The Value of Public Employment: A Survey Experiment
How to cite
Ferreira, Pedro de Souza. 2026. "The Value of Public Employment: A Survey Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019202. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19202-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study uses a survey experiment to measure how students and workers in Brazil perceive and value public employment relative to private employment. Participants report baseline beliefs about wages, job stability, and probabilities of entering public and private employment under different search strategies. They are then randomly assigned to receive aggregate labor-market information about one of these topics or to a no-information control condition. After the information module, the survey elicits expected wages, reservation wages, cross-sector switching thresholds, career-path probabilities, willingness to pay for additional information through a Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) mechanism, and choices over hypothetical jobs in a discrete choice experiment (DCE).
The main hypotheses are that public employment is valued because of a combination of perceived wages, perceived stability, perceived entry probabilities, and non-wage amenities; that information changes beliefs, downstream choices, and behavioral measures of demand for career-related information and tools; that demand for information depends on what participants already know and what information they have already received; and that the DCE can recover willingness to pay for public-sector employment, lower dismissal risk, remote work, teamwork, regular hours, and contract type. The analysis will estimate intention-to-treat effects of information on beliefs, reservation wages, crossing thresholds, BDM willingness to pay, and DCE choices, with pre-specified heterogeneity by family public-sector exposure, state, academic program or field, previous experience with concursos publicos, and selected exploratory moderators such as risk tolerance, family norms, mobility constraints, and salary-privacy norms.
The survey also includes two behavioral measures of downstream demand: whether participants click a link to sign up to receive forthcoming material related to public-sector exams, and whether they choose to enter a lottery for a three-month subscription to either QConcursos, a platform for public-sector exam preparation, or LinkedIn Premium Career, a private-sector-oriented professional platform.
Intervention
The intervention is a randomized information-provision experiment embedded in an online survey about public and private employment in Brazil. After reporting baseline beliefs about public- and private-sector wages, job stability, and entry probabilities, participants are randomly assigned to receive one short module of objective, aggregate labor-market information on one of three topics — wages, job stability, or probability of entry — or to a no-information control arm. The information is presented as group-level statistics (drawn from Brazil's PNAD Continua for comparable groups) and states explicitly that the figures describe groups and do not determine what will happen to any individual. After the information module, participants complete an incentivized Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) exercise eliciting willingness to pay for one additional information topic (which is drawn randomly among one of the three topics not yet displayed), and a discrete choice experiment (DCE) in which they choose between pairs of hypothetical jobs that vary in wage, sector, dismissal risk, remote work, teamwork, work pace, and contract type.
At the end of the survey, participants are also offered two optional behavioral choices: they may click a link to sign up to receive forthcoming material related to public-sector exams prepared by ENAP (Escola Nacional de Administração Pública), and they may choose whether to enter a lottery for a three-month subscription to either QConcursos or LinkedIn Premium Career. These are outcomes used to measure downstream demand for public-sector-related information and for career-search tools -- not additional randomizations.
Experimental design
This is an individual-level online survey experiment. The main randomization (R1) assigns each participant to one of four arms: wage information, stability information, entry-probability information, or a no-information control. A second randomization (R2) determines which not-yet-shown information topic is offered in an incentivized BDM exercise and the random price that determines whether it is delivered. A third randomization (R3) generates six pairs of hypothetical job profiles per participant, randomizing job attributes subject to logical restrictions that ensure the job profiles are credible. The main analysis estimates intention-to-treat effects of R1 assignment (relative to control) on beliefs, reservation wages and crossing thresholds, BDM willingness to pay, DCE choices, and the pre-specified behavioral outcomes measured at the end of the survey, with pre-specified heterogeneity by parental public-sector employment, state, program/field, prior concurso experience, and baseline beliefs. Risk aversion will also be considered as a heterogeneity variable. Treatment is not clustered. Respondent-level standard errors are robust to heteroskedasticity and DCE standard errors are clustered by respondent. The study is fielded to two samples — UnB undergraduates and an online sample of Brazilian workers/job-seekers — analyzed separately and, secondarily, pooled with sample fixed effects and treatment-by-sample interactions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.