Effects of Physical Characteristics of Meeting Spaces on Discussion Activity, Psychological States, and Autonomic Nervous System Responses

How to cite

Asakawa, Shinsuke. 2026. "Effects of Physical Characteristics of Meeting Spaces on Discussion Activity, Psychological States, and Autonomic Nervous System Responses." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019097. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19097-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shinsuke Asakawa*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019097
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19097-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-06 – 2027-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J24, D91, M54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19097

Abstract

This study is a field experiment that identifies the causal effect of the physical characteristics of meeting rooms — acoustic privacy and visual openness — on in-meeting speech behavior, subjective psychological states, and autonomic nervous system responses. The intervention consists of six meeting-room conditions that differ in their combination of acoustic and visual privacy (Panel, Frosted Glass, Glass, Open, Frame, and Louver). These conditions are randomly assigned to recurring meeting groups within a firm at the meeting-group-by-week level, in a crossover design.
The primary estimands compare each of the five alternative room conditions with the Panel room, which serves as the pre-specified reference condition. Because the six conditions are not a fully factorial manipulation of acoustic and visual privacy, the study does not interpret any single pairwise comparison as isolating the effect of acoustic privacy or visual privacy alone; condition-specific treatment effects are reported as the primary analysis.
Primary outcomes are the time series of heart rate variability indicators (RMSSD and the LF/HF ratio) from the start of each meeting, together with communication outcomes — speech volume and turn-taking intensity — derived from speech-to-text data. Secondary outcomes are subjective evaluations collected via a post-meeting questionnaire. A time-series analysis interacting treatment with elapsed time since meeting start is also used to examine the timing and persistence of effects (time-series dynamics). This study aims to generate evidence, useful for both practice and policy, on the causal effect of physical workplace design on employee communication and well-being.

Intervention

The intervention consists of assigning one of six workplace meeting-room conditions that differ in acoustic privacy and visual openness: Panel, Frosted Glass, Glass, Open, Frame, and Louver. Meeting groups continue their regularly scheduled meetings under the assigned room conditions. Room conditions are randomly assigned to each meeting group on a weekly basis using a crossover design. Aside from the physical meeting environment, no aspect of meeting operation, agenda, or participant composition is intentionally altered.

Experimental design

This study is a crossover field experiment conducted among recurring meeting groups within a firm, in which six spatial conditions (Panel, Frosted Glass, Glass, Open, Frame, and Louver) are randomly assigned at the meeting-group-by-week level. Each group is assigned a pre-specified order of the six conditions before the study begins (the order differs across groups), and conditions are fixed at the group-week level. Groups enter the study on different dates under a phased rollout, so a group's first treatment week may start mid-week. After a group enters the study, conditions are updated weekly, typically on Mondays.

The cluster is defined as the meeting group. The number of groups actually participating may increase over time as additional groups become operationally ready; eight groups are the planned upper bound.

Panel (the condition with the highest acoustic and visual privacy) serves as the reference condition, and the difference from each of the other five conditions is the primary object of estimation. The six conditions are not a fully factorial manipulation of acoustic and visual privacy, so the study does not interpret any single pairwise comparison as isolating the effect of acoustic privacy or visual privacy alone. Condition-specific treatment effects constitute the primary analysis; an aggregate comparison after reclassifying conditions by acoustic and visual openness is treated as an exploratory secondary analysis.

The primary analysis is restricted to recurring meetings with at least 3 in-person participants, an in-person participation rate of at least 70%, and an attendance rate of at least 80%. Meetings operated as standing hybrid meetings (routinely including remote participants) are excluded. For groups that meet more often than once per week, the primary analysis uses one pre-specified representative meeting per treatment week, in order to align the unit of observation with the weekly treatment assignment. Report-only meetings and unusually short meetings are excluded under pre-specified, quantitative definitions (rather than post hoc judgment); full definitions are provided in the Pre-Analysis Plan.

Estimation uses a two-way fixed-effects model with individual and week fixed effects, with condition-dummy coefficients identifying each condition's difference from the reference. In addition, a time-series fixed-effects model interacting treatment with elapsed time since meeting start (5-minute bins during the meeting, 10-minute bins afterward) is used to examine the timing and persistence of effects. Full estimation equations, the control-variable list, and sensitivity analyses are detailed in the Pre-Analysis Plan.

Design details

Randomization method
The research team conducted computer-generated randomization before the intervention. Each meeting group was assigned a pre-specified randomized sequence of the six meeting-room conditions using a computer-generated random-number algorithm.
Randomization unit
Meeting group (cluster), with treatment assigned at the meeting-group-by-week level.
Clusters
8 meeting groups (groups with substantial membership changes will be treated as new groups.)
Observations
Approximately 150 eligible meeting sessions. The primary analysis sample is defined at the meeting-session level, where one session is one representative meeting for a given meeting group in a given treatment week. Physiological outcomes are observed at the participant-by-minute level within each eligible session. Separately, the total number of meetings actually held across the 8 target groups during the study period (the raw count of occurrences, including all weekly occurrences for daily groups) is approximately 390; this is distinct from the primary analysis observation unit, one representative meeting per treatment week (see Sections 3 and 5 of the Pre-Analysis Plan). The total number of sessions is a planning estimate based on each group's meeting frequency and phased entry into the study, and may vary due to personnel changes, staggered group start dates, and meeting feasibility. The number of observations per condition depends on randomized assignment and operational feasibility; perfectly balanced allocation is not required.
Arms
Approximately 25 eligible meeting sessions per room condition: * Panel: approximately 25 sessions * Frosted Glass: approximately 25 sessions * Glass: approximately 25 sessions * Open: approximately 25 sessions * Frame: approximately 25 sessions * Louver: approximately 25 sessions The final allocation may vary slightly because of staggered group entry, personnel changes, and operational constraints.
Primary outcomes
1. Minute-level RMSSD during each meeting. 2. Minute-level LF/HF ratio during each meeting. 3. Total speaking volume per meeting. 4. Turn-taking intensity (speaker turns per minute). 5. Speech inequality across participants (Gini coefficient of speaking volume). 6. Average sentiment score of meeting utterances.
Secondary outcomes
1. Subjective evaluation of external sound. 2. Subjective evaluation of visual distraction. 3. Subjective concentration. 4. Psychological safety (concern about being observed by others). 5. Meeting satisfaction. 6. Perceived liveliness of discussion.
Sponsors
Name: Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS), Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (KAKENHI) Location: Japan Url: https://kaken.nii.ac.jp/en/grant/KAKENHI-PROJECT-25K16706/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords