Employee Reactions to Company Policy Change: The Effect of Policy Direction and Managerial Justification
How to cite
Xiong, Xiaomei (Grazia); Libby, Theresa; Guo, Lan. 2026. "Employee Reactions to Company Policy Change: The Effect of Policy Direction and Managerial Justification." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019083. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19083-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study examines how employees respond to organizational policy changes and the justifications managers provide for those changes.
A managerial pre-study was conducted to obtain managers’ policy decisions and accompanying justifications. Following completion of the managerial pre-study, we have revised the implementation plan for the employee experiments.
The revised employee experiment uses a 2 (Policy Change: Abandon vs. Double Down) × 2 (Justification: Business vs. Moral) between-subjects design in the context of an organizational sustainability policy. The study examines how the direction of a policy change and the manager’s justification jointly influence employee responses, including honesty and turnover intentions.
The revised employee experiment is limited to the Sustainability context only following evidence from the managerial pre-study that decisions differed substantially across policy domains, suggesting that the DEI context may introduce additional domain-specific considerations beyond the theoretical mechanism of interest. To provide a cleaner confirmatory test of our hypotheses, we will first conduct the employee experiment using the Sustainability context only.
This amendment was made before any employee-experiment data were collected or observed.
Intervention
The project consists of two online studies conducted through Prolific. In Study 1 (already collected), participants with managerial experience make decisions about organizational initiatives and provide a justification for those decisions. In Study 2, working adults receive information based on decisions made by Study 1 participants and complete an incentivized reporting task. Participants’ decisions have real financial consequences for themselves and, where applicable, a matched participant.
Experimental design
The revised employee experiment uses a 2 (Policy Change: Abandon vs. Double Down) × 2 (Justification: Business vs. Moral) between-subjects design. Participants will be individually and randomly assigned to one of the four conditions. All conditions concern an organizational sustainability policy.
The originally registered policy-domain factor—Sustainability versus DEI—has been removed from the revised employee experiment. This change was made following completion of the managerial pre-study and before the collection or observation of any employee-experiment data. The managerial pre-study indicated substantial differences in managers’ decisions across the two domains, raising the possibility that the DEI context introduces domain-specific considerations beyond the theoretical mechanism of interest.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.