk: Affective Priming and Prediction Error in Dynamic Credit Simulation, here: https://osf.io/rd9ay/overview. The companion study performed in laboratory is named "Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision- Making Under Uncertainty: A Laboratory Experiment" also registered both AEA RCT Registry and OSF.
Intervention
The intervention consists of two orthogonal treatment manipulations embedded in a 24-
month simulated personal loan repayment task administered online via Prolific:
(1) Framing manipulation: The financial information shown to participants each month
(income, expenses, loan balance, interest, and running totals) is presented using either
gain-framed language (emphasizing what participants retain, save, or gain) or lossframed
language (emphasizing what participants owe, lose, or fall short of). The
underlying numerical values are identical across both framing conditions — only the
presentation differs.
(2) Feedback visibility manipulation: After each monthly decision, participants either see
(displayed condition) or do not see (hidden condition) their running composite
performance score.
Each participant is randomly assigned to exactly one combination of these two
manipulations (four arms: gain/displayed, gain/hidden, loss/displayed, loss/hidden) and
remains in that condition for the entire 24-month task.
Experimental design
A 2×2 between-subjects factorial design randomly assigns participants to one of four
conditions crossing outcome framing (gain vs. loss) and score feedback visibility
(displayed vs. hidden). After a pre-task psychometric questionnaire, participants
complete 24 simulated monthly decisions in a personal loan repayment scenario, facing
an identical sequence of income, expenses, and narrative life events across all
conditions—only the framing of the presented numbers and the visibility of the score
differ by condition. A post-task questionnaire assesses perceived task stress, difficulty,
and realism.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.