Anticipated Child Sex and Prospective Parents' Labour Supply and Childcare Intentions

How to cite

Clarke, Damian; Nazarova, Angelina; Bhalotra, Sonia. 2026. "Anticipated Child Sex and Prospective Parents' Labour Supply and Childcare Intentions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019267. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19267-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Damian Clarke* , Angelina Nazarova , Sonia Bhalotra

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019267
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19267-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-26 – 2026-10-31
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
JEL codes
J2, J7, I3
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19267

Abstract

This study collects survey data on how the anticipated sex of a first child affects prospective parents’ stated intentions regarding labour supply and childcare. Respondents aged 22 to 35, cohabiting and without children, are randomly assigned to imagine that their first child will be a daughter or a son. Randomisation is stratified by respondent sex. We then elicit expected and desired weekly working hours for the respondent and their partner, the anticipated division of childcare and household work, open-ended text on apprehensions and excitement, beliefs about raising sons and daughters, and gender role attitudes.

Intervention

Respondents are recruited via Prolific and complete a single online survey in Qualtrics (median completion time approximately 7 minutes). After a block of pre-treatment demographic and labour market questions, each respondent is randomly assigned with equal probability to one of two conditions by an embedded randomiser, stratified by respondent sex (both measured before assignment).

In both conditions respondents are asked to imagine that they and their partner are expecting their first child. The conditions differ only in the sex of the imagined child: the daughter condition asks respondents to imagine a girl, the son condition a boy. The screen displays the sentence "This is your future child" alongside a stick figure of the assigned sex. An accompanying adult figure is set by the respondent's own reported sex and is not randomised. The two conditions are otherwise identical in wording, layout and length. Assignment and receipt coincide, since every respondent reaching the vignette screen is exposed to the assigned condition; only intention-to-treat effects are estimated.

Immediately after the vignette, all respondents complete an identical outcome block: open-ended responses on their main apprehensions and on what they are excited about; expected own and partner weekly working hours when the child is aged 1 to 5; the expected division of childcare and household work; and desired own hours, partner hours and division over the same period. A subsequent block elicits preference over the child's sex and desired number of children, beliefs about whether daughters or sons are harder to raise and about maternal and paternal effort by child sex, and a five-item gender role attitudes battery. A manipulation check asks respondents to recall the sex of the imagined child.

A second, subsidiary randomisation determines whether two questions about the respondent's surprise at findings from a companion observational study appear before or after the gender role attitudes battery, since those questions reveal a research finding that could otherwise contaminate attitudes responses. The order indicator is recorded and tested.

There is no intervention outside the survey instrument; respondents receive no treatment beyond exposure to the assigned vignette.

Experimental design

A single-vignette survey experiment, fielded online through Qualtrics with respondents recruited from Prolific. Eligible respondents are aged 22 to 35, cohabiting with a partner, and have no children; eligibility is enforced through platform prescreeners rather than in-survey screening. A recruitment quota targets approximately half female and half male respondents.

Respondents first complete a pre-treatment block covering sex, age, education, ethnicity, religion, occupation, own and partner current weekly working hours, and own and partner gross annual earnings. They are then randomly assigned with equal probability to imagine that their expected first child is a daughter or a son, and immediately complete an identical outcome block: open-ended text on apprehensions and on sources of excitement; expected own and partner weekly hours for the period when the child is aged 1 to 5; the expected division of childcare and household work; and desired own hours, partner hours and division over the same period. A later block collects preferences over child sex, beliefs about raising sons and daughters, and gender role attitudes. A manipulation check asks respondents to recall the sex of the imagined child.

Estimation is intention-to-treat throughout, by OLS with mean-centred covariates interacted with treatment (Lin 2013) and stratification indicators always included, with HC1 standard errors. Covariates measured after the vignette are never used as controls. Heterogeneity by respondent sex is confirmatory and is estimated separately within men and within women, with the male-female differential and its standard error obtained from a single fully interacted pooled regression. Heterogeneity by education is designated exploratory in advance, because the design cannot detect plausible differentials on that margin.

Data collection proceeds in two stages. Stage 1 collects 200 complete responses and is assessed against four pre-specified feasibility criteria: at least 5 per cent of respondents reporting zero expected paid hours; Stage 1 filling within seven days at the offered reward; median length across the open-ended questions of at least 60 words; and at least 80 per cent passing the attention check with median completion time between 4 and 15 minutes. Continuation is conditioned on these criteria only. No treatment effect on any outcome is examined at the end of Stage 1, and continuation is not conditioned on the sign or magnitude of any estimate. Stage 1 observations are retained in the final pooled analysis in all cases. If the extensive-margin criterion fails, the study will be reported as a descriptive exercise on stated intentions and will not be presented as a test of the employment-margin result in the companion observational study.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer. Assignment is carried out by an embedded randomiser in the Qualtrics survey instrument at the point the respondent reaches the vignette screen, with equal probability to each of the two conditions. Randomization is stratified by respondent sex, collected before assignment, implemented as a separate balanced randomiser within each of the two strata. The realised assignment is written to a stored data field for every respondent, and the stratum indicator is included in all estimation. A second, independent computer randomisation within the same instrument sets the order of two question blocks in the post-outcome section; the realised order is likewise stored and tested.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Not clustered. Randomization is at the level of the individual respondent, so the number of clusters equals the number of observations: 2,510 individual respondents recruited.
Observations
2,510 individual respondents recruited, from a target analysis sample of 2,180 individual respondents with over-recruitment of 15 per cent to allow for attrition and pre-specified exclusions. Collected in two stages: 200 respondents in Stage 1 and the remainder in Stage 2.
Arms
1,255 respondents assigned to the daughter condition and 1,255 to the son condition as recruited; 1,090 per arm in the target analysis sample. Assignment is stratified by respondent sex, so each arm is designed to contain approximately 1,090 individuals in the analysis sample.
Primary outcomes
1. Labour supply reduction intention (binary): respondent expects to work fewer weekly hours when the child is aged 1 to 5 than they currently work. 2. Expectation-preference gap in own weekly working hours (continuous, hours per week): desired hours minus expected hours over the same period. 3. Expected own hours
Secondary outcomes
Confirmatory Outcomes 1. Childcare allocation (binary): respondent expects to do most of the childcare and household work. 2. Couple specialisation (binary): respondent's expected hours fall relative to current hours while the partner's hold or rise. Additional Outcomes 1. Expected own weekly hours in levels conditional on working; an indicator for expecting no paid work at all; the change in expected hours relative to current hours; partner expected hours, partner desired hours, and the partner expectation-preference gap; expected and desired division of childcare and household work in levels. 2. Standardised index of gender role attitudes (five items). Belief that daughters are harder to raise than sons; belief that mothers invest more effort in daughters than sons; the same for fathers; and the mother-minus-father effort gap, each on a signed scale from +1 (daughter) through 0 to -1 (son). Stated preference for a daughter, a son, or neither. Desired number of children, and desired number of girls and boys. 3. Text measures from the two open-ended questions asked after assignment, all expressed as counts per 100 words: first-person singular and first-person plural use and the plural share of first-person references; fear, sadness, joy, trust and anticipation categories from the NRC Word-Emotion Association Lexicon; mean valence and mean arousal from the Warriner, Kuperman and Brysbaert norms; care and harm language from Moral Foundations Dictionary 2.0; and masculine- and feminine-typed trait and activity language from word lists adapted from the item content of published gender role instruments, together with their difference. 4. Total words and total characters written across the open-ended questions, and total survey duration, estimated by median regression with OLS reported alongside.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords