Norms, Beliefs, and Determinants of Harsh Parenting: Experimental Evidence from Zambia

How to cite

Álvarez-Aragón, Pablo; Cao, Elisabetta de; Lesueur, Mathilde; Grabowska, Marta; Lagarde, Mylène. 2026. "Norms, Beliefs, and Determinants of Harsh Parenting: Experimental Evidence from Zambia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019275. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19275-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Pablo Álvarez-Aragón* , Elisabetta de Cao , Mathilde Lesueur , Marta Grabowska , Mylène Lagarde

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019275
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19275-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-03-01 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19275

Abstract

Corporal punishment and other forms of harsh discipline remain widespread in homes across sub-Saharan Africa. Yet little is known about how caregivers' acceptance of such practices depends on the child's offence, on the severity of the response, or on perceived social expectations. To answer that question, we designed a factorial vignette experiment and administer it to parents and caregivers of learners enrolled in 223 primary schools in Zambia. Each respondent is presented with a short scenario in which the vignette attributes are randomly assigned: the child's gender, the type of misbehaviour, and the mother's disciplinary response. After each vignette, respondents report their personal acceptance of the disciplinary response, their empirical and normative expectations about the community's views, how likely they would be to act in the same way, and their beliefs about the consequences of the response for the child — behavioural, relational, and developmental.

Experimental design

The study is a factorial vignette experiment embedded in the endline survey of a cluster-randomised trial evaluating a comprehensive school health program in 225 primary schools in Zambia. The vignette experiment is administered to parents or guardians of learners enrolled in these schools.
Each respondent is presented with one vignette describing a scenario in which a mother reacts to a child's misbehaviour. Vignettes take place "today, in a community similar to yours" and involve a 10-year-old child. The attributes of each vignette are randomly assigned to the respondent from a factorial design:
(a) the child's gender.
(b) the type of misbehaviour ("accidentally knocks over and breaks a clay pot while playing in the yard", " refuses to help with household chores when the mother asks", " lies about having been to school during the day when they were not", " comes home at 21 hours when the mother expected them back by 17 hours", " takes money from the mother's purse without asking", or " beats another child")
(c) the disciplinary response (slaps the child across the face", "whips the child on the legs", "grounds the child and does not allow them to go out and play", or "sits the child down and explains why their behaviour was wrong").
This yields 2 × 6 × 4 = 48 unique vignettes.
For each vignette, respondents report: (A) whether they personally find the adult's behaviour acceptable; (B) how many members of their community — out of five — would find the behaviour acceptable, and how many would react in the same way; (C) how likely they themselves would be to act in the same way; and (D) their beliefs about the likely consequences for the child.
The random assignment of vignette attributes allows experimental identification of how respondents' attitudes, social expectations, self-projected behaviour, and beliefs about consequences vary with the type of offence, the severity and nature of the disciplinary response, and the child's gender. Content and wording of the scenarios were developed on the basis of focus group discussions and key informant interviews with mothers and fathers in Ndola.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization of vignettes was conducted at the individual level.
Clusters
Using baseline sample sizes as an upper bound: - Parents: 13,255 (planned; will be lower at endline due to attrition)
Observations
Using baseline sample sizes as an upper bound: - Parents: 13,255 (planned; will be lower at endline due to attrition) - Teachers: 1,714 (planned; will be lower due to turnover) - Total planned: ~14,969 observations
Arms
Vignette experiment (unit = respondent): The vignette experiment uses within-respondent factorial randomisation, so the "arms" are the cells of the factorial design. Each respondent is randomly assigned to one cell. Expected sample sizes per level (based on baseline sample of 13,255 parents/guardians): (2 × 6 × 4 = 48 cells; ≈13,255 parents): - By disciplinary response (4 levels — talk, ground, whip on legs, slap across face): ≈3,314 parents per level - - By misbehaviour (6 levels — accidental, refuses chores, lies about school, comes home late, takes money, beats another child): ≈2,209 per level - - By child gender (2 levels — boy, girl): ≈6,627 per level - - Per full cell (misbehaviour × discipline × child gender): ≈276 parents
Primary outcomes
For each vignette shown to a respondent, we measure: 1. Personal acceptability of the adult's disciplinary response 2. Social expectations about the disciplinary response (normative and empirical expectations) 3. Personal behavioural attitude 4. Beliefs about the consequences of the disciplinary response for the child The randomization of vignette attributes allows each of these outcomes to be estimated as a function of the type of offence, the severity and nature of the disciplinary response, and the child's gender — providing experimental identification of the determinants of adult attitudes, norms, and beliefs about harsh discipline.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords