Effects of Part-Time Subject-Specialist Teachers on Student Achievement: A Cluster-Randomized Trial in Japanese Elementary Schools

How to cite

Nakamuro, Makiko. 2026. "Effects of Part-Time Subject-Specialist Teachers on Student Achievement: A Cluster-Randomized Trial in Japanese Elementary Schools." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019336. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19336-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Makiko Nakamuro*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019336
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19336-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-04-01 – 2024-05-31
Countries
Japan (Chiba)
JEL codes
I20; I21; I28
Secondary IDs
SFC Research Ethics Committee at Keio University (Approval No. 475)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19336

Abstract

Japanese elementary schools have traditionally used a homeroom-based system, in which one teacher teaches all subjects to the same class. The Japanese government is now promoting subject specialization, where different teachers teach different subjects, mainly to reduce teacher workload. However, little is known about whether this change benefits students. This study evaluates a program in Chiba Prefecture that assigned experienced retired teachers as part-time specialist teachers for mathematics or science in the fourth grade, while keeping the homeroom system in place. Among 60 public elementary schools, 20 were randomly assigned to receive a part-time mathematics specialist, 20 to receive a part-time science specialist, and 20 served as a comparison group. We measure the effects on students' academic achievement in mathematics, science, and reading, as well as their learning strategies and non-cognitive skills, using standardized tests and surveys conducted before and after the program. We also examine effects on homeroom teachers, including their working hours, workload, teaching practices, and well-being, and whether the program affected teacher-student relationships or classroom behavior. The findings are intended to inform ongoing policy discussions in Japan about expanding subject specialization in elementary schools.

Intervention

The intervention assigned part-time subject-specialist teachers to public elementary schools in Chiba Prefecture, Japan, during the 2023 academic year (April 2023 to March 2024). The specialists were retired former full-time teachers holding valid teaching licenses, recruited by the prefecture for their expertise in mathematics or science. Each specialist taught mathematics or science classes to fourth-grade students in place of the homeroom teacher, while the homeroom teacher continued to teach all other subjects and remained responsible for student guidance, grading, and evaluation. The homeroom-based system was thus preserved; the intervention changed only who taught the designated subject. Specialists taught an average of about 10 classes per week, and a single specialist could serve multiple schools, grades, or classes. Schools assigned to the mathematics treatment received a mathematics specialist only, and schools assigned to the science treatment received a science specialist only; no school received specialists in both subjects. Control schools continued with the conventional homeroom-based system, in which the homeroom teacher taught all subjects. The total number of instructional hours was unchanged in all schools, as instructional hours are fixed by the national curriculum; the intervention reallocated who delivered instruction, not how much instruction students received.

Experimental design

Learning strategies are measured using scales developed by Sato and Arai (1998), covering five domains: flexible, planning, task-oriented, cognitive, and effort-regulation strategies. Self-control is measured using the Japanese translation of the domain-specific impulsivity scale of Tsukayama, Duckworth, and Kim (2013), and self-efficacy using the Self-Efficacy for Learning and Performance subscale of the MSLQ (Pintrich et al., 1991); each consists of eight items. All indices are constructed by averaging item responses on a 5-point Likert scale and standardizing to mean zero and standard deviation one in the analytic sample. Science domain scores are constructed from test items classified into difficulty-based categories (basic, applied) and competency-based categories corresponding to Japan's national Course of Study (knowledge and skills; inquiry, reasoning, and expression; proactive attitude toward learning), each standardized in the same manner. Teacher outcomes are drawn from a survey administered by the Chiba Prefectural Board of Education in February 2024: perceived workload is an eight-item index (4-point Likert scale) aligned with the 2019 TIMSS teacher questionnaire; instructional practices follow the TIMSS 2019 classification (lecture-based, repetitive practice, inquiry-based); mental well-being is measured by the WHO-5 Well-Being Index; and growth mindset uses two items adapted from Yeager et al. (2022), with higher values indicating stronger endorsement of a growth mindset. The teacher-student relationship index is constructed from three student-reported items (whether teachers recognized students' strengths, listened to their concerns, and explained until understanding was achieved). The behavioral problems index is the sum of twelve student-reported classroom discipline items (punctuality, attendance, proper shoe arrangement, organization and orderliness, proper greetings, responsiveness, clarity of speech, polite language use, preparedness of learning materials, and others), each on a four-point Likert scale.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer, using statistical software (Stata), stratified by school district.
Randomization unit
School. Randomization was conducted at the school level (cluster randomization), stratified by school district. There is only one level of randomization; students and teachers within a school share the school's treatment status.
Clusters
60 schools
Observations
Approximately 2,780 fourth-grade students in 60 schools (1,021 in mathematics treatment schools, 852 in science treatment schools, and 913 in control schools, based on enrollment as of April 2, 2023)
Arms
20 schools assigned to the part-time mathematics specialist arm, 20 schools assigned to the part-time science specialist arm, and 20 schools assigned to the control arm.
Primary outcomes
Student academic achievement in mathematics, science, and reading, measured by standardized achievement tests administered at baseline (May 2023) and endline (May 2024). Test scores are standardized to have a mean of zero and a standard deviation of one within the analytic sample. Standardized achievement tests in mathematics, reading, and science were administered to all fourth-grade students in participating schools during regular class hours. Science tests were conducted by a separate testing provider and, in science treatment schools, administered on a different day from the mathematics and reading tests. Scores in each subject are standardized (mean 0, SD 1). Treatment effects are estimated in a value-added framework, regressing endline scores on baseline scores, treatment assignment indicators, student gender, class size, total enrollment, and randomization strata fixed effects, with standard errors clustered at the school level.
Secondary outcomes
(1) Student learning strategies: flexible, planning, task-oriented, cognitive, and effort-regulation strategies. (2) Student non-cognitive skills: self-control and self-efficacy. (3) Science achievement by domain: basic and applied items; knowledge and skills; inquiry, reasoning, and expression; and proactive attitude toward learning. (4) Homeroom teacher outcomes: working hours, lesson preparation time, perceived workload, instructional practices (lecture-based, repetitive practice, inquiry-based), mental well-being (WHO-5), and growth mindset. (5) Teacher-student relationships and classroom behavior: a student-reported teacher-student relationship index, a behavioral problems index, and twelve classroom discipline indicators.
Sponsors
Name: Chiban Prefecture (local government) Location: Chiba, Japan Url: https://www.pref.chiba.lg.jp/kyouiku/

Papers from this trial

  1. RIETI Working Paper Series, 25-E-111 https://www.rieti.go.jp/jp/publications/summary/25120001.html

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords