Decision making following advice from humans and AI

How to cite

Thunstrom, Linda; DePaemelere, Collin; Mollerstrom, Johanna. 2026. "Decision making following advice from humans and AI." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019360. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19360-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Linda Thunstrom* , Collin DePaemelere , Johanna Mollerstrom

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019360
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19360-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-20 – 2026-11-13
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19360

Abstract

This study examines how advice affects decision-making in an allocation task and how people evaluate the social appropriateness of different allocation choices. It also examines whether these effects differ depending on whether the advice comes from another person or from AI.

Intervention

The project consists of 3 related studies.
Study 1 (N=950): Participants are asked to rate the social appropriateness of dictator game (DG) allocations (splits of $10 between the proposer and recipient, in $1-increments). Participants are randomized into one of 5 conditions:
- control (no advice): the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness of the possible splits in the DG
- selfish-human: the participant needs to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from a human to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-human: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from a human to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient
- selfish-AI: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from an AI to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-AI: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from an AI to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient

Study 2 (N=1200): Participants are asked to choose dictator game (DG) allocations (splits of $10 between themselves and a recipient, in $1-increments). Participants are randomized into one of 5 conditions:
- control (no advice): the participant gets no advice before choosing their allocation
- selfish-human: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from a human to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-human: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from a human to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient
- selfish-AI: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from an AI to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-AI: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from an AI to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient

Study 3 (N=120): All participants are asked to predict the allocation most commonly chosen by participants in the selfish-AI-treatment in Study 2.

Experimental design

The project consists of 3 related studies.
Study 1 (N=950): Participants are asked to rate the social appropriateness of dictator game (DG) allocations (splits of $10 between the proposer and recipient, in $1-increments). Participants are randomized into one of 5 conditions:
- control (no advice): the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness of the possible splits in the DG
- selfish-human: the participant needs to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from a human to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-human: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from a human to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient
- selfish-AI: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from an AI to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-AI: the participant is asked to rate the social appropriateness in the scenario where the proposer in the DG gets advice from an AI to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient

Study 2 (N=1200): Participants are asked to choose dictator game (DG) allocations (splits of $10 between themselves and a recipient, in $1-increments). Participants are randomized into one of 5 conditions:
- control (no advice): the participant gets no advice before choosing their allocation
- selfish-human: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from a human to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-human: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from a human to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient
- selfish-AI: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from an AI to choose a $8/$2 split between themselves/recipient
- fair-AI: before choosing their allocation, the participant gets advice from an AI to choose a $5/$5 split between themselves/recipient

Study 3 (N=120): All participants are asked to predict the allocation most commonly chosen by participants in the selfish-AI-treatment in Study 2.

Design details

Randomization method
By computer.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
None.
Observations
Study 1: 950 individuals Study 2: 1200 individuals Study 3: 120 individuals
Arms
Study 1: 950/5=190 Study 2: 1200/5=240 Study 3: 120
Primary outcomes
Study 1: social appropriateness ratings Study 2: amount kept by proposers in the DG Study 3: predicted amount kept by proposers in Study 2
Secondary outcomes
N/A

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords