Peer Information and Loan Demand: A Field Experiment in Kenya

How to cite

Krenk, Ursa; Yanagizawa-Drott, David; Helmke, Stine; Cárdenas, Daniela Santos; Hernández-Pachón, Rafel; Rabino, Sara; Awuah, Kobbina. 2026. "Peer Information and Loan Demand: A Field Experiment in Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019183. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19183-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ursa Krenk* , David Yanagizawa-Drott , Stine Helmke , Daniela Santos Cárdenas , Rafel Hernández-Pachón , Sara Rabino , Kobbina Awuah

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019183
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19183-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-07-16 – 2027-03-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19183

Abstract

We study whether telling loan applicants what other borrowers ask for changes how much they themselves request. Does it matter whether the information is about male peers, female peers, or borrowers in general? And do men and women react differently?

We work with a microfinance institution in Kenya, and the study is embedded in the institution's routine loan-application phone call. Applicants are randomly assigned to hear the average requested amount of a random sample of similar past borrowers (same area and age bracket): either male applicants, female applicants, or applicants in general. A control group receives no information.

Experimental design

We study whether telling loan applicants what other borrowers ask for changes how much they themselves request and whether the behavior varies by applicant gender. Applicants are randomized into four groups: information about male peers similar to the participant, about female peers similar to the participant, about peers similar to the participant (gender neutral), or no information. The information given to the participants in the treatment arms is an average from random draws from real past applications (a sample of 5 or 20 applications, randomized, and the participants are aware of how many peers they are getting the information from).
This extra variation helps us examine mechanisms. The three treatment arms vary two things at once: the amount shown and who the information was about. Using this extra variation in the amount we can hold the information the clients were provided with fixed and test whether it is the amount or who the information is about that matters for behavior. We will also test what kind of rule borrowers follow: for example, do they only react when the number is above their own planned request? Differences between male and female applicants are of primary interest throughout.

Details
During the call, applicants first state how much they want to borrow. They are then asked what they think similar borrowers typically ask for. Applicants in the treatment groups then hear the average requested amount of a sample of comparable past applicants (male, female, or general, depending on the group); the control group hears nothing. Treated applicants are asked again about their beliefs about what other borrowers typically ask for. They are also asked some additional questions such as how common is taking a loan in their area and whether they know any other people who have borrowed from the same company. At the end, all applicants are asked whether they want to keep or change their requested amount, and it is made clear that keeping the original amount is fine. Approval and default rates are taken from the institution's records.
Our main comparisons will be:
1) Does providing gendered information (about female or male peers) have differential effects compared to providing gender-neutral information. Do these effects vary by respondent gender? The no-information group will serve as a benchmark for secondary analyses.
2) Is it the amount shown or the group it describes? The three treatment arms vary both at once: the amount and who the information is about. Because the amounts are random draws from real past applications, we can hold the amount fixed and isolate the effect of who the information describes: other men, other women, or peers in general.
3) Test whether people mainly change the requested amount when the information provided exceeds their own planned amount and whether that trigger differs by treatment group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation is done in Python
Randomization unit
Individual level. The main randomization is randomization into 3 treatment arms and control: individual level Randomization of the number of past applications underlying the information (5 or 20) (5 or 20 individuals): individual level Amount (information) randomization: individual level, amounts are independent random draws for each participant, drawn from past applications in the participant's area × age bracket (≤39 / >39).
Clusters
NA
Observations
3500-5000
Arms
Control: 525 to 750 Male-peer information: 990 to 1,415 Female-peer information: 990 to 1,415 Gender-neutral information: 990 to 1,415
Primary outcomes
Whether the applicant raises their initially requested loan amount (binary). Loan requests are typically tied to a specific planned use, so we expect information to operate mainly on the upward margin; downward revisions should be rare, and we will report them as a check on this prediction. Co-primary: whether the applicant changes their initially requested loan amount (in any direction)
Secondary outcomes
The size of the change in initial loan amount requested (in levels and logs), the applicant's beliefs about what peers ask for (before and after the information), and later administrative outcomes: the actual loan approved amount and default rates.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords