Scaling Up Information to Expedite Conciliation

How to cite

Sadka, Joyce; Woodruff, Christopher. 2026. "Scaling Up Information to Expedite Conciliation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019075. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19075-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joyce Sadka* , Christopher Woodruff

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019075
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19075-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2027-08-01 – 2028-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
K31, K41, K42, J52, J83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19075

Abstract

This study evaluates whether providing personalized statistical information can improve the resolution of labor disputes in Mexico’s Labor Conciliation Centers. In Mexico, workers who are dismissed must seek severance payments through a mandatory conciliation process before filing a lawsuit. However, many workers and firms have limited information about likely case outcomes, expected settlement amounts, and the benefits of reaching an agreement quickly. This lack of information may contribute to unrealistic expectations, reliance on costly legal intermediaries, and lower settlement rates.
The intervention provides workers, firms, and conciliators with information from a statistical calculator embedded in SINACOL, the national labor conciliation case management system used in most states of Mexico. The calculator uses historical administrative data from similar cases to generate personalized predictions about the probability of settlement and expected settlement amounts. The goal is to help parties form more realistic expectations and support fairer and faster dispute resolution.
The study will be implemented in Mexico City and several additional Mexican states. Randomization will occur at the day level. Depending on the assigned day, workers may receive the calculator information when they file their conciliation request, workers and firms may receive it at the beginning of the hearing with an explanation from the conciliator, both forms of communication may be used, or the case may proceed under the standard process. The study will measure effects on settlement rates, settlement amounts, case outcomes, understanding of the information, satisfaction with the process, and subsequent intentions to file a lawsuit.
The project builds on prior experimental evidence showing that statistical information can increase settlement in labor disputes without reducing worker compensation. By testing different ways of delivering this information through an existing public case management system, the study aims to inform how labor authorities can scale the intervention effectively and sustainably

Intervention

This intervention provides personalized statistical information to parties in labor conciliation cases in Mexico. The information is generated by a statistical calculator embedded in SINACOL, the case management system used by most Labor Conciliation Centers. Using historical administrative data from similar cases, the calculator provides information on likely case outcomes, including the probability of reaching a settlement and expected settlement amounts.
The intervention is designed to help workers, firms, and conciliators form more realistic expectations during the conciliation process. By reducing information gaps about typical outcomes in similar labor disputes, the intervention aims to support faster, fairer, and more informed dispute resolution before cases proceed to labor court.

Experimental design

This study is a randomized evaluation of an informational intervention in Mexico’s Labor Conciliation Centers. The intervention provides parties in labor disputes with personalized statistical information generated from historical administrative data on similar cases. The information is intended to help workers and firms form more realistic expectations about likely case outcomes and settlement amounts.
The evaluation will be implemented through SINACOL, the case management system used by Labor Conciliation Centers in participating Mexican states. Randomization will occur at the day level. Depending on the assignment, cases initiated or heard on a given day may receive the statistical information at different moments of the conciliation process, or may proceed under the standard conciliation process.
The study will use administrative data from SINACOL to measure settlement rates, settlement amounts, and final case outcomes. Survey data collected through SINACOL will be used to measure understanding of the information, satisfaction with the process, and related secondary outcomes. The study is designed to inform how labor authorities can most effectively incorporate statistical information into routine conciliation procedures.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in office by a computer. The research team will randomly assign eligible implementation days to treatment arms using a reproducible computer-generated randomization procedure. Randomization will be at the day level, with days assigned to the control condition or to one of the calculator delivery conditions before the start of the intervention period. Treatment status will then be implemented through SINACOL according to the pre-specified assignment schedule.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization will be the day. Eligible implementation days in each participating Labor Conciliation Center will be randomly assigned to one of the experimental arms. All eligible cases filed or heard on a day assigned to a given arm will receive the corresponding condition according to the pre-specified treatment schedule. There is no individual-level randomization.
Clusters
The planned number of clusters is 180 implementation days, with approximately 45 days assigned to each of the four experimental arms.
Observations
Approximately 135,000 conciliation requests/cases.
Arms
Control group: 45 implementation days, approximately 33,750 conciliation requests. Treatment 1: 45 implementation days, approximately 33,750 conciliation requests. Treatment 2: 45 implementation days, approximately 33,750 conciliation requests. Treatment 3: 45 implementation days, approximately 33,750 conciliation requests. Total: 180 implementation days and approximately 135,000 conciliation requests.
Primary outcomes
1. Settlement reached during the conciliation process: an indicator equal to one if the worker and firm reach a settlement agreement before the case proceeds to labor court, and zero otherwise. 2. Settlement amount: the monetary compensation agreed upon in the settlement, measured both in Mexican pesos and in daily wages. We will analyze this outcome conditional on settlement and, in secondary specifications, unconditionally assigning zero to cases without settlement. 3. Case outcome at the end of the conciliation stage: whether the case ends in settlement, is dropped, or otherwise proceeds toward litigation (no conciliation). These outcomes will be measured using administrative data from SINACOL, Mexico’s labor conciliation case management system. The main endpoint is the final recorded outcome of the conciliation process for each case. The central hypothesis is that providing statistical information will increase settlement rates without reducing the compensation workers receive in settled cases.
Secondary outcomes
1. Understanding of the calculator information: whether workers report understanding the information provided by the statistical calculator, including the predicted likelihood of settlement and expected settlement amount. 2. Knowledge of labor rights and conciliation procedures: workers' knowledge about severance pay, the conciliation process, and whether legal representation is required during conciliation. 3. Satisfaction with the conciliation process and outcome: workers' reported satisfaction with the information received, the hearing process, and the final case outcome. 4. Intention to file a lawsuit: among cases that do not settle during conciliation, whether the worker reports intending to proceed to labor court. 5. Use of legal or other representatives: whether the worker is accompanied by a "person of confidence" during the conciliation process, and whether this person is a licensed lawyer. Legally, workers are not allowed to bring legal representatives that are active during the hearings, but they can be accompanied by them. 6. Hearing attendance and procedural compliance: whether workers and firms attend the scheduled hearing and whether the case proceeds according to the expected administrative timeline. 7. Post-conciliation labor market outcomes: workers' employment status, wages, and job search activity after the conciliation process, when available through survey data.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords