Understanding Demand for Children: A Discrete Choice Experiment

How to cite

Michaels, Guy; Jamieson, Evie. 2026. "Understanding Demand for Children: A Discrete Choice Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019209. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19209-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Guy Michaels* , Evie Jamieson

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019209
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19209-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-22 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J13, J16, J22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19209

Abstract

Fertility has fallen to historically low levels across high-income countries, with first-order consequences for population aging, labor supply, and the financing of social-insurance systems. The household trade-offs behind this decline -- how the money and time costs of children shape family-size choices -- are difficult to identify from observational data, because those costs are not exogenous and are entangled with the preferences and circumstances that drive fertility. This study uses a discrete choice experiment (DCE) to recover US women's trade-offs between additional children, household income, and the allocation of time, independently of one another. Each of 2,000 women aged 23-35 completes ten hypothetical choice tasks comparing two descriptions of her life ten years hence; the two options independently and exogenously vary the number of additional children (0, 1, or 2), combined pre-tax household income, and a typical weekday's allocation of hours across paid work, care/household tasks, and leisure/sleep. Because income and time use are randomized independently of the number of children and of each other, the design separately identifies the money price and the time price of an additional child -- the central obstacle to recovering these trade-offs from observational data. The study's confirmatory tests are whether demand for additional children slopes down in both its money and time price and whether children are a normal good (demand rising with household income). It also examines, as an exploratory analysis identified in piloting, an asymmetry in how revealed choices track a respondent's own stated ideal family size.

Intervention

There is no real-world intervention. This is a hypothetical discrete choice experiment: the
"treatment" is the randomized variation of attributes within the survey instrument (the number of
additional children, household income, and time allocation shown in each choice task). No
respondent receives any real-world treatment, payment tied to choices, or change in circumstances.

Experimental design

A discrete choice experiment. Each respondent completes ten binary choice tasks; in each, she
compares two hypothetical descriptions of her life ten years hence and selects the one she prefers.
The two descriptions independently and exogenously vary three attributes: the number of additional
children over the next ten years, combined pre-tax household income, and a typical weekday's
allocation of hours across paid work, care/household tasks, and leisure/sleep. Because the income
and time attributes are randomized independently of the children attribute and of each other, the
design separately identifies the money price and the time price of an additional child. The exact
attribute levels, the randomization procedure, the estimation specifications, and the power
analysis are provided in the hidden experimental-design field and in the attached pre-analysis
plan, which will be released on completion.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer. Attribute combinations for the ten choice tasks are drawn independently and uniformly (rejecting fully identical option pairs) from pre-generated task sets, assigned sequentially to respondents within education stratum. The generation seed and version counts are recorded with the study materials.
Randomization unit
The scenario profile within a respondent's choice task. Within each education stratum, question sets (each of ten choice tasks) are pre-generated by drawing both scenarios' attribute profiles independently and uniformly from the 108 possible profiles (rejecting identical pairs), and are then assigned to respondents sequentially -- not at random -- within stratum. There is no respondent-level random assignment and no treatment arms; the randomization is in the drawing of the attribute profiles that populate each choice task.
Clusters
Not applicable (no clustered treatment). Randomization is at the individual-respondent and choice-task level.
Observations
2,000 women (20,000 choice tasks: 2,000 respondents x 10 tasks each).
Arms
Not applicable. The design has no fixed treatment arms; all 2,000 respondents complete ten choice tasks with independently randomized attributes. Soft recruitment targets are approximately 45% college graduates (about 900) and 55% non-college (about 1,100), subject to realized composition.
Primary outcomes
1. The choice probability of the larger-family option as a function of its money price (household income cost) and its time price (non-leisure hours cost). 2. The dependence of the money-price/income relationship on household income level (the income-interaction parameter of the demand model). 3. Willingness to pay for additional children, expressed in money and in time. Further specification of these outcomes -- estimation equations, the confidence-interval framing for the income-interaction parameter, the willingness-to-pay construction, and the education- stratum breakdowns -- is provided in the hidden fields and the attached pre-analysis plan.
Secondary outcomes
An exploratory analysis, identified during piloting, of the asymmetry between a respondent's stated ideal family size and her revealed choices.
Sponsors
Name: Guy Michaels Location: London School of Economics and Political Science Url: https://personal.lse.ac.uk/michaels/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords