Designing plant-based defaults to maximize uptake while minimizing reactance

How to cite

Green, Seth; Mathur, Maya; Chang, Kenjin; Lawrence, Natalia. 2026. "Designing plant-based defaults to maximize uptake while minimizing reactance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019102. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19102-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Seth Green* , Maya Mathur , Kenjin Chang , Natalia Lawrence

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019102
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19102-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-13 – 2026-08-24
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D91, D12, Q18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19102

Abstract

Plant-based defaults are widely touted as a scalable, sustainable solution for increasing uptake of plant-based foods. However, defaults are not a singular thing; their designs can be varied to make opting out more or less difficult, or they can be accompanied by persuasive text that promotes the change to choice architecture to participants' conscious awareness. This experiment -- a collaboration between researchers at Stanford, the University of Exeter, and the nonprofit Greener By Default -- compares four plant-based defaults in an online context on two dimensions: how much they increase uptake of plant-based food and how much reactance they engender (re: how much they annoy people). We will test four plant-based defaults in the setting of a hypothetical catered lunch to see which performs best on these two axes: a standard default where the plant-based option is pre-selected and a participant can switch to the meat option, a nonstandard default where the plant-based option is pre-selected and a user must unclick it (and then select nothing) to get a meat-based lunch, a standard plant-based default along with a message about inclusivity, and a standard plant-based default along with a message about sustainability. We will measure reactance by asking how satisfied participants were with their meal order. We will also conduct some exploratory analyses based on demographic information collected.

Intervention

Participants imagine attending an event with a free catered lunch and choose between two meals: a Tofu Bánh Mì (plant-based) and a Chicken Bánh Mì. We randomize the format in which this choice is presented. In the control condition, neither option is pre-selected. Four treatments make the plant-based meal the default: T1 pre-selects it on a standard two-option ballot; T2 presents a single pre-checked checkbox that participants must uncheck to receive the chicken option instead; T3 and T4 use the T1 ballot plus a short justification, framing the plant-based meal as the most inclusive option (T3) or the most sustainable option (T4).

Experimental design

Five-arm between-subjects survey experiment on Prolific (US adults, N =
3,750). Participants imagine a catered event and choose between a plant-based
and a chicken sandwich under one of five randomly assigned choice formats: no
default, plant-based pre-selected, plant-based opt-out checkbox, pre-selected
plus an inclusivity message, or pre-selected plus an environmental message.
Each format is evaluated on two co-primary outcomes: plant-based uptake,
tested against a pre-registered minimum gain over control, and dissatisfaction
with the chosen meal, tested against a pre-registered acceptability ceiling.
Analyses are linear probability models with HC2 robust standard errors
(unadjusted primary, covariate-adjusted robustness) and 95% Wilson intervals
for dissatisfaction rates, with alpha = .01 for significance tests. The
analytic sample is completed responses passing a pre-treatment attention
check, the sole exclusion, applied before any analysis. A pre-analysis plan
containing the full analysis pipeline, run end-to-end on simulated data, is
attached.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer randomization: a randomizer element in the Qualtrics survey flow presents the five arms evenly; assignment is stored in an embedded-data field.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
3,750 individuals (individual-level randomization; no clustering).
Observations
3,750 US adults recruited on Prolific; approximately 3,560 expected in the analytic sample after attention-check exclusions.
Arms
750 individuals per arm: control, T1 (pre-selected default), T2 (opt-out checkbox), T3 (inclusivity framing), T4 (environmental framing); approximately 712 per arm in the analytic sample.
Primary outcomes
(1) Choice of the plant-based meal (chose_veg). (2) Dissatisfaction with the chosen meal (dissat_chosen).
Secondary outcomes
Dissatisfaction with the available meal choices; dissatisfaction with how the choices were presented; manipulation check (reported meal matches recorded choice); perceived descriptive norms (estimated percentage of participants choosing the same meal). Pre-specified exploratory analyses: pooled framed defaults (T3 + T4) vs. the bare default (T1) on both primary outcomes; cross-condition comparisons among treatment arms; dietary identity coded from open text; heterogeneous treatment effects by gender, education, and age.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords