What Drives Citizen Demand for Pollution Enforcement?

How to cite

Nakamura, Shotaro; Nasim, Sanval. 2026. "What Drives Citizen Demand for Pollution Enforcement?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019092. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19092-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shotaro Nakamura* , Sanval Nasim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019092
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19092-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-10 – 2026-09-30
Countries
Pakistan (Lahore, Punjab)
JEL codes
C93, D83, Q53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19092

Abstract

This pre-analysis plan describes the design and planned analysis of an experimental module embedded in a pilot survey in Lahore, Pakistan. The module investigates what drives citizen demand for pollution enforcement and how information about pollution sources shapes that demand. The design leverages legitimate scientific disagreement about pollution source attribution in Lahore: respondents are randomized into one of three arms---two information treatment arms that present findings from competing scientific studies emphasizing different pollution sources, and a pure control arm that receives no information. Pre-registered primary outcomes are (i) an incentivized donation to a public good (air purifiers for schools), (ii) signing a customizable enforcement letter to the Urban Unit, (iii) belief updating about pollution sources (the information mechanism), and (iv) stated enforcement preferences across pollution sources. A contingent-valuation willingness-to-pay module and additional mechanism items are analyzed as secondary outcomes. The study is a pilot conducted in a single union council of Lahore (300), intended to assess comprehension, field protocols, and effect-size magnitudes ahead of a separately funded scale-up built around high-frequency, ground-monitor-based source apportionment.

Intervention

Respondents (urban working-class adults in Lahore) are individually randomized into one of three arms. In the two information-treatment arms, an enumerator reads a short, factually accurate statement summarizing a scientific study of air pollution in areas including Lahore and then shows the respondent, on the enumerator's tablet, a bar chart giving the estimated contribution ("parts out of 100") of four pollution sources - vehicle emissions, factories and industry, crop burning, and other sources. Arm 1 presents a vehicle-emphasizing study (vehicles approx. 83%); Arm 2 presents a multi-source study (vehicles approx. 43%, industry approx. 37%, crop burning approx. 20%). Arm 3 is a pure control that receives no information about pollution sources. The two statements exploit genuine scientific disagreement in published source-apportionment studies; no deception is used.

Experimental design

A three-arm, individually randomized, in-person survey experiment among urban working-class households in Lahore, conducted as a pilot in a single union council ahead of a planned scale-up. After eliciting prior beliefs about pollution sources, respondents are randomized to a vehicle-emphasizing information arm, a multi-source information arm, or a pure control, and then complete incentivized and stated outcome modules. The primary comparison is any information vs. no information; the secondary comparison is vehicle-emphasizing vs. multi-source information.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by computer (Stata, with a preset seed), at the individual respondent level, stratified by GPS coordinate pin; assignments are preloaded into SurveyCTO.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent (household). There is a single level of randomization.
Clusters
not clustered
Observations
300 respondents (target), approx. 100 per arm.
Arms
Approx. 100 Arm 1 (vehicle-emphasizing), approx. 100 Arm 2 (multi-source), approx. 100 Arm 3 (pure control). Primary estimand pools Arms 1-2 (n approx. 200) vs. Arm 3 (n approx. 100).
Primary outcomes
(1) Incentivized donation to a public good - the amount (PKR 0-500) donated to air purifiers for schools; (2) signing a customizable enforcement letter to the Urban Unit (binary); (3) belief updating about pollution sources - the change in the stated share attributed to each source from pre- to post-treatment; (4) stated enforcement preferences across pollution sources (the top-priority source and the full ranking of the four sources).
Secondary outcomes
Contingent-valuation willingness to pay for source-specific enforcement and monitoring (four double-bounded vignettes); the enforcement priority written into the letter and whether it was personalized; belief confidence; perceived state responsiveness; trust and information channels; enforcement awareness; and exploratory fairness and green-sticker items.
Sponsors
Name: International Growth Centre Location: London, UK Url: https://www.theigc.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords