How to Increase Demand for Evidence in Policymaking: Experimental Evidence from 3,500 Elected Officials
How to cite
Zelizer, Adam; Pereira, Miguel. 2026. "How to Increase Demand for Evidence in Policymaking: Experimental Evidence from 3,500 Elected Officials." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019143. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19143-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite the growing availability of policy evidence, politicians seldom use impact evidence. We argue that demand-side constraints explain part of this gap. In a survey of 3,521 local politicians, we document two key constraints on demand for evidence: (1) knowledge about evidence quality and application, and (2) political incentives. However, these obstacles can be partially overcome. We fielded an experiment that provided randomly-selected politicians with a training course on incorporating evidence in policymaking. The training increased statistical literacy and willingness-to-pay for evidence, though political constraints continue to mediate how politicians incorporate evidence.
Intervention
We fielded an intensive training intervention that provided randomly-selected politicians in Germany, Switzerland and the United Kingdom with a capacity building course on incorporating evidence in policymaking. The course was developed in conjunction with the Joint Research Center of the European Commission. A pre-treatment survey asked about potential obstacles to the incorporation of evidence in policymaking including political and knowledge constraints.
Experimental design
We partnered with the Joint Research Center (JRC) of the European Union (EU) to evaluate a program on statistical literacy for policymakers. The JRC is a department of the European Commission responsible for providing independent advice and support to EU policy. In 2023, the JRC commissioned a training program for local elected officials aimed at better connecting scientific knowledge and policymaking. The JRC released the training materials in 2024. We embedded a streamlined version of this training in an RCT with 150 local politicians recruited in three countries: Germany, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.\footnote
To isolate the effects of attending the JRC training, we implemented a placebo design. Officials were invited to register for ``a series of online training courses on evidence-based policy making and participatory governance for local elected officials.'' When registering, officials could select one of seven training sessions, held on different dates and times. Notably, they could not choose whether they wanted the evidence-based policymaking or participatory governance training; they could only choose a date and time and were not told which session was being held. Five of the sessions were conducted in English and two in German, to accommodate officials in Switzerland and Germany, though they could also register for the English sessions.
After officials registered for a training, we randomly assigned participants to either the JRC training or the placebo training. The placebo training had the same duration (two hours) and centered on how to organize citizens' assemblies and other forms of participatory governance. It did not discuss incorporating policy evidence or expertise. The placebo sessions were conducted at the same dates and times as the JRC trainings, which means we held 14 training sessions in total.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.