Experiment A from "Neglect at Your Own Risk: Evidence on Risk-Taking Prevalence and Motives from the Field"

How to cite

Bhargava, Saurabh; Hyde, Timothy. 2026. "Experiment A from "Neglect at Your Own Risk: Evidence on Risk-Taking Prevalence and Motives from the Field"." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019138. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19138-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Saurabh Bhargava* , Timothy Hyde

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019138
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19138-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-07-06 – 2026-07-18
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
D81; D83; J33; C91; C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19138

Abstract

Experiment A is part of a larger project studying risky choice in GoalQuest, an employee rewards program in which workers choose one of three increasingly ambitious performance goals paired with increasingly valuable all-or-nothing rewards. The broader paper uses field data from GoalQuest to document excess conservative choice and choice heterogeneity, and develops a mechanism in which people evaluate nested risky options through pairwise comparisons while neglecting the relevant conditional probabilities. Experiment A addresses a key conceptual step in the project: whether behavior in a stylized GoalQuest menu resembles behavior in economically equivalent lottery menus, and whether conservative choice changes when the relevant pairwise conditional probabilities are made salient. The primary outcome is conservative choice, defined as selecting Option 1 or Option 2 rather than Option 3, which is the expected-value-maximizing option. Secondary outcomes include conditional-probability beliefs, reported decision processes, and gender differences in conservative choice.

Intervention

Participants complete an online survey in which they are introduced to one of four versions of a nested risky-choice problem. All versions present a menu of three options with increasing rewards and decreasing chances of earning the reward. The economic structure is held constant across the GoalQuest and RewardQuest conditions: Option 1 has the lowest reward and highest chance of success, Option 2 has an intermediate reward and chance of success, and Option 3 has the highest reward and lowest chance of success. The menu is calibrated so that Option 3 maximizes expected value.
The four experimental conditions are:
GoalQuest: Participants choose one sales goal from a menu of three goals. Each goal has a reward and a stated chance of being achieved.
RewardQuest: Participants choose one reward from an explicit lottery menu. RewardQuest points are determined by a random draw from 1 to 100, and the participant earns the selected reward if the points meet the selected reward threshold.
Incentivized RewardQuest: Participants make the same RewardQuest choice, but the selected reward may be implemented for real bonus payment. If the participant's coin flip is Heads, the displayed reward is converted to a bonus at 0.5 cents per $1 of displayed reward. If the coin flip is Tails, the participant receives no additional bonus from the RewardQuest choice.
Incentivized RewardQuest with pairwise information: Participants make an incentivized RewardQuest choice with the same bonus procedure and with additional pairwise conditional-probability information that makes the nested lottery structure more salient.
All conditions include instruction screens, comprehension questions, a choice menu, belief elicitation, process measures, demographic items, and feedback opportunities.

Experimental design

The study is an individually randomized online experiment. Eligible participants are randomly assigned to one of four conditions with approximately equal probability. Each participant sees only one condition.

Sample frame:
- Prolific
- 25 to 55 year olds
-US
-employed (full/part)

Sample exclusions:
- bots (as identified by Prolific)
- exceedingly fast respondents (< 2 mns)
- anyone below 98% prolific approval
- anyone with less than 20 prolific studies completed
- Qualtrics recaptchta human score < .5
-duplicate entries identified by qualtrics

Experimental design details
Participants first provide consent and confirm eligibility. They then receive condition-specific instructions and comprehension questions. Participants who answer the first comprehension question correctly proceed to the choice task; participants who miss the first comprehension question receive a second comprehension question before proceeding. The main analysis includes all valid completed responses regardless of comprehension status. Robustness analyses restrict the sample to participants who answer both comprehension questions correctly, and separately to participants who answer at least one comprehension question correctly.
After making a choice, participants report beliefs about conditional probabilities, answer process questions or provide open-ended decision explanations, and complete demographic and feedback items. In the incentivized conditions, bonus eligibility and bonus amounts are determined according to the coin-flip and exchange-rate procedure described to participants.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be implemented by the survey platform / Qualtrics randomizer, with approximately equal allocation across the four conditions. The unit of randomization is the individual participant.
Randomization unit
Individual participant
Clusters
The target sample is 1,200 valid completed responses, with 300 participants per condition. The final sample may differ modestly due to platform availability, exclusions for invalid submissions, or budget constraints.
Observations
The target sample is 1,200 valid completed responses, with 300 participants per condition. The final sample may differ modestly due to platform availability, exclusions for invalid submissions, or budget constraints.
Arms
300 / condition
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is conservative choice. Conservative choice equals 1 if the participant selects Option 1 or Option 2 and equals 0 if the participant selects Option 3. Option 3 is the expected-value-maximizing option in the experimental menu. We will report conservative choice shares by condition and estimate differences across the main adjacent condition comparisons. The main condition comparisons are: Condition 1 vs. Condition 2: GoalQuest vs. RewardQuest. Condition 2 vs. Condition 3: hypothetical RewardQuest vs. incentivized RewardQuest. Condition 3 vs. Condition 4: incentivized RewardQuest vs. incentivized RewardQuest with pairwise information.
Secondary outcomes
1) Choice distribution: The share choosing Option 1, Option 2, and Option 3 in each condition. 2) Beliefs: Participants' reported conditional-probability beliefs about the chances of also reaching the next higher threshold conditional on reaching the lower threshold. The two main belief measures are the perceived chance of reaching/earning Option 2 conditional on reaching/earning Option 1, and the perceived chance of reaching/earning Option 3 conditional on reaching/earning Option 2. 3) Belief accuracy: Differences between reported beliefs and the Bayesian conditional probabilities implied by the menu. The relevant benchmark probabilities are approximately 89 percent for Option 2 conditional on Option 1 and 88 percent for Option 3 conditional on Option 2. 4) Process measures: Responses to process questions and open-ended text about how participants made their choices, especially whether they report making pairwise comparisons between options. 5) Gender differences: Conservative choice differences by gender, overall and by condition.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords