Cross-Sibling Linkages in the Marriage Market

How to cite

Guha, Arigna. 2026. "Cross-Sibling Linkages in the Marriage Market." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019119. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19119-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Arigna Guha*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019119
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19119-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-07-19 – 2026-08-15
Countries
India (Lucknow District), India (Prayagraj District)
JEL codes
D13, J12, J13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19119

Abstract

Marriage is among the largest financial decisions an Indian family makes. Dowry transfers at a daughter's wedding can consume more than a year of household income, and the quality of her match shapes her economic security, autonomy, and well-being for decades. How wisely families allocate financial resources across daughters therefore matters enormously. Parents typically arrange their children's marriages in birth order. If a good elder match functions as a positive signal to the marriage market, improving how prospective grooms' families view the household, then parents can capitalise on this spillover by strategically allocating more resources to the elder daughter's match. If no such spillover exists, or if parents misjudge it, the same allocation deprives the younger sister of resources to find a suitable match. This study asks whether parents believe that an elder daughter's marriage changes the younger sister's prospects in the marriage market, whether families on the groom's side actually update their assessments in the way parents of daughters expect, and whether parents act on these beliefs when dividing marriage budgets between daughters. We conduct a vignette-based survey experiment with approximately 520 parents of marriageable-age children in two districts of Uttar Pradesh, India. Respondents advise hypothetical families on marriage proposals and budget allocations under experimentally varied family circumstances. The design separates what parents believe about cross-sibling spillovers from their willingness to act on those beliefs, and measures both sides of the same market - the beliefs held by families of brides and the beliefs held by families of grooms.The findings will show how families allocate marriage resources among daughters, whether beliefs on the bride's side match behaviour on the groom's side or a wedge separates the two, and what any such wedge implies for the efficiency of matching in the marriage market and for the design of transfer programmes tied to marriage.

Intervention

There is no field intervention in the conventional sense: this is a survey experiment in which the experimental variation is embedded in hypothetical vignettes administered within the interview. Each respondent evaluates a series of marriage-market scenarios in which we experimentally vary the circumstances of a hypothetical family, including the quality of a proposed match, the composition of the family's children, and the spacing between daughters. Respondents state beliefs about marriage-market outcomes and make advisory choices for these hypothetical families. Scenario content and presentation order are randomised across and within respondents. All scenarios concern fictional families.

Experimental design

The study is a within-subject vignette experiment conducted using a face-to-face survey of parents in two districts of Uttar Pradesh, sampled from 26 localities. Eligible respondents are assigned to one of two belief modules according to the composition of their own children, and all respondents complete a common budget-allocation module. Scenario attributes vary within respondent according to a full factorial design; scenario order is balanced across respondents using Williams Latin square designs, so that each scenario appears in each position, and follows every other scenario, with equal frequency. All experimental assignments are pre-generated by seeded computer routines, linked to anonymised respondent identifiers, and delivered automatically by the electronic survey instrument; neither enumerators nor respondents influence any assignment.

Design details

Randomization method
All experimental assignments were generated in office by seeded computer scripts and attached to pre-printed respondent identifiers before fieldwork. Within-respondent scenario orders follow Williams Latin square designs (bride side: a 4 x 4 square over family types crossed with counterbalanced groom sub-orders; groom side: counterbalanced family order crossed with a balanced set of revelation permutations). Between-respondent factors are assigned from pre-generated lists with exact balance enforced over the core sample within and across primary sampling units. PSU selection used systematic PPS with a seeded random start.
Randomization unit
All experimental assignments are at the individual respondent level. Between-respondent factors (wealth-split block; groom-side son type; allocation split; allocation cell configuration) and within-respondent presentation orders (Williams Latin square rows; Phase-1 counterbalance) are assigned to anonymised respondent identifiers in pre-generated lists, stratified and balanced within primary sampling unit (locality). Sampling, as distinct from experimental assignment, is clustered: localities are selected by systematic PPS within district, and respondents are recruited within locality subject to screening; no treatment is assigned at the cluster level.
Clusters
We survey in two districts of Uttar Pradesh (Lucknow and Prayagraj). Within each district we select 10 rural villages and 3 urban municipal wards by systematic probability-proportional-to-size sampling from the 2011 Census frame (minimum 500 households), reflecting the state's rural-urban population composition - 26 primary sampling units in total. In Lucknow district the rural frame excludes villages of Lucknow tehsil, which contains the municipal corporation. Many villages listed in the 2011 census have since become peri-urban. Two pre-specified frame-adjacent replacement PSUs are recorded for every selected PSU. We survey 20 respondents meeting screening criteria in each PSU.
Observations
Each Bride-Side respondent provides : 32 responses from the Belief Module and 6 responses from the Allocation Choice Module. Thus a total of 38 responses. Each Groom-Side respondent provides : 22 responses from the Belief Module and 6 responses from the Allocation Choice Module. Thus a total of 28 responses.
Arms
Approximately 500 total respondents: 250+ Bride-Side respondents and 250+ Groom-side respondents.
Primary outcomes
Bride-side module: (i) acceptance of the elder daughter's proposal; (ii) the believed distribution of the younger daughter's match opportunities across groom types; (iii) the perceived reputation effect of the elder's match; (iv) the believed gift value required for the younger daughter to marry a fixed high-quality groom. Groom-side module: (v) acceptance likelihood (0-10); (vi) the reservation gift value at which the respondent would advise accepting the match; (vii) the updated assessment of the proposing family. Allocation module: (viii) the binary choice between the unequal and equal budget split.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords