Gender Coordination and the Sustainability of Housing Investments: Experimental Evidence from Rural Peru

How to cite

Ruiz-Pulgar, Marcia; Acosta, Gustavo. 2026. "Gender Coordination and the Sustainability of Housing Investments: Experimental Evidence from Rural Peru." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019332. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19332-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Marcia Ruiz-Pulgar* , Gustavo Acosta

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019332
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19332-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-08 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D13, D91, O12, O18, H41, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19332

Abstract

This study evaluates whether the framing of household maintenance responsibilities affects investment in government-provided thermal housing modules in rural Peru. The modules, distributed through Peru's National Rural Housing Program (PNVR), are designed to improve thermal comfort in high-altitude and tropical communities, but their long-term benefits depend on regular household maintenance. We randomize approximately 1,700 households across approximately 150 communities into three arms: a control group that receives a placebo video, a Sphere arm that receives a video assigning maintenance activities to familiar household roles to promote role clarity and identity congruence, and a Coordination arm that receives a video reframing maintenance as a shared couple responsibility to address intra-household coordination failures. Both treatment videos contain identical practical maintenance content; the arms differ only in how responsibility for maintenance is framed. The primary confirmatory contrast is Coordination versus Sphere on an endline maintenance index, testing whether explicit coordination framing adds to the behavioral response generated by role-based framing alone.

Intervention

Households are randomly assigned to one of three arms. The control group receives a placebo video unrelated to housing maintenance. The Sphere arm receives a video that assigns four maintenance tasks, sealing wall cracks, cleaning roof gutters, keeping upper windows unobstructed, and lubricating hinges and locks, to familiar household roles, promoting role clarity and individual internalization of responsibility. The Coordination arm receives a video with identical practical content but a different relational narrative: it frames under-maintenance as a coordination failure, corrects pessimistic beliefs about the partner's willingness to contribute, and closes with a joint implementation intention. The video is shown on a tablet during the household visit immediately after a pre-video survey instrument, and assignment is auto-loaded by the survey software. The experiment is implemented in two waves. The first wave (2024 cohort, approximately 870 households) includes Control and Sphere only. The second wave (2025 cohort, approximately 870 households) includes all Sphere and Coordination only. The primary contrast, Coordination versus Sphere, is estimated from the second wave.

Experimental design

Randomization is at the household level. The trial is not cluster-randomized. Assignment is stratified by village, with households allocated across arms as evenly as village size permits. Standard errors are clustered by village at the analysis stage.

The 2024 cohort assignment was selected from 1,000 candidate random draws evaluated on the joint balance of six pre-specified covariates: sex of beneficiary, age, household size, a maintenance index, module material type, and ecoregion, using an omnibus F-test with village fixed effects. The draw maximizing the F-test p-value was selected. The same procedure will be applied to the 2025 cohort. Randomization files, seeds, and checksums are archived before field implementation.

The experiment is implemented in two waves. The first wave (2024 cohort, 870 households) uses a two-arm design with Control and Sphere. The second wave (2025 cohort, approximately 870 households) assigns all households to Sphere or Coordination with no control group, and is the confirmatory wave for the primary Coordination-versus-Sphere contrast. Both waves use identical randomization code and survey instruments.

Assignment is loaded into the CAPI survey software before fieldwork begins and is revealed to the enumerator only after the pre-video instrument is complete. Enumerators cannot select or modify the assigned arm.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-generated randomization using a documented seed and rerandomization algorithm, implemented in Stata before field implementation. Randomization is stratified by village (núcleo ejecutor): within each village, floor(N/2) households are randomly assigned to Control and the remainder to Sphere. The retained assignment is selected from 1,000 candidate draws to maximize the p-value of an omnibus F-test of covariate balance, estimated with department-by-maintenance-tertile fixed effects.
Randomization unit
Household. Within each village, households are individually randomized to treatment arms.
Clusters
NA
Observations
Approximately 1,700 households across two intervention cohorts (870 households in the 2024 cohort and approximately 870 households in the 2025 cohort).
Arms
2024 cohort: 435 households Control, 435 households Sphere. 2025 cohort (planned): 435 households Sphere, 435 households Coordination, 0 households Control.
Primary outcomes
The study has three sets of primary outcomes, all measured at the monitoring visit (midline) and endline. 1) Maintenance condition (direct observation). 2) Task completion and intra-household task allocation. 3) Decision-making and gender norms.
Secondary outcomes
1) Frequency of maintenance in the past 12 months 2) Frequency of couple conversation about the module's condition in the past 6 months 3) Whether there were disagreements in the household about whether to do maintenance 4) Partner expectation that the respondent participates in maintenance 5) Self-reported belief that preventive maintenance prolongs module life 6) Belief that a small crack not repaired quickly becomes a major problem 7) Descriptive norm: estimated share of neighbors who perform preventive maintenance 8) Thermal comfort inside the module during cold months 9) Life satisfaction 10) Information diffusion 11) Post-video comprehension 12) Immediate behavioral intention 13) Incentivized choice Exploratory health outcomes (framed as exploratory given sample size and causal chain length): Number of respiratory infections (IRAS) in the past 12 months Number of diarrheal illness episodes (EDAS) in the past 12 months Skin infections in the past 12 months Healthcare expenditure on respiratory and gastrointestinal illness School absenteeism due to respiratory or diarrheal illness (children aged 4–17)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords