Task divisions in teams and the (in)efficiency of gender stereotypes: The impact of communication
How to cite
Bieberstein, Frauke von; Feess, Eberhard; Lorz, Oliver; Tibitanzl, Frank. 2026. "Task divisions in teams and the (in)efficiency of gender stereotypes: The impact of communication." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019072. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19072-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We analyze if and how gender stereotypes influence the (in)efficiency of task divisions, and if and how this is moderated by communication. In Part I, all participants are incentivized by piece rates to perform two tasks, one stereotyped to males (identifying rotated pictures) and one to females (recognizing emotions). Individual performance for each of the two tasks is measured by the number of correct answers in a given period of time. Participants are not informed about their performance. In Part II, subjects are paired after they have performed both tasks. Each pair consists of one male and one female. Each pair has to determine the efficient combination of tasks performances. For that purpose, both members vote independently whether the male’s performance in the rotation task should be combined with the female’s performance in the emotion recognition task, or vice versa. If both vote for the efficient task division. i.e., the one that maximizes the sum of correct answers, both of them receive a bonus. If exactly one of them votes for the efficient task division, both of them receive the bonus with 50% probability. If none of them votes for the efficient division of task performances, they do not get the bonus. There are two treatments: In treatment N, participants vote directly after they are paired. Treatment C (communication) is identical to treatment N with the only difference that subjects can, before they submit their votes independently, communicate for two minutes in a chat window.
Intervention
Subjects are paired after they have performed the two tasks described in the abstract. They are not informed about their performance. Each pair consists of one male and one female (mixed-gender pairs). Both members of a team vote independently whether the male’s number of correct answers in the rotation task and the number of the female’s correct answers in the emotion recognition determines the sum of their correct answers, or vice versa. If both vote for the efficient task division that maximizes the sum of their correct answers, both of them receive a bonus. If exactly one of them votes for the efficient task division, both of them receive the bonus with 50% probability. If none of them votes for the efficient task division, they do not get the bonus. If both task divisions yield the same sum of correct answers, both divisions are treated as efficient.
There are two treatments:
In treatment N, participants vote directly after they are paired.
Treatment C (Communication): Identical to Treatment N, except that pair members can communicate fvia a chat window before voting.
Thus, the intervention varies whether communication is allowed prior to the individual votes on the task division that determines whether subjects receive the bonus or not.
We have three main hypotheses. In all three hypotheses we control for efficiency gains, which we define as the difference in the number of correct answers with the efficient and the inefficient allocation of task performances.
H1. Stereotype-consistent efficient task divisions are more likely to be chosen than counter-stereotypical efficient task divisions.
H2. Communication increases the probability of choosing efficient task divisions.
H3 (if we find support for H1 and H2). Communication reduces the impact of stereotypes on efficient task divisions.
In addition, we have the following secondary hypotheses:
H4. The probability of choosing efficient task divisions increases with efficiency gains.
H5. Communication increases the accuracy of estimating the partner’s performance.
Experimental design
The online experiment follows a between-subject design structured in two parts. In Part I all participants perform the same two tasks, one task stereotyped to males (identifying rotated pictures) and one to females (recognizing emotions). Participants are not informed about their performance. After each task, participants answer four self-evaluation questions about their own performance and one question on performance differences of men and women at the task.
In Part II, participants are paired and these pairs are randomly assigned to one of the two treatments explained above. At the end of the instructions for Part II, we ask two comprehension questions. Participants who answer more than one question incorrectly, cannot proceed to Part II.
After the actual experiment, we elicit the participants’ beliefs about their own and their partner’s performance in both tasks.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.