Effect of collective efficacy and allyship trainings on social cohesion in Nigeria

How to cite

Adida, Claire; Fisher, Rachel; Kosec, Katrina; Kyle, Jordan; Mo, Cecilia. 2026. "Effect of collective efficacy and allyship trainings on social cohesion in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019105. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19105-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Claire Adida* , Rachel Fisher , Katrina Kosec , Jordan Kyle , Cecilia Mo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019105
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19105-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-04-01 – 2027-06-01
Countries
Nigeria ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19105

Abstract

The study evaluates whether training interventions designed to strengthen women’s individual and collective efficacy and political participation influence social cohesion, and whether or not additionally training women’s husbands in male allyship further amplifies those effects. In a randomized controlled trial spanning 450 communities in southwestern Nigeria, we recruited 5,850 politically unaffiliated women into newly formed women’s groups (WGs) trained by ActionAid Nigeria. All communities first participated in an identical burn-in process in which women were recruited into WGs and received a basic civic education session during May-June 2023. Following this, communities were randomly assigned to one of three conditions: a control group that received no further programming; a treatment group (T1) that received additional intensive training in advocacy, leadership, and organizing designed to build women’s individual and collective efficacy; and a second treatment group (T2) that received the same training as T1, with parallel allyship training offered to the male partners of participating women focused on men’s role in supporting women’s empowerment and gender equality. Analysis of the first endline survey yielded encouraging evidence that intensive women’s trainings designed to foster collective action produce positive effects across both political and economic domains. This study proposes to assess whether the trainings have positive spillovers on social cohesion.

Intervention

This pre-analysis plan (PAP) builds on the original Metaketa V Nigeria study, “Women’s Action Committees and Local Services in Nigeria.” It pre-registers the analysis for a new paper on the spillovers of the study interventions on social cohesion, made possible by additional data collection not planned at the time of the original PAP registration. The study evaluates whether training interventions designed to strengthen women’s individual and collective efficacy and political participation influence social cohesion, and whether or not additionally training women’s husbands in male allyship further amplifies those effects. In a randomized controlled trial spanning 450 communities in southwestern Nigeria, we recruited 5,850 politically unaffiliated women into newly formed women’s groups (WGs) trained by ActionAid Nigeria. All communities first participated in an identical burn-in process in which women were recruited into WGs and received a basic civic education session during May-June 2023. Following this, communities were randomly assigned to one of three conditions: a control group that received no further programming; a treatment group (T1) that received additional intensive training in advocacy, leadership, and organizing designed
to build women’s individual and collective efficacy (an approximately 3 hour session once monthly over the following five months); and a second treatment group (T2) that received the same training as T1, with parallel allyship training (also an approximately 3 hour session once monthly over the following five months) offered to the male partners of participating women focused on men’s role in supporting women’s empowerment and gender equality. We carried out a first endline survey approximately 2-3 months after all trainings had concluded, and a second endline survey is planned for approximately 2.25 years after trainings conclude. The second endline will attempt to resurvey the exact same women interviewed at baseline. Some attrition is expected, and we will assess whether attrition is differential by treatment status following the same approach outlined in the original PAP and its first amendment for the original Metaketa V study. No
new data sources will be introduced. Analysis of the first endline survey yielded encouraging evidence that intensive women’s trainings
designed to foster collective action produce positive effects across both political and economic domains. This study proposes to assess whether the trainings have positive spillovers on social cohesion.

Experimental design

The intervention began with an initial burn-in meeting, identical in content and length (just over 3 hours) across all study communities (T1, T2, and control). For T1 and T2, the intervention involved selected women receiving 5 additional trainings (beyond the burn-in training also received by the control group) over a period of 5 months. Each of these trainings lasted for just over 3 hours. For T2, husbands of women participants did not receive the burn-in meeting, but they did receive five trainings of just over 3 hours where each training session focused on showcasing why men should be allies and advocates for women’s empowerment, and specific discussions around how men can be effective champions for women’s empowerment and participation

Design details

Randomization method
Bock randomized on a computer via R code.
Randomization unit
Communities
Clusters
450 (150 per treatment condition)
Observations
11,700 (13 women per cluster for 450 clusters, and 13 men per cluster for 450 clusters)
Arms
150 clusters per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
Social cohesion comprises the vertical and horizontal relations among members of society and the state, characterized by trust, inclusive identity, and cooperation for the common good (Chan et al. 2006). Within this framework, horizontal social cohesion refers to the quality of citizen-citizen relationships, or the sense of trust, solidarity, and shared purpose that holds communities together across group boundaries. It encompasses both bonding social capital (trust and attachment within groups) and bridging social capital (relationships and networks that extend across groups and societal divisions) (Putnam 2000). We measure horizontal social cohesion along two dimensions—generalized communal trust and out- group social cohesion, capturing bonding trust within the community and bridging trust across group boundaries, respectively (Putnam 2000). Considering vertical (citizen-state) trust, for both men and women, we will construct indicator vari- ables for trusting the state and authority figures. The three remaining outcomes incorporate aspects of horizontal and vertical cohesion that are especially relevant in conflict-affected settings: perceived conflict resilience capacity, perceived effectiveness of civil society and local authorities, and freedom of movement and activity in the face of insecurity.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords