The Impact of Gender-Marked Professional Titles on Individual Preferences: Evidence from a Representative Survey Experiment

How to cite

Cappelletti, Dominique; Burlacu, Sergiu; Marzadro, Sonia; Tondini, Alessandro; Gioia, Chiara; Gardi, Carolina. 2026. "The Impact of Gender-Marked Professional Titles on Individual Preferences: Evidence from a Representative Survey Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019185. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19185-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Dominique Cappelletti* , Sergiu Burlacu , Sonia Marzadro , Alessandro Tondini , Chiara Gioia , Carolina Gardi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019185
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19185-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-28 – 2026-10-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J16, C93, D91, Z13, J44
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19185

Abstract

Gender-marked language may influence attitudes, preferences, and behavior, with tangible economic consequences. In Italian, professional titles carry grammatical gender (e.g., avvocato/avvocata for lawyers), yet the feminine form remains rarely used, especially in stereotypically male professions. A pilot survey experiment conducted by the research team in 2022 found that, all else equal, female lawyers presented with the feminine title were less likely to be contacted — a penalty equivalent to roughly 10 years less experience (Burlacu et al., 2024). This study extends that design to a representative sample of the Italian adult population (N = 3,200) and to four professions that differ in gender stereotypicality, in the prevalence of women in the profession, and in the prevalence of feminine-title use (law, engineering, architecture, medicine). Through a survey experiment combining between-subject randomization of title gender-marking with within-subject variation in the mixed-title arm, we investigate: (i) the causal impact of the gender marking of professional titles on stated preferences; (ii) the mechanisms underlying the observed effects, drawing on perceived descriptive and injunctive norms about title use, first- and second-order beliefs, conformity thresholds, and individual attitudes toward gender roles and gender-inclusive language; and (iii) the prevalence of sensitive beliefs about feminine professional titles — their appropriateness, their potential to penalize women in certain professions, and their perceived ideological connotation — elicited through a list experiment.

Intervention

The study examines how the gender marking of Italian professional titles (e.g., avvocato/avvocata for lawyer) affects people’s stated preferences when choosing a professional to contact, across four professions (law, engineering, architecture, medicine). Respondents are randomly assigned to conditions that vary whether the female professional profiles they evaluate are presented with the masculine or the feminine form of the title. The survey also investigates the social norms, beliefs, and attitudes associated with the use of feminine professional titles in Italian, embedding several secondary randomized components (a label-format experiment, a list experiment, and a conformity-threshold scenario).

Experimental design

The study is an online survey experiment on a representative sample of Italian adults (SWG CAWI panel; completion time approximately 15 minutes), comprising two blocks. In Block A, respondents complete 4 rounds of profile evaluation, one per profession (law, engineering, architecture, medicine); for each profession, one service-need scenario is drawn at random from three candidates. In each round they view 4 hypothetical professional profiles (2 male, 2 female) and rate each profile on the likelihood of contacting them on a 0–10 scale. Profiles display the professional title with first and last name, year of birth, year of professional-register enrollment, and two quality signals. The gender marking of professional titles is randomized between subjects: throughout the 4 rounds, some respondents see female profiles titled exclusively with the masculine form, others exclusively with the feminine form, and others encounter both forms (one female profile with each form in every round); male profiles are always presented with the masculine form.
In Block B, respondents complete attitudinal and belief-elicitation sections: gender-typing of professions and sports (with randomized label formats), a list experiment on attitudes toward feminine professional titles, first- and second-order belief elicitation, direct attitude questions, a conformity-threshold scenario with randomized conditions, and validated attitudinal scales (POLID, Ulrich et al., 2021; Modern Sexism, Swim et al., 1995; ATGIL, Schwarz et al., 2026). Section order is fixed and designed to limit priming; item and response-option orders are randomized. All randomizations are assigned at the individual level, independently of one another.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization at the individual respondent level, implemented in software (oTree) at session start. All treatments and randomized orderings are drawn independently.
Randomization unit
Respondent level
Clusters
3,200 individuals (randomization is at the individual level; no clustering): adults (18+) residing in Italy, members of the SWG CAWI panel, representative by gender, age group, and Istat geographic macro-area.
Observations
3,200 respondents. For the vignette analysis, each respondent rates 16 profiles, yielding 51,200 profile ratings
Arms
Title treatment (vignette): ~960 respondents in T1 (all female profiles with the masculine title), ~960 in T2 (all with the feminine title), ~1,280 in T3 (mixed titles). List experiment (cross-randomized): ~960 control, ~960 “appropriateness”, ~640 “harm”, ~640 “signaling”). Label condition (gender-typing section, cross-randomized): ~1,067 respondents per arm (masculine-only, double form, field name). Conformity-threshold scenario (cross-randomized 2×2): ~800 respondents per cell (female share 25% vs 50% × feminine- vs masculine-anchored framing); ~1,600 respondents per level on each margin.
Primary outcomes
Contact-likelihood rating: the stated likelihood of contacting each profile, on an integer 0–10 scale (0 = “not at all”, 10 = “for sure”). Each respondent provides 16 ratings (4 rounds × 4 profiles).
Secondary outcomes
Moderation of the primary treatment effect by pre-specified respondent characteristics and attitudes (heterogeneity analyses) Secondary experiments to investigate potential mechanisms - list-experiment prevalence estimates of three sensitive beliefs about feminine professional titles, and the corresponding social-desirability gaps relative to direct elicitation; - gender-typing of professions and sports as an outcome of the label-format condition; - recommendations and switching points in the conformity-threshold scenario, and their responses to the female-share and framing conditions; - first- and second-order beliefs about women’s presence in the professions, feminine-title use, and the perceived appropriateness of the feminine title, including a norm-misperception wedge.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords