Auto-stabilizing debt repayment schedules for common shocks: A large-scale field experiment
How to cite
Gupta, Apoorv; Mezzanotti, Filippo; Zinman, Jonathan; Eaglin, Christopher. 2026. "Auto-stabilizing debt repayment schedules for common shocks: A large-scale field experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019137. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19137-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We develop and evaluate a novel “auto-stabilizer loan” where the lender commits ex-ante to temporarily reduce borrower minimum payment requirements when exogenous shocks disrupt business activity. The sample is small business borrowers providing mass transit: minibus taxi services. We use Telematics data to identify negative shocks at the pertinent level of economic activity: minibus routes, of which there are hundreds in our sample Our partner lender offers the new auto-stabilizer loan to borrowers operating on randomly selected routes. We test how borrower repayment and effort respond to the initial commitment (i.e., the offer to switch from the regular term loan to auto-stabilizer loan, in the event of future negative shock), during a common shock event, and post-shock recovery.
Intervention
The intervention is a temporary loan modification triggered by an identified negative common shock, coupled with an ex-ante commitment to make the modification. The modification reduces the minimum required loan installment payment by approximately 75% for 3 months, with the loan term extending to accommodate the lower principal amount paid in the modification months (“the stabilization period”). The loan installment will revert to the account’s original pre-treatment amount, approximately, after the three-month stabilizing period. Borrowers can pay more than the minimum at any time, without a prepayment penalty, so the intervention is designed to give borrowers flexibility to weather an exogenous, temporary shock.
The experiment focuses on a set of small, privately-owned businesses, providing mass transport services, that have a vehicle loan with our partner lender (“partner”). The typical borrower is a closely-held small business with one owner-operated minibus taxi or a small fleet. Borrowers already have GPS devices installed in their loaned vehicles due to credit contract covenants.
The unit of randomization is an operating area for minibus taxi services: a route or cluster of overlapping/contiguous routes. The partner decided to run the experiment on 118 route-clusters (with 3,024 loan accounts): 34 route-cluster (with 942 loan accounts assigned to them at baseline) in Metro Area 1 and 84 route-clusters in Metro Area 2 (with 2,082 loan accounts assigned to them at baseline). Identifying routes, and mapping borrowers to where they operate, are technically challenging tasks, and we have developed algorithms to do so.
For each metro area, the experiment randomly assigns half of the route-clusters with at least 5 loan accounts from our partner lender to the treatment group, with remaining half to the control group. We stratify by one variable (for each metro area separately): an indicator for whether a route-cluster has more than the median number of loans provided by our lender.
The partner sends communications to treatment-group accounts before any triggering shock, then again if a shock is identified and the stabilizing modification will be triggered, and then again during the temporary modification period. Borrower take-up is opt-out: customers on route-clusters assigned to treatment arm will receive the auto-stabilizing modification, in the event of an identified negative shock, unless they opt-out beforehand. Text messages summarize the stabilizer and link to an account-customized pdf providing additional details and a summary visualization of how the new product feature works, from the borrower’s perspective. Per standard practice, communications also provide contact info for specially-trained customer service representatives who can answer questions and handle opt-out requests. Treatment-group accounts on routes that have not (yet) been triggered will also receive a monthly communication similar to what they received at program inception and that will serve as a reminder that their contract features the commitment of loan modification from the lender in the event of a trigger in the future. Treatment group also receives all business-as-usual communications (of which there are many).
Control group accounts receive only business-as-usual communications.
Experimental design
Mapping financed vehicles to routes: At baseline, each loan account is assigned to an operating area (route-cluster aka “route” below) based on proprietary algorithm that utilizes detailed driving behavior from installed telematics devices in the vehicles. We use information from last six months of driving to assign the most-frequented route for each vehicle.
Random assignment: We then identify experiment-eligible routes (those with >=5 loans financed by our lender at baseline) and assign each to Treatment or Control (50-50 probability) at baseline. An account’s assignment to a given route, and thus to T or C, will remain fixed during the duration of the experiment.
Measurement of stabilizer-triggering events: Our goal is to identify route-months where there is a substantial decrease in total activity on the route. We do this by first assigning all financed vehicles to a primary route this month (updating this dynamically each month, in contrast to our random assignment), and then calculate the median of the total distance driven by vehicles assigned to a route during the month. We then define a route to be triggered if the percentage difference between this measure in the last month and its mean over the past twelve months is below a threshold chosen by the lender ex-ante. Borrowers do not know the exact threshold: it is communicated to them as a “major disruption in your operating area”. The partner initially agreed on a 15% threshold (i.e., triggered routes are those where driving declines by more than 15%) but decided to switch to a more generous 10% threshold after the first month of implementation.
Eligibility to receive a loan modification: Receiving a modification is conditional on clearing eligibility criteria determined by the lender. In particular, an account on a treated triggered route is ineligible to receive a modification during that month if the account is under default status (90+ days delinquent). To be eligible to receive modification the account has to be less than 90 days delinquent on their loan. If not, borrowers are provided information on the minimum payments they would need to make to be eligible. As of now, each account is eligible of one loan modification during the experiment duration of 12 months, but this might be modified during the experiment duration due to the recent fuel cost shock and/or other considerations.
For the 12-month lookback period and each current month, for classifying the route as triggered or not, we only include route-months with at least 3 vehicles, since requiring more than two limits the chance of misclassifying a route as shocked on the basis of too few observations.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.