Evidence on clean cooking subsidies for exclusive use, exposure, and affordability from a randomized control trial in rural Tanzania
How to cite
Gill-Wiehl, Annelise; Pillarisetti, Ajay; Chirangi, Bwire; Ray, Isha. 2026. "Evidence on clean cooking subsidies for exclusive use, exposure, and affordability from a randomized control trial in rural Tanzania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019248. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19248-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Clean stoves and fuels are largely unaffordable across Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), especially if used exclusively, the level needed to meaningfully reduce exposure and disease risk. Multi-laterals have suggested an affordability threshold of 5%, whereby cooking fuel and the amortized upfront cost of the stove over the stove’s lifetime together must not exceed 5% of consumers’ household expenditure. While reasonable given other affordability thresholds in use (water < 3% and total energy <10%), there is limited evidence to support or oppose this 5% threshold. Further, there is no evidence to suggest that even when clean fuel costs 5% of a household’s expenditure, other competing needs would not be prioritized. Thus, it is unclear whether this 5% threshold indicates affordable clean fuel in practice. Regardless, reaching this 5% threshold can be achieved either through (1) increasing incomes or (2) directly decreasing the price of fuel. The causal impact of either approach is poorly understood.
We propose a year-long, three-armed randomized controlled trial in Shirati, Tanzania to test the impact of an LPG subsidy on exclusive LPG use. The subsidy will be structured to ensure users would pay 5% of their total expenditure to have exclusive LPG use (should they buy it), delivered as either an unconditional cash transfer (UCT) or a voucher for a percentage of their cylinders. Outcomes include cooking fuel use patterns, participant’s air pollution exposure, and participant budgets. We ask: what is the impact of an LPG subsidy that would make LPG cost, in effect, 5% of expenditure on exclusive LPG use, household air pollution exposures, and household budgets? We will evaluate and compare outcomes of households subject to these two different subsidy approaches against a control group. Post-trial qualitative work will help us understand our quantitative results.
Intervention
In the first study arm, participants will receive an unconditional cash transfer. Using data from their baseline survey (household size and estimated monthly expenditure), we will estimate the cost for the participant to exclusively use LPG. Then, we will calculate the necessary UCT to ensure that exclusive use would cost the participant ~5% of her monthly expenditure. We rely on the main participant (94% women)’s expenditure, rather than household as often considered, as our previous work in this field site revealed that the woman was entirely responsible for purchasing cooking fuel from her income/stipends.
The second study arm is the subsidy treatment group in which participants will receive vouchers to obtain discounted LPG. To determine the subsidy, we will calculate what the participant would have received as a UCT, that is the monthly amount needed to make sure exclusively LPG use would only cost 5% of expenditure. We will then discount each 6kg cylinder by a percentage so that the overall subsidy over the course of each month (if used) is equal to the UCT. That is, for each participant the UCT and voucher amounts would be of equal value on a monthly basis regardless of which group they are assigned. The values are not equal across respondents, given that different household sizes and expenditures will affect both treatment arms’ approaches. Subsidy amounts are participant specific.
The final study arm is the control group. They will not receive a UCT or a fuels subsidy; however, at the end of the study, they will receive an equivalent package of household items. We will pilot in Shirati to understand what package of goods would be culturally appropriate.
Experimental design
In this proposed yearlong RCT, we will enroll households across Shirati, Tanzania, who had previously participated in an LPG RCT (n~511) (Gill-Wiehl et al. 2025), and had received two 6 kg LPG cylinder and burner kits. After obtaining consent to the study, we will conduct a baseline survey that collects information on socio-demographic characteristics and current cooking fuel use. Each respondent will be randomly assigned to one of three study arms.
Before treatment is revealed or delivered, we will ask a random subset of individuals to wear PM2.5, CO, and NO2 monitors for 24 hours, to obtain baseline exposure estimates. Those selected for exposure will also have stove use monitors on their main polluting stove for the study period. For treatment households, we return the next week to either collect the participant’s mobile money number where UCTs will be sent on the first of each month or provide the participant with a distinct ID voucher for them to receive discounted LPG from the main LPG retailers across Shirati. Voucher participants will only be allowed a certain number of subsidized LPG each month, depending on the respondent’s monthly expenditure.
After the baseline survey and exposure measurement, survey enumerators will return every other week to conduct follow-up surveys that collect information on cooking use and the respondents’ expenditure. At baseline, prior to randomization, and at four additional points throughout the study (to capture seasonality), we will ask a random subset to wear PM2.5, CO, and NO2 monitors for 24 hours to obtain exposure estimates. We estimate BC exposures through postsampling transmisometry. After a year, we will analyze the results, develop focus groups and semi-structured interview guides, and conduct qualitative work.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.