Beliefs about AI Exposure and the Demand for Redistribution: An Information Experiment in a Japanese Panel

How to cite

Wagner, Alexander; Okubo, Toshihiro. 2026. "Beliefs about AI Exposure and the Demand for Redistribution: An Information Experiment in a Japanese Panel." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019366. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19366-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexander Wagner* , Toshihiro Okubo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019366
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19366-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-29 – 2027-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19366

Abstract

We study whether beliefs about the labor-market exposure to artificial intelligence (AI) causally affect the demand for redistribution. The experiment is embedded in wave 15 (fielded in the second half of 2026) of a long-running Japanese national online panel (the NIRA-Okubo survey, where NIRA is the Nippon Institute for Research Advancement; about 10,000 respondents per wave since April 2020). Early in the survey, all respondents state a prior belief: out of 100 working people in Japan, how many are in jobs with high exposure to AI (numeric answer, 0-100). A randomly selected half of respondents is later shown a short, truthful statement, based on published staff estimates of an international organization, about the estimated share of working people in Japan in jobs with high exposure to AI. The survey's standard policy-preference question battery, identical in format to previous waves, contains the primary outcomes: support for reducing income differences between the rich and the poor, and support for uniform benefits or consumption-tax cuts financed by future tax increases. After the battery, all respondents answer a belief question about the exposed share. The panel provides pre-treatment outcomes from earlier waves, and wave 16 (early 2027) re-asks the belief and policy questions with no further information provision, measuring persistence. Treatment assignment is stored permanently as a respondent-level variable. The analysis sample is restricted to respondents aged 18 and over. The exact information text and source are documented in the analysis plan and hidden fields, embargoed until trial completion.

Intervention

A randomly selected half of respondents is shown a short information screen at a fixed position in the questionnaire. The screen contains a truthful, published estimate, attributed on screen to its source, of the share of working people in Japan who are in jobs with high exposure to artificial intelligence (AI), together with a brief statement that the form of AI's impact differs across jobs. The control half sees no information screen. All other survey content is identical across the two groups. The exact wording, number, and source are documented in the hidden fields and the attached analysis plan, embargoed until trial completion.

Experimental design

The experiment is embedded in wave 15 of the NIRA-Okubo Japanese national online panel (NIRA is the Nippon Institute for Research Advancement; fielded in the second half of 2026 by a commercial survey company; roughly 9,000 expected completes). Continuing panelists are invited first and are not screened on employment status, and newly recruited respondents, who fill the remaining cells of the survey company's stratified design, are in employment at recruitment. The analysis sample is restricted to respondents aged 18 and over, a restriction adopted for the university ethics review and applying identically across arms; it affects at most about 0.2 percent of respondents, judging by the six most recent waves. Early in the questionnaire, all respondents report a prior belief: out of 100 working people in Japan, how many are in jobs with high exposure to artificial intelligence (AI), as a numeric answer from 0 to 100, with a definition of "exposure to AI" shown to everyone. Respondents are randomly assigned (50/50, individual level) to an information group, which later sees a short truthful statement on the published estimated share (see the intervention description), or to a control group, which does not. The survey's standard policy-preference battery (about ten items, five-point oppose-support scale, format identical to all previous waves) contains the primary outcomes. After the battery, all respondents answer a belief question about the exposed share. Wave 16 (early 2027) re-asks the belief question and the battery with no information provision and no new randomization. The assignment indicator is stored permanently as a respondent-level variable. A separate, independently randomized survey module on an unrelated topic appears elsewhere in the same questionnaire and is registered separately.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is carried out by the survey company's platform at the individual respondent level, at the moment a respondent begins the questionnaire. Each respondent receives an independent random draw over the eight combinations of the two experiments fielded in this wave (two information conditions for this experiment, crossed with four conditions of a separate investment-framing experiment registered separately), each combination with probability one eighth. Assignment is therefore 50/50 for this experiment and independent of the other experiment by construction. The draw is made when the respondent enters the main survey, and a number is drawn for every respondent who enters, including those who later break off; the pattern does not change if a respondent pauses and resumes. The assignment indicator is stored permanently as a respondent-level variable. The assignment involves no blocking, no stratification and no quota balancing: group sizes are left to come out as chance determines.
Randomization unit
Individual (respondent)
Clusters
Approximately 9,000 (clusters are individuals; individual-level randomization).
Observations
Approximately 9,000 wave-15 completes (about 4,500 per arm); approximately 6,300 expected at the wave-16 follow-up (70 percent continuation, about 3,150 per arm). Respondents under 18, whom the panel admits and who make up about 0.2 percent of a wave, are excluded from the analysis sample.
Arms
2 arms: approximately 4,500 information, 4,500 control. The wave also carries a separate four-arm experiment, registered separately, and the survey platform assigns respondents over the eight combinations of the two (2 x 4). Assignment to the two arms of this trial is therefore approximately half and half, and approximately one eighth of respondents falls in each of the eight combinations.
Primary outcomes
(1) Support for reducing income differences between the rich and the poor (survey item policy22), measured on the survey's standard five-point oppose-support scale. (2) Support for uniform benefits to all citizens or consumption-tax cuts financed by future tax increases (survey item policy10), same five-point scale. Both items sit inside the panel's standard policy battery. The battery's format has been the same since 2020 - the same stem, the same five-point oppose-support scale and the same separate "don't know" option - and items that recur are worded identically across waves, but the set of items has changed as topics were added and retired: policy10 has been fielded in seven waves, policy22 in one.
Secondary outcomes
(1) Support for strengthening taxation of high earners (item policy23), same five-point scale. (2) Support for the promotion of artificial intelligence (AI) and big-data use (item policy8). (3) Support for regulating the development and use of generative AI (item policy11), same five-point scale. (4) Post-battery belief about the share of workers in jobs with high AI exposure, numeric 0-100 in the same format as the prior question (same-wave first stage). (5) Wave-16 (early 2027) re-asks of the 0-100 belief question and the policy battery, conditional on the items being re-fielded in wave 16 as agreed with the survey organization in July 2026. (6) Incidence of "don't know" responses on the primary outcome items. (7) Belief about the number of foreign workers per 100 working people (numeric, 0-100).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords