Experiment E from "Neglect at Your Own Risk: Evidence on Risk-Taking Prevalence and Motives from the Field"
How to cite
Bhargava, Saurabh; Hyde, Timothy. 2026. "Experiment E from "Neglect at Your Own Risk: Evidence on Risk-Taking Prevalence and Motives from the Field"." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019247. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19247-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Experiment E is part of a broader study of contingency neglect: the possibility that people make different risky choices when equivalent probabilities are represented as unconditional outcomes or nested conditional events. The broader study examines this mechanism in employee goal-reward choices and prescription-drug insurance; Experiment E extends it to low-probability homeowners insurance, where it may contribute to overinsurance. Participants choose among three insurance plans under one of three equivalent probability displays. We examine whether the displays change overinsurance choosing the Medium or Premium Plan rather than the Basic Plan and how post-choice probability estimates relate to choice.
Intervention
All participants complete the same insurance education, comprehension item, incentive explanation, plan menu, post-choice probability questions, liquidity question, and incentivized random-outcome procedure. The three conditions vary only in how the same objective damage distribution is described immediately before plan choice.
1. Separate damage-outcome probabilities condition: 96% chance of no damage, 1% chance of minor damage costing $750, and 3% chance of severe damage costing $2,500.
2. Any-damage and conditional-severity condition: 4% chance of any damage of at least $750 and, conditional on any damage, a 75% chance that damage is severe and costs $2,500.
3. Any-damage and severe-damage probabilities condition: 4% chance of any damage of at least $750 and 3% chance of severe damage costing $2,500.
Participants choose among a Basic Plan ($616 premium, $2,000 deductible), Medium Plan ($806 premium, $400 deductible), and Premium Plan ($926 premium, $250 deductible). Their plan choice and a randomly selected damage outcome determine a bonus between $0.00 and $1.54. The regular participation payment is $1.00.
Experimental design
This is an individually randomized online survey experiment. Participants see one condition and make one incentivized insurance-plan choice. The separate damage-outcome probabilities and any-damage plus conditional-severity conditions provide mathematically equivalent information about the same damage distribution. The any-damage plus severe-damage probabilities condition is a secondary diagnostic arm.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.