Referral information and persistence in multi-stage processes
How to cite
Munoz, Manuel. 2026. "Referral information and persistence in multi-stage processes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019061. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19061-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This online field experiment studies whether information about referral status encourages or discourages persistence in a multi-stage application process for a talent recognition program at a university in Colombia. Eligible students are invited to apply for the award. The application is a three-stage assessment process in which the top 25 percent of applicants receive a certificate of excellence and a subset of certificate recipients receive monetary prizes. Before invitations are sent, faculty members and eligible students nominate up to four eligible students through online surveys. Students are randomized within three mutually exclusive referral-status blocks: students nominated by faculty, students nominated by peers, and students who were not nominated. Within these blocks, the experiment varies whether students are informed about being nominated, not informed about being nominated, or, among non-nominated students, informed that referrals were collected but that they were not nominated. The primary outcomes measure persistence: a binary indicator for completing all three stages by the final deadline and a continuous measure of the number of stages completed. Secondary analyses use survey, assessment, and administrative data to study beliefs, confidence, assessment performance, and the composition of students who persist.
Intervention
Eligible students at a Colombian university are invited to apply to a talent recognition program. The application process consists of three weekly stages, each requiring approximately 20 minutes to complete. Before invitations are sent, faculty members and eligible students nominate up to four eligible students through online surveys. Students are assigned to treatment conditions based on their referral status. Students nominated by faculty are randomized into being informed or not informed that a faculty member nominated them. Students nominated only by peers are randomized into being informed or not informed that a peer nominated them. Students who were not nominated are randomized into receiving no referral information, being informed that faculty referrals were collected but that they were not nominated by faculty, or being informed that peer referrals were collected but that they were not nominated by peers.
Experimental design
This study is an individual-level randomized field experiment among students eligible to apply to a university talent recognition program in Colombia. Before invitations are sent, faculty members and eligible students nominate students whom they believe should be invited to participate. Eligible students are then randomized within referral-status blocks that depend on whether they were nominated by faculty, nominated only by peers, or not nominated. The intervention varies whether students are informed about their referral status when invited to apply. All students receive the same core information about the opportunity, including the three-stage application process, expected time cost, deadlines, selection criteria, the certificate awarded to the top 25 percent of applicants, and the possibility of receiving a monetary prize. The study measures whether referral-status information affects persistence in the application process.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.