Effects of Childcare-Experience Training for Managers of SMEs: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Japan

How to cite

Yamaguchi, Shintaro; Tanaka, Mari; Okudaira, Hiroko; Yang, Chang. 2026. "Effects of Childcare-Experience Training for Managers of SMEs: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Japan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019239. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19239-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shintaro Yamaguchi* , Mari Tanaka , Hiroko Okudaira , Chang Yang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019239
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19239-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-05-16 – 2028-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J13, J16, J22, M53, M54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19239

Abstract

This study evaluates the effects of a management training program combined with a one-day childcare-center immersion experience on managers at small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Fukushima Prefecture, Japan. The project is implemented jointly by the University of Tokyo, Doshisha University, and ten municipal governments in the prefecture, in partnership with the NPO "Fathering Japan (FJ)."

The intervention has two linked components: (1) an online management-training session providing concrete knowledge and practical recommendations on family-friendly workplace management; and (2) an in-person childcare-center immersion in which managers directly observe and interact with toddlers. The guiding hypothesis is a causal chain: hands-on childcare exposure heightens managers' recognition of the practical constraints of childcare (raising their perceived burden of caregiving); this shifts their support for family-supportive workplace management and their attitudes toward fathers' caregiving and gender roles; and these shifts translate into actual family-supportive management behavior. The childcare immersion is hypothesized to be the key driver of the translation from knowledge/attitudes into behavior.

Municipalities recruit firms, each enrolling up to two managers (executives or department heads). After a baseline survey of managers and firm HR contacts, firms are paired in order of enrollment within each municipality and randomly assigned within pairs to one of two cohorts: Group A receives the program in 2026 (treatment), Group B receives the identical program one year later in 2027 (delayed / waitlist control). All participants and firms are surveyed again roughly 1–3 months after their program (Follow-up 1) and before the next cycle. A subset of employees is surveyed as a complementary, non-incentivized, employer-blind data source. The between-arm comparison in the first period (A vs B in 2026, while B is untreated) is the primary design, maintained under a no-interference (SUTVA) assumption (see the PAP); the two-cohort structure additionally permits a staggered-adoption / event-study analysis using both periods.

All survey data are collected via Qualtrics using anonymized participant IDs not linked to personal identifiers or employee ID numbers; individual responses go directly to the University of Tokyo and are never shared with participants' employers.

Intervention

Treatment has two linked components delivered to participating managers by Fathering Japan: (1) an online management-training session on supporting employees' work-family balance; and (2) a one-day in-person childcare-center immersion experience (observation of and interaction with toddlers, followed by a structured reflection with childcare staff). Group A receives both components in 2026 (training in July; childcare-center experience August–October 2026). Group B receives the identical program one year later and serves as the control group during 2026.

Experimental design

A firm-level randomized rollout with a delayed-treatment (waitlist-control) design. Within each of the 10 participating municipalities, enrolled firms are paired in order of application. Within each pair, one firm is randomly assigned to Group A (program in 2026) and the other to Group B (identical program in 2027, serving as a waitlist control during 2026). Because Group B eventually receives the same intervention, this is a delayed-treatment (staggered-adoption) design; the primary between-arm contrast is the 2026 first period, when B is untreated (maintained under a no-interference assumption; the PAP pre-registers a spillover/anticipation diagnostic).

Design details

Randomization method
Within each municipality, firms are ordered by application sequence and grouped into consecutive pairs (1st–2nd firm = pair 1, 3rd–4th = pair 2, etc.). Within each pair, one firm is randomly assigned to Group A and the other to Group B. No other stratification variables (e.g., firm size, industry) are used. Randomization is executed centrally by the research team at the University of Tokyo using an archived R script with a recorded random seed (for reproducibility); municipalities do not execute or influence assignment. Assignment is determined at the point of firm enrollment — before the firm's baseline survey is answered — and proceeds on a rolling basis as firms enroll. If a municipality has an odd number of enrolled firms, the final unpaired firm is assigned singly by an independent random draw (having no pair-mate, it is handled via the municipality-fixed-effects variant in analysis; see the PAP). At registration, allocation is still in progress.
Randomization unit
Establishment (firm for single-establishment firms).
Clusters
~200 establishments.
Observations
~350 individual managers (1–2 per firm); ~200 firm-level respondents (1 per firm); ~400 employees (complementary survey).
Arms
Group A (2026): ~100 firms / ~175 managers. Group B (2027, delayed): ~100 firms / ~175 managers.
Primary outcomes
The following 4 variables measured at the individual manager level. - PO1. Recognition of childcare constraints - PO2. Support for family-supportive workplace management - PO3. Attitudes toward fathers' involvement in childcare and gender roles - PO4. Family-supportive management behavior
Secondary outcomes
- SO1. Work–family support information-search index - SO2. Support for employees with childcare responsibilities - SO3. Communication and support-activation index - SO4. Individual work-accommodation index - SO5. Work redesign and organizational-resilience index - Additional firm survey outcomes: male and female employee childcare-leave uptake rates; availability and male usage of non-statutory childcare-related leave; availability and generosity of family-friendly HR policies (shortened hours, flextime, telework, sick-child leave, overtime exemption); overtime/long-hours measures; implementation of general work-style-reform initiatives.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords