Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Laboratory Study

How to cite

Coita, Ioana - Florina; Peliova, Jana. 2026. "Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Laboratory Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019431. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19431-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ioana - Florina Coita* , Jana Peliova

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019431
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19431-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-06-17 – 2026-08-18
Countries
Czechia (Prague)
JEL codes
risk perception; loss aversion; framing effect; feedback; financial decision-making; household debt; behavioral economics; laboratory experiment; robustness check
Secondary IDs
Companion online trial: "Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Randomized Experiment" — AEA RCT Registry [ID after Prolific trial is published]. Earlier related design (research program precursor): "Neurocognitive Pathways to Risk: Affective Priming and Prediction Error in Dynamic Credit Simulation," OSF Registration, registered November 25, 2025. DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/RD9AY. https://osf.io/rd9ay/
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19431

Abstract

This study is a laboratory replication and robustness check of a companion online experiment (Gain-Loss Framing and Feedback Visibility in Financial Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: A Randomized Experiment, registered separately on the AEA RCT Registry — see Secondary IDs) using the same 24-month simulated personal loan repayment task and the same 2×2 design crossing outcome framing (gain vs. loss) and score feedback visibility (displayed vs. hidden). Unlike the online study, where individual participants are independently randomized, this laboratory study randomizes at the session level: each of 8 laboratory sessions (≈24–28 participants per session) is randomly assigned to one of the four conditions, and all participants in a session complete the same scenario together. The study examines whether the framing and feedback-visibility effects observed online replicate in a supervised laboratory setting, and exploratorily examines the same psychometric trait moderators as the companion study. An earlier version of this study was pre-registered on OSF under the name of Neurocognitive Pathways to Risk: Affective Priming and Prediction Error in Dynamic Credit Simulation, here: https://osf.io/rd9ay/overview.

Intervention

(1) a framing manipulation presenting the same monthly financial information using either gain-framed or loss-framed language, and (2) a feedback-visibility manipulation in which the running composite performance score is either displayed or hidden after each monthly decision. The sole procedural difference from the companion online study is the unit and method of randomization: here, treatment is assigned at the laboratory session level rather than to each individual participant.

Experimental design

A 2×2 factorial design, randomized at the session level, assigns each of 8 laboratory sessions to one of four conditions crossing outcome framing (gain vs. loss) and score feedback visibility (displayed vs. hidden). All participants attending a given session complete a pre-task psychometric questionnaire, 24 simulated monthly decisions in a personal loan repayment scenario (identical scenario content to the companion online study — only framing and feedback visibility differ by condition), and a post-task questionnaire, under supervised laboratory conditions at VŠE Prague. This study is designed as a robustness check of the companion online (Prolific) experiment using the same design and materials in a supervised, in-person setting.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer, at the session level: each laboratory session is randomly assigned to one of the four experimental conditions with equal probability before the session begins. All participants attending that session are administered the same condition (one scenario per session).
Randomization unit
Laboratory session (cluster). There is a single level of randomization at the session level; individual participants within a session are not separately randomized.
Clusters
8 laboratory sessions (approximately 2 sessions per treatment arm).
Observations
Approximately 200 participants (approximately 24–28 per session, across 8 sessions).
Arms
2 sessions (~50 participants) gain-framing/score displayed, 2 sessions (~50 participants) gain-framing/score hidden, 2 sessions (~50 participants) loss-framing/score displayed, 2 sessions (~50 participants) loss-framing/score hidden.
Primary outcomes
(1) monthly loan repayment amount relative to the scheduled installment; (2) overdraft usage (amount and duration) over the 24-month task; (3) composite monthly financial-decision score (repayment, liquidity, and overdraft sub-scores).
Secondary outcomes
Self-reported post-task stress, perceived difficulty, and realism of the task. Exploratory analyses will examine whether individual differences in psychological traits (e.g., impulsivity, emotion regulation, general wellbeing) moderate the effect of framing and/or feedback visibility on behavioral outcomes; no directional prediction is made a priori.
Sponsors
Name: Funded by the EU NextGenerationEU through the Recovery and Resilience Plan for Slovakia under the project No. 09I03-03-V04-00502. Location: Slovakia Url: https://reforms-investments.ec.europa.eu/recovery-and-resilience-facility-1/country-pages/slovakias-recovery-and-resilience-plan_en

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords