Witchcraft as a Conflict-Mitigating Institution: A Randomized Vignette Experiment in Monrovia, Liberia
How to cite
Rossignol, Etienne Le; Araujo, Daniel. 2026. "Witchcraft as a Conflict-Mitigating Institution: A Randomized Vignette Experiment in Monrovia, Liberia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019129. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19129-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We test whether witchcraft can function as an informal conflict-mitigating institution in urban Liberia. It can do so through two mechanisms. Under deterrence, a wronged person refrains from confronting a wrongdoer who is known to have access to supernatural power, for fear of supernatural retaliation. Under substitution, a wronged person who takes the grievance to a traditional healer no longer needs worldly confrontation, because the grievance is pursued through the supernatural domain instead. Each breaks the escalation chain that turns everyday wrongs into open conflict. We conduct a household survey among 600 adults across thirty communities in Monrovia, Liberia. Each respondent evaluates three randomized third-person vignettes in which a stranger (the wrongdoer) steals money from a victim's house and is later identified. We randomize, within respondent, (i) the wrongdoer's community reputation for consulting traditional healers, (ii) whether the victim takes the grievance to no one, to a social third party, or to a traditional healer, and (iii) whether the wrongdoer learns of the victim's action. Outcomes are respondents' likelihood ratings of confrontational and conciliatory reactions by each party.
Intervention
Respondents complete a household survey containing an embedded randomized vignette experiment.
Each respondent evaluates three hypothetical third-person scenarios in which a stranger enters a victim's home while the victim is away, steals money, and is later identified. Because the thief did not know whose house it was, the victim's attributes (demographics) are orthogonal to the offense by construction.
After the victim identifies the thief, we randomize, within respondent and using the survey software at form load: (i) the wrongdoer's community reputation for consulting traditional healers (our observable measure of engagement with witchcraft and access to supernatural recourse, i.e., known vs. not known to consult healers when facing problems); and (ii) the confidant the victim turns to (no one; a social third party (a friend, community leader, or pastor/priest/imam); or a traditional healer). The amount stolen and both actors' demographic attributes are also randomized per scenario.
After each scenario, respondents rate the likelihood of a range of reactions by the victim, including confrontation (arguing, threatening, fighting) and worry about physical versus supernatural harm. The experiment tests whether belief in witchcraft mitigates interpersonal conflict, through deterrence (a victim refrains from confronting a wrongdoer believed to have supernatural recourse) and substitution (a victim who takes the grievance to a healer no longer needs worldly confrontation).
Experimental design
The study is a household survey of approximately 600 adults across thirty communities in Greater Monrovia, Liberia, containing an embedded within-respondent randomized vignette experiment. Each respondent evaluates three hypothetical scenarios involving two fictional people, a victim and a wrongdoer, in which the wrongdoer steals money from the victim's home and is later identified.
Two treatments are randomized within respondent. First, the wrongdoer's community reputation for consulting traditional healers (known vs. not known). This is our measure of engagement with witchcraft and access to supernatural recourse. It is varied so that both levels appear across each respondent's three scenarios. Second, the confidant the victim turns to after identifying the wrongdoer is blocked so that each respondent sees all three conditions exactly once: talking to no one, to a social third party (a friend, community leader, or pastor/priest/imam), and to a traditional healer. The order of the three scenarios is randomized. Additional scenario features, including the amount stolen and both actors' gender, age, education, employment, and religiosity, are randomized independently in each scenario. All randomization is performed by the survey software on the data-collection tablet and stored with each submission, so that assignment is fully recoverable.
The design tests two mechanisms by which belief in witchcraft may mitigate interpersonal conflict. Under deterrence, a victim refrains from confronting a wrongdoer believed to have supernatural recourse, for fear of supernatural retaliation; this is identified from the wrongdoer's healer-reputation treatment. Under substitution, a victim who takes the grievance to a traditional healer no longer needs worldly confrontation; this is identified from the confidant treatment, comparing the healer condition to a social third party who holds constant the act of confiding while lacking the supernatural channel.
Analysis is at the respondent-scenario level, with respondent and scenario-position fixed effects and standard errors clustered by respondent.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.